Active Users:1121 Time:22/11/2024 03:16:13 PM
Re: That is the most rational argument put forth thus far, HOWEVER Dan Send a noteboard - 17/11/2012 08:07:19 PM
Doctors don't go around clubbing terminal stage IV cancer patients in the head like a baby seal either.

THe stage IV cancer patient has just as much chance of survival as that fetus. In fact there is MORE rational for the euthanasia of the cancer patient as at least they can ask to be killed, while the child can not. The death of the mother was NOT a certainty. The death of the child, while extremely likely bordering on certainty, was not a certainty. While the child and mother were alive, the moral obligation of the physicians was to do everything they could to save them BOTH.


Source on the relative chances on the survival of "stage IV cancer" and a 17 week old fetus being miscarried.

Further, there are no analogous situations where one can apply what you said. If a Stage 4, terminal cancer patient's living were putting an otherwise healthy person in immanent mortal danger, AND was not sentient, then your analogy would hold.

So, maybe: two conjoined twins, one of which has inoperable, malignant cancer spread too far but otherwise treatable, that has rendered him comatose, and the other twin has, say, stage 2. And, removing the twins would bisect the organs in such a way as one would have to die for the other to live. In that case, yes, almost every doctor would make the call to euthanize the terminal twin to treat the other twin.

One point of note, Ireland, with its strict no abortion law, has a lower instance of maternal death than England which allows elective abortion.

It is real simple, if you don't like the laws in Ireland, don't live there.


This is what betrays you as an Internet Fuckwit. You had a valid, if specious argument above, but then you go full retard and just spit out useless truisms unrelated to your earlier point. Because you see, Fuckwit, laws can be changed if they're unjust or lead to unjust deaths. Good luck comprehending that.
Reply to message
woman dies after doctors deny her a life-saving abortion - 14/11/2012 06:58:31 PM 1304 Views
this is so terribly sad. keeping abortions legal is important. *NM* - 14/11/2012 07:09:00 PM 247 Views
Maybe this is more a testament to the quality of care in that hospital than an arguemnt for abortion *NM* - 15/11/2012 01:49:00 PM 259 Views
Can you elaborate? - 16/11/2012 04:07:48 PM 498 Views
Do you have access to her medical charts? - 16/11/2012 08:44:45 PM 505 Views
Statistically speaking... - 15/11/2012 07:03:51 PM 529 Views
Where did you get your statistics from? - 15/11/2012 09:19:29 PM 765 Views
Psst. - 15/11/2012 09:43:35 PM 559 Views
I'm pretty sure his 0.3% figure comes from - 15/11/2012 10:01:29 PM 476 Views
That would certainly change the difference between the numbers. - 15/11/2012 10:07:42 PM 540 Views
Re: Statistically speaking... - 15/11/2012 10:56:35 PM 512 Views
Where's the due process? - 15/11/2012 11:35:39 PM 591 Views
First, prove that the fetus is a "ONE". - 16/11/2012 04:14:34 PM 468 Views
That argument is specious - 16/11/2012 08:36:07 PM 482 Views
But you cannot call another living person an "environment." Only for parasites. - 16/11/2012 10:16:18 PM 449 Views
Yes I can, look up the word environment - 17/11/2012 11:49:55 AM 582 Views
No, I do not accept the risk of pregnancy. - 20/11/2012 01:41:07 PM 461 Views
Re: No, I do not accept the risk of pregnancy. - 20/11/2012 03:59:19 PM 471 Views
well said - 20/11/2012 05:27:11 PM 568 Views
I agree, but it does not matter. - 16/11/2012 08:26:17 PM 463 Views
Win some, lose some - 15/11/2012 11:29:32 PM 623 Views
In other words, if you don't want to die, become a lesbian. *NM* - 16/11/2012 04:16:23 PM 261 Views
stop calling women whores - 16/11/2012 04:55:49 PM 554 Views
Some facts for you - from the article Stephen linked in his reply above, and from general knowledge. - 16/11/2012 09:38:32 PM 601 Views
That is the most rational argument put forth thus far, HOWEVER - 17/11/2012 07:06:58 PM 532 Views
Wow. - 17/11/2012 07:28:23 PM 554 Views
Re: That is the most rational argument put forth thus far, HOWEVER - 17/11/2012 08:07:19 PM 650 Views

Reply to Message