Active Users:1135 Time:22/11/2024 07:57:17 PM
Re: As an addendum to what Greg wrote: Rebekah Send a noteboard - 20/03/2010 02:36:36 PM
1. After a brief scan through several articles, I've not seen the answer to this, so: Are Strelnikov and the foresty chap based on real people?

With respect to Strel'nikov, the question is a very contentious one. Some people think he is just an anti-hero (Antipov, his real last name, is a clue to this), who fights Zhivago's "life" with executions (Strel'nikov is based on the word for shooting in Russian). Others for some bizarre reason associate him with Sokol'nikov, who was a minor Bolshevik - I don't know why, though - everything about Sokol'nikov is different from who Strel'nikov is. The last name just sounds similar. Others think he is Marshal Tukhachevsky, executed by Stalin. Given Pasternak's protection by Stalin, many see Yevgraf as Stalin. The forest partisans are based on a variety of groups of red partisans that Pasternak researched and read about when he was living in Yekaterinburg in the Urals.


I guess that's why I couldn't find an answer then. :P


2. What social class is Yuri in? Couldn't work that out either.

Yuri's family seems to be a blend of lower nobility and the merchant class (the "kuptsy" ). The merchant class arose in the 18th Century and by the 19th Century many of them were fabulously wealthy. Their code of honor was paramount to them, and if they shook hands on something they would abide by the terms of the agreement as scrupulously as if they had signed a written contract. As they became extremely wealthy, many of them married into impoverished noble families to increase their pedigree (a practice common all over Europe at the time). It seems that the Zhivagos on the father's side were kuptsy, and the mother's side were impoverished nobles. The Gromekos are the exact same way - the combination of the factories and country homes shows a mixture of enterprise and privilege.


OK. I wasn't sure because his family had owned property and didn't know if they were an equivalent of the landed gentry in England or similar. So that all makes sense now.

Greg is completely right that by today's standards (and indeed, by Soviet standards) they would be considered part of the intelligentsia.


~nods~


3. And why, when his family was essentially exiled, would he have had to get permission to leave Russia?

That question shows that you don't really know Russia well. Russia has always controlled the movement of its people. The peasants were tied to the land, and after the Revolution the Bolsheviks enslaved them once again by instituting a system of internal passports and not giving them to the peasants. Without an internal passport, it was impossible to board a train or take a commuter bus to a different town or stay in a hotel.

Even if a person had an internal passport, however, they still needed an external passport to travel. Getting an external passport was a very difficult process, and even now it can be complicated and frustrating. In the Soviet period, however, it raised questions about loyalty and people had to prove they were good Party members or that they were at least committed to Soviet ideals, to get a passport. Even with an external passport, it was not possible to leave the country without travel papers. It was almost impossible to get these travel papers - trips were viewed with extreme suspicion, even to places like East Germany, KGB minders were attached to groups to spy on them and keep them from fleeing and upon their return they were forced to detail every hour of their trip and explain any suspicious contacts they might have had. If the authorities were not happy about the responses, they might never give someone travel papers ever again.

The Soviet Union did not have a habit of exiling dissidents until the 1970s. Prior to that time, it was considered dangerous to let potential enemies out of the country, where they could publish the truth about what life in the Soviet Union was like. As a result, internal exile (or, in the 1930s, summary execution) was preferred to giving travel papers to people critical of the Soviet system.


You're right. I don't know much about Russia at all. Is it a translator's fault, then, that the version I read said Tonya etc had been exiled?
*MySmiley*

Outside of a dog, a book is man's best friend. Inside of a dog it's too dark to read. - Groucho Marx
Reply to message
So, let's talk about Doctor Zhivago. - 15/03/2010 12:51:09 PM 1556 Views
I liked it a lot. - 15/03/2010 03:24:34 PM 820 Views
So far, so good - 15/03/2010 03:58:44 PM 807 Views
There are lots of good quotes. - 15/03/2010 09:20:26 PM 671 Views
I have finally finished it. - 22/03/2010 12:31:24 AM 833 Views
There will be more later. Much more. So lets start at the beginning. - 15/03/2010 04:22:15 PM 740 Views
... I'm clearly lacking in braincells. - 15/03/2010 05:03:35 PM 834 Views
... yes, you moved to scotland? *NM* - 15/03/2010 05:42:21 PM 318 Views
It's not contagious! - 15/03/2010 05:47:41 PM 666 Views
It probably is. Don't worry, we still like you! *NM* - 15/03/2010 09:55:07 PM 322 Views
I didn't notice the Anna Karenina connection. That's a good point. - 15/03/2010 09:26:41 PM 772 Views
Yes. Perhaps we should tell the non-Russian speakers/readers that the name of the protagonist, - 15/03/2010 10:22:39 PM 877 Views
Zhivago is the Church Slavonic genitive singular of живой (zhivoi), "living" - 15/03/2010 11:18:23 PM 723 Views
I knew those - 15/03/2010 11:22:02 PM 815 Views
I thought this was a great read, and I'm sure I've missed a lot, which will make a reread good too. - 15/03/2010 05:16:19 PM 871 Views
On balance, there IS a love story. Just not quite the one that most people think. - 15/03/2010 09:34:20 PM 777 Views
I noticed that as well - 15/03/2010 09:42:04 PM 857 Views
There is a lot of Christian eschatology, too - 15/03/2010 09:46:59 PM 772 Views
Yes - 15/03/2010 11:23:23 PM 912 Views
My initial thoughts - 15/03/2010 06:02:21 PM 821 Views
Re: My initial thoughts - 15/03/2010 08:54:15 PM 748 Views
Which idioms were you talking about? - 15/03/2010 09:43:09 PM 799 Views
Re: Which idioms were you talking about? - 15/03/2010 10:07:23 PM 778 Views
The names are not quite as hard as it may seem at first - 15/03/2010 09:41:06 PM 761 Views
There appears to be a lull, so some background - How many of you have read anything about - 15/03/2010 08:19:07 PM 743 Views
This is my first novel in that genre, fiction or non. - 15/03/2010 08:22:04 PM 662 Views
I've read bits & pieces. - 15/03/2010 08:33:41 PM 785 Views
Ok, since you're interested, here is some "light" reading for you. Approach with caution. - 15/03/2010 08:47:42 PM 910 Views
Interestingly, I'm seeing parallels now that I'm reading Gibbon. - 15/03/2010 09:53:15 PM 779 Views
Koenker was mine for Soviet history. - 15/03/2010 10:08:40 PM 1053 Views
Finally got around to reading this. Thanks for sharing. *NM* - 22/03/2010 04:45:24 PM 318 Views
You're welcome. *NM* - 22/03/2010 05:14:26 PM 277 Views
I knew a bit about it. - 15/03/2010 08:36:20 PM 883 Views
Fiction or non-fiction? - 15/03/2010 09:21:04 PM 915 Views
Do you mean Ten Days that Shook the World by John Reed? - 15/03/2010 09:54:34 PM 765 Views
Ten...I was typing from memories of close to 15 years ago - 15/03/2010 10:57:05 PM 762 Views
Either, though specifically I was thinking of non-fiction. - 15/03/2010 10:11:52 PM 802 Views
That's what I was thinking of when I read it - 15/03/2010 10:59:36 PM 805 Views
Enough to understand everything easily enough. - 21/04/2010 01:03:54 AM 634 Views
My own personal thoughts on Doctor Zhivago - 15/03/2010 11:44:05 PM 999 Views
This review has been helpful so far for me. - 23/03/2010 11:39:51 PM 716 Views
Essay I just finished writing on the book - 16/03/2010 01:26:23 AM 1125 Views
I'm really enjoying it. - 16/03/2010 03:05:25 AM 805 Views
Hey, if I can come late to the party, so can you. *NM* - 21/04/2010 01:04:15 AM 244 Views
I'm still sailing through it - 16/03/2010 09:25:34 PM 800 Views
Some questions. - 19/03/2010 08:27:38 AM 719 Views
Class can be tricky given the Russian context. - 19/03/2010 05:09:14 PM 895 Views
Grand. Thanks for the answers. - 20/03/2010 02:33:18 PM 741 Views
As an addendum to what Greg wrote: - 19/03/2010 05:56:56 PM 768 Views
Re: As an addendum to what Greg wrote: - 20/03/2010 02:36:36 PM 787 Views
No, Tonya was exiled. It was a fortune of timing. - 20/03/2010 05:22:44 PM 787 Views
The Possessed: Adventures with Russian Books and the People Who Read Them - 21/03/2010 05:34:03 PM 817 Views
It looks a bit strained to me. - 22/03/2010 03:28:34 AM 707 Views
So far the reviews are pretty glowing, as are the Amazon reviewers. - 22/03/2010 01:44:19 PM 815 Views
In other news, I read about 100 pages of The Island at the Center of the World. - 22/03/2010 03:48:47 PM 756 Views
I figured that you would like it. - 22/03/2010 05:14:06 PM 881 Views

Reply to Message