I was just wondering if we could get some discussion here going on the subject of Jon's parents. I'm not widely familiar with the debate, so if it has been resolved or come to a near conclusive decision just smack me and tell me I am dumb. I personally suppose that the Rhaegar and Lyanna theory makes the most sense, and of course, would be the most dramatic so maybe I'm just hoping it will be that. The only problem is that I feel like that even with Ned's honor obsession, he would at the very least tell Cat, I mean, her honor obsession is definitely comprable and it would save young Jon from a lot of misery in his early years.
The evidence is just too strong - if it turns out to be otherwise, a lot of people are going to be pissed off. As to why Ned didn't tell Cat... hard to say. Perhaps he figures that's the safest way to make sure nobody finds out, including Jon - after all, if it got out while Jon was a kid, that would've made him a target.
Maybe, but I doubt Cat would have told anyone and I think Ned trusted her enough.
It doesn't matter how much he trusts her. It's not his secret, so his honor won't let him tell "just one person" or some such.
Even if he was absolutely sure she wouldn't tell anyone, it wouldn't be honorable to divulge the identities of Jon's parents.
And it's been quite a while since I've read the books, so I could be way off.
"And it breaks my heart to look around, and see the unimpressed; who can't believe the emperor is dressed"~Fastball
2-7-1
2-7-1
ASOIAF- Jon's parents
- 20/06/2010 04:09:27 PM
1127 Views
There is a consensus on that, yeah.
- 20/06/2010 04:58:40 PM
808 Views
Oh well, sorry.
- 20/06/2010 05:07:19 PM
892 Views
I don't think that reasoning entered into it.
- 20/06/2010 05:43:59 PM
787 Views
That is about what I was thinking. If I promise not to tell anybody something, that includes my
- 20/06/2010 10:59:10 PM
752 Views
Trusting Catelyn would have been idiotic, promises aside.
- 21/06/2010 04:35:32 PM
948 Views
ehhhh
- 22/06/2010 01:29:46 AM
784 Views
And WHAT rigid morality? Why don't you give me a clear cut example of his moral "rigidity"?
- 22/06/2010 04:31:35 PM
771 Views
Re: Trusting Catelyn would have been idiotic, promises aside.
- 04/07/2010 12:59:23 PM
877 Views
That is NOT moral rigidity! It was weakness and a huge moral failure!
- 05/07/2010 11:54:03 PM
881 Views
That is NOT moral rigidity! It was weakness and a huge moral failure!
- 05/07/2010 11:54:03 PM
881 Views