Professor Roberts reads "The Shadow Rising"
RugbyPlayingAshaman Send a noteboard - 02/04/2010 02:38:57 PM
This was the book that got me into the series in the first place. Up to that point, the longest series I had read in the fantasy genre was "Dragonlance". I do find myself agreeing with his critiques, even while I acknowledge that I was so young at that time that nostalgia still makes me give a nod of satisfaction to this book compared to the prior 3.
That being said, I did always gets a "theme park/amusement ride" feel from "The Wheel of Time" - I actually thought it was set in a Western, frontier American setting for the longest time due to this book's cover, and I was initially interested because it wasn't the same old quasi-medieval fantasy that other books were.
But most of us readers already know two main things about Robert Jordan's writing style, so I think long-time readers are willing to forgive weaknesses in these areas. Those two things are 1) He doesn't know how to write or convey a good villain without making them seem like super-villains from a comic book or "James Bond" movie complete with individualized quirks and gimmicks and 2) He doesn't know how or want to write sex scenes or romance scenes favoring a very conservative approach (ie: loads of scenes of women bathing, scenes of women getting naked and intimations that a male has an erection). But do we really want the romance scenes to resemble a Harlequin romance? Personally, I would have preferred him to concentrate on strengthening his battle scenes especially with the Power.
That being said, I did always gets a "theme park/amusement ride" feel from "The Wheel of Time" - I actually thought it was set in a Western, frontier American setting for the longest time due to this book's cover, and I was initially interested because it wasn't the same old quasi-medieval fantasy that other books were.
But most of us readers already know two main things about Robert Jordan's writing style, so I think long-time readers are willing to forgive weaknesses in these areas. Those two things are 1) He doesn't know how to write or convey a good villain without making them seem like super-villains from a comic book or "James Bond" movie complete with individualized quirks and gimmicks and 2) He doesn't know how or want to write sex scenes or romance scenes favoring a very conservative approach (ie: loads of scenes of women bathing, scenes of women getting naked and intimations that a male has an erection). But do we really want the romance scenes to resemble a Harlequin romance? Personally, I would have preferred him to concentrate on strengthening his battle scenes especially with the Power.
"Those who think they have no time for bodily exercise will sooner or later have to find time for illness."
This message last edited by RugbyPlayingAshaman on 19/04/2010 at 04:04:13 PM
Professor Roberts reads "The Shadow Rising"
02/04/2010 02:38:57 PM
- 1413 Views
Well, I was keeping his reviews in one thread way down below...
02/04/2010 09:44:42 PM
- 614 Views
More garbage.
02/04/2010 11:59:13 PM
- 737 Views