I support your view, with maybe a few comments to add...
Shannow Send a noteboard - 03/01/2010 02:58:05 PM
I'm tired of the Bell Curve, as I think the most likely answer is that RJ didn't actually know what a Bell Curve is in the true sense of the word.
Because a true Bell Curve simply does not fit the evidence so well presented by you in the above post.
In any case, I used to think that the 13 sister rule provided a minimum level for a woman like Dagian, but since the increased precision of circles was presented to us in scenes like the Cleansing I no longer hold that view. Therefore, I agree that someone like Dagian might well be less than one thirteenth as powerful as Rand, or at the very least, less than one thirteenth of the power required to overwhelm him in physical terms (remembering that you have to be MUCH stronger than someone to shield them if they are already holding the Power).
As for Egwene, I also place her at about 50. At most.
The quote about Egwene not standing a chance against Moghedien's strength, and the quote about Egwene, Lelaine and Romanda being doubtful of overpowering a single male Forsaken pretty much seals it for me.
We have to remember that three Black Ajah sisters can overwhelm Moghedien, according to Liandrin (if I recall the name correctly).
Therefore, if 3 can do so to Moghedien, then it seems likely that two can do so to Egwene at her full potential.
My only disagreement with your list is that I would place Nynaeve lower, at about 80. To me there is simply too much emphasis on Lanfear's great strength advantage over the other Forsaken for Nynaeve to be so close to her. I also don't think Alivia's "considerable strength advantage" over Nynaeve can be represented by a mere 10% on the strength scale.
Furthermore, I don't believe Alivia equals Lanfear - the most powerful woman of the Age of Legends by a margin big enough to leave her no doubt that she is exceeded by no woman.
In any case, the top individuals leave a lot of room for debate. But what seems incontrovertible to me is the placing of lesser characters like Egwene, Moiraine and the average Aes Sedai.
I don't really know how this notion of Egwene being 60-70% as strong as Lanfear crept up on us. It is not supported by the weight of evidence and should not be seriously considered, in my view.
Because a true Bell Curve simply does not fit the evidence so well presented by you in the above post.
In any case, I used to think that the 13 sister rule provided a minimum level for a woman like Dagian, but since the increased precision of circles was presented to us in scenes like the Cleansing I no longer hold that view. Therefore, I agree that someone like Dagian might well be less than one thirteenth as powerful as Rand, or at the very least, less than one thirteenth of the power required to overwhelm him in physical terms (remembering that you have to be MUCH stronger than someone to shield them if they are already holding the Power).
As for Egwene, I also place her at about 50. At most.
The quote about Egwene not standing a chance against Moghedien's strength, and the quote about Egwene, Lelaine and Romanda being doubtful of overpowering a single male Forsaken pretty much seals it for me.
We have to remember that three Black Ajah sisters can overwhelm Moghedien, according to Liandrin (if I recall the name correctly).
Therefore, if 3 can do so to Moghedien, then it seems likely that two can do so to Egwene at her full potential.
My only disagreement with your list is that I would place Nynaeve lower, at about 80. To me there is simply too much emphasis on Lanfear's great strength advantage over the other Forsaken for Nynaeve to be so close to her. I also don't think Alivia's "considerable strength advantage" over Nynaeve can be represented by a mere 10% on the strength scale.
Furthermore, I don't believe Alivia equals Lanfear - the most powerful woman of the Age of Legends by a margin big enough to leave her no doubt that she is exceeded by no woman.
In any case, the top individuals leave a lot of room for debate. But what seems incontrovertible to me is the placing of lesser characters like Egwene, Moiraine and the average Aes Sedai.
I don't really know how this notion of Egwene being 60-70% as strong as Lanfear crept up on us. It is not supported by the weight of evidence and should not be seriously considered, in my view.
This message last edited by Shannow on 03/01/2010 at 02:59:28 PM
One Power strength - critical analysis of previous posts and some further ideas
03/01/2010 07:59:24 AM
- 2342 Views
I support your view, with maybe a few comments to add...
03/01/2010 02:58:05 PM
- 1055 Views
where is this phantom quote of Egwene "not standing a chance"
03/01/2010 05:20:20 PM
- 756 Views
Here's the real quote
03/01/2010 05:38:59 PM
- 815 Views
Well that quote perfectly illustrates the skewed way in which you interpret the evidence...
03/01/2010 06:18:22 PM
- 778 Views
I also think the quote is specific
03/01/2010 06:34:38 PM
- 781 Views
Skill not Strength is the key that and the potential that another FS was with her
03/01/2010 06:51:46 PM
- 797 Views
Bah
03/01/2010 07:13:01 PM
- 740 Views
Who's arguing that?
03/01/2010 07:34:21 PM
- 715 Views
What ARE you arguing?
03/01/2010 07:43:06 PM
- 782 Views
That there is far more to strength in her quote!
03/01/2010 08:05:20 PM
- 678 Views
Re: That there is far more to strength in her quote!
04/01/2010 09:40:05 AM
- 876 Views
and where do I ever say Elayne is only a small step below Moghedien?
04/01/2010 03:08:37 PM
- 775 Views
You more than imply it with your own list
04/01/2010 03:39:06 PM
- 784 Views
and you are fixated on simple strength to the exclusion of everything else
04/01/2010 05:05:54 PM
- 729 Views
Re: and you are fixated on simple strength to the exclusion of everything else
04/01/2010 06:46:45 PM
- 1119 Views
Tiny Unimportant Objection to "Bell Curve" Point
03/01/2010 03:09:55 PM
- 876 Views
Re: Tiny Unimportant Objection to "Bell Curve" Point
03/01/2010 04:39:25 PM
- 781 Views
I've got a slightly revised opinion than my last post
03/01/2010 05:16:39 PM
- 987 Views
Re: I've got a slightly revised opinion than my last post
03/01/2010 06:31:09 PM
- 911 Views
It's actually not that complicated ... simple math actually
03/01/2010 07:08:52 PM
- 784 Views
Yes, but to think that RJ put that much effort into it is improbable
03/01/2010 07:19:13 PM
- 791 Views
I'm being harsh with one poster who continues to mis-quote things!
03/01/2010 07:56:17 PM
- 706 Views
Re: I'm being harsh with one poster who continues to mis-quote things!
04/01/2010 09:50:38 AM
- 820 Views
Re: I'm being harsh with one poster who continues to mis-quote things!
04/01/2010 03:26:10 PM
- 897 Views
Re: I'm being harsh with one poster who continues to mis-quote things!
04/01/2010 03:52:19 PM
- 766 Views
You are talking out of both sides of your mouth
04/01/2010 05:09:15 PM
- 716 Views
Dude
04/01/2010 06:21:28 PM
- 671 Views
Dude, please go back to Fionwe's post
04/01/2010 06:35:03 PM
- 712 Views
A reply...
03/01/2010 06:02:33 PM
- 718 Views
The Tower sample is skewed allright, but to the upper side of the strength range...
03/01/2010 06:36:45 PM
- 853 Views
Re: A reply...
03/01/2010 07:09:55 PM
- 847 Views
I think distance is related to Strength
03/01/2010 07:21:46 PM
- 764 Views
amusing side note
04/01/2010 05:22:39 AM
- 709 Views
Which is exactly what I envisage the AOL distribution to have looked like...
04/01/2010 07:03:51 AM
- 658 Views
Re: Which is exactly what I envisage the AOL distribution to have looked like...
04/01/2010 03:29:47 PM
- 734 Views
It may sound silly, but did you look at One Power values in the Wheel of Time CCG?
05/01/2010 12:56:41 AM
- 1161 Views
Re: It may sound silly, but did you look at One Power values in the Wheel of Time CCG?
05/01/2010 07:33:21 AM
- 813 Views