Pretty good given the circumstances. I'm grateful.
Sandwich Send a noteboard - 23/12/2009 06:49:46 PM
I agree that it's got some problems, some of them fairly glaring. And I was wary after reading Sanderson's other work - he is not Jordan caliber. But enough of it was Jordanlike and familiar that that I was just really happy to have it and to experience some long-awaited forward motion in the series.
I remember thinking during the zenith of Jordan's quality writing phase, "This is just so good. What if he dies before he finishes? I think I'll go insane." It was just one of those hypotheticals that you spare only a percentage point or two of probability. But lo, he did. Obviously I want Jordan's finish to this series, not somebody else's. But I can't have it. So the other options are somebody else or nothing. Nobody else is Jordan so naturally it won't be quite like him. And it won't be as good. But I'd rather have that and get some resolution than never know how it ended. I felt Sanderson used the existing characters and plotlines well enough to put me back in that world, which is all I wanted. I squint here and there to get around the fumbly initial writing and the Hinderstraps and Mats and Forsaken deaths and mountaintop epiphanies of the world and feel pretty good about it overall.
As for re-reading, there are some books earlier in the series I have no interest in reading again either - starting with #7 or #8 maybe and not picking back up until KoD. As many have noted, the series lost its way and got constipated. So at that point, while it was so sad to have lost the magic, I cut my losses and just wanted him to wrap it up. That's still what I want. Move the ball forward, get to TG, and let's fight and resolve things. If Sanderson can write just well enough to get that done, I'll be satisfied given the not ideal situation we find ourselves in.
I remember thinking during the zenith of Jordan's quality writing phase, "This is just so good. What if he dies before he finishes? I think I'll go insane." It was just one of those hypotheticals that you spare only a percentage point or two of probability. But lo, he did. Obviously I want Jordan's finish to this series, not somebody else's. But I can't have it. So the other options are somebody else or nothing. Nobody else is Jordan so naturally it won't be quite like him. And it won't be as good. But I'd rather have that and get some resolution than never know how it ended. I felt Sanderson used the existing characters and plotlines well enough to put me back in that world, which is all I wanted. I squint here and there to get around the fumbly initial writing and the Hinderstraps and Mats and Forsaken deaths and mountaintop epiphanies of the world and feel pretty good about it overall.
As for re-reading, there are some books earlier in the series I have no interest in reading again either - starting with #7 or #8 maybe and not picking back up until KoD. As many have noted, the series lost its way and got constipated. So at that point, while it was so sad to have lost the magic, I cut my losses and just wanted him to wrap it up. That's still what I want. Move the ball forward, get to TG, and let's fight and resolve things. If Sanderson can write just well enough to get that done, I'll be satisfied given the not ideal situation we find ourselves in.
Can't bring myself to re-read tGS
23/12/2009 12:01:33 PM
- 1584 Views
I think pretty much alone, yes
23/12/2009 01:39:52 PM
- 958 Views
I'm sorry you feel that way. I thought Sanderson did an outstanding job. *NM*
23/12/2009 04:30:16 PM
- 545 Views
Pretty good given the circumstances. I'm grateful.
23/12/2009 06:49:46 PM
- 953 Views
People who post on WOT messageboards do not comprise a reprsentative sample
23/12/2009 07:01:48 PM
- 828 Views
Re: People who post on WOT messageboards do not comprise a reprsentative sample
23/12/2009 10:34:15 PM
- 915 Views
It was better than POD or COT if you ask me. It was as good as I could have asked for from BS *NM*
25/12/2009 12:10:51 AM
- 372 Views
OK, maybe the writting wasn't as good, but the story was better than the previous couple of books *NM*
29/12/2009 08:24:17 AM
- 317 Views
No, you're not. It was OK - I was more happy that the series seemed to be progressing
29/12/2009 03:43:59 PM
- 643 Views
Except for the Mat parts, it was fairly good.
30/12/2009 04:30:15 AM
- 673 Views
Yeah, CoT is one of the WoT books I don't even use as a reference. I try to forget it. *NM*
30/12/2009 03:53:25 PM
- 358 Views
The Mat parts were the only places I was jarred by the difference in writing style
14/01/2010 03:12:58 PM
- 651 Views
Sorry, but I think Jordan was not writing all that well himself anymore
14/01/2010 09:19:07 AM
- 733 Views