Personally, I would take out what was probably the LotR's biggest failing...
MightyYT Send a noteboard - 17/12/2009 05:52:04 AM
Mainly all the scense with them walking, but nothing happening. I mean, most of the book, they are being pursued in one way or another. So it could still be exciting, but there is almost as much walking in EotW as there is in Fellowship. It could be cut down quite a bit.
I think when everyone gets split up after SL, you don't have to separate Perrin/Egwene, and Moraine, Lan, and Nyn. You can still have Perrin and Egwene get attacked by Whitecloaks, and still setup the bornhald(sp?) plot, but you can cut quite a bit out that way. Besides, both groups seem to show up in Caemlyn at roughly the same time. or close enough it wouldn't matter.
I agree that Fal Dara doesn't need to be shown, not yet anyways. It could be mentioned at the end, or have the final scene there, but they don't need to go there before hand.
I don't think that Rand and Tam need to return to the Farm before the Trolloc attack, they could be in EF, and Rand could be sitting with him while Moraine is out healing 'more serious' injuries, so Rand could hear Tam babble about finding him.
Most of Mat's and Rand's trip could be cut out. Showing Bayle, the Tower, and maybe one attack by DarkFriend's, but it doesn't need to be dragged out. Maybe meeting the Grinwell's and setting up some Ta'Varenness,
I think when everyone gets split up after SL, you don't have to separate Perrin/Egwene, and Moraine, Lan, and Nyn. You can still have Perrin and Egwene get attacked by Whitecloaks, and still setup the bornhald(sp?) plot, but you can cut quite a bit out that way. Besides, both groups seem to show up in Caemlyn at roughly the same time. or close enough it wouldn't matter.
I agree that Fal Dara doesn't need to be shown, not yet anyways. It could be mentioned at the end, or have the final scene there, but they don't need to go there before hand.
I don't think that Rand and Tam need to return to the Farm before the Trolloc attack, they could be in EF, and Rand could be sitting with him while Moraine is out healing 'more serious' injuries, so Rand could hear Tam babble about finding him.
Most of Mat's and Rand's trip could be cut out. Showing Bayle, the Tower, and maybe one attack by DarkFriend's, but it doesn't need to be dragged out. Maybe meeting the Grinwell's and setting up some Ta'Varenness,
Castle: This is so weird. I dressed up as him for Halloween.
Beckett: Me too.
~When Castle and Beckett met Gene Simmons.
Beckett: Me too.
~When Castle and Beckett met Gene Simmons.
EotW movie. What would you cut to make a 2-2:30 movie?
16/12/2009 07:35:41 PM
- 992 Views
Two things cannot be cut. At all.
17/12/2009 12:31:06 AM
- 629 Views
Bela and Narg would definitely be in MY version of the movie! *NM*
17/12/2009 12:45:41 AM
- 259 Views
anything not from Rand's POV
17/12/2009 12:39:59 AM
- 584 Views
Personally, I would take out what was probably the LotR's biggest failing...
17/12/2009 05:52:04 AM
- 619 Views
I'd split it into two movies and add a dream sex scene between Harry and Hermione.
30/12/2009 04:35:42 AM
- 476 Views