Active Users:1159 Time:22/11/2024 06:29:10 PM
Deconstruction of failed comprehension TheUltimateReality Send a noteboard - 30/11/2009 10:04:24 PM
Let's take this apart nicely and easily.

Egwene comes into the room, spots a significant herb garden on the balcony and various shrubs and small trees, and in one corner something for carrots and radishes to grow in. Food is certainly not the prime focus of this interior garden.

Egwene, because of her training as apprentice to a Wisdom, has knowledge of herbs and their uses. How much knowledge, we don't know, but she hung around Nynaeve for quite a while and from the quizzes Nynaeve gave her in the first couple of books, she knew her stuff. Follow that with her training with the Wise Ones and that knowledge should be pretty comprehensive.

She is able to, at a glance, recognize over fourteen herbs in the garden. She names two of them, two herbs with known medicinal properties in our world. Basil and thyme are *NOT* spices. Basil has been used for treating asthma and is being researched for antioxidant purposes. Thyme is an antiseptic and was used to prevent infections as a poultice.

So, far from thinking Suana's food had medicinal purposes, Egwene clearly identifies herbs, herbs she knows Nynaeve would use and could use herself. Whether it is a leap of faith or a logical flow, she now realizes that unlike the majority of Yellows she has met over the couple of years she's been in training, here is one that doesn't eschew the stigma of herbal medicine.

Since a Yellow is unlikely to develop an attitude like that to herbs late in life, it isn't too much of a reach to assume Suana came from similar roots to Nynaeve. With the ridicule that the Yellows have shown over Nynaeve's herbs, finding that one of the Sitters shares the reverence for her early roots is a revelation that would, and did, change her own attitude to the Ajah. Don't forget Nynaeve has a biased view of the Yellows, a view she passed onto Egwene in Salidar.

As to why Suana would invite Egwene to the Yellow despite her poor healing skills, I think that has been debated correctly above. Egwene is powerful and Suana wanted added strength to enhance the Yellows' position in the fragmentary hierarchy of the Tower at the time.

My old English teacher would have given you 3/20 if you handed that mess in as an answer to a reading comprehension test.
Reply to message
Who comes out looking worst in the Egwene-Suana encounter? Egwene, Suana or B-Sand? - 27/11/2009 04:16:18 PM 1666 Views
I interpreted it as Branderson trying to make the Yellow more believable. - 27/11/2009 07:09:43 PM 830 Views
Re: I interpreted it as Branderson trying to make the Yellow more believable. - 27/11/2009 08:16:48 PM 753 Views
anti-Nynaeve? - 27/11/2009 08:26:54 PM 735 Views
But that is not the connotation of Egwene's comment. - 27/11/2009 08:45:40 PM 808 Views
I disagree - 27/11/2009 09:01:04 PM 696 Views
Cannoli comes out looking like crap. RtDB! - 27/11/2009 07:51:53 PM 749 Views
Re: Cannoli comes out looking like crap. RtDB! - 27/11/2009 08:19:46 PM 653 Views
He's doing a crappy job of that, too. - 27/11/2009 08:37:06 PM 710 Views
Re: Cannoli comes out looking like crap. RtDB! - 27/11/2009 11:06:06 PM 717 Views
Please recall that you have admitted an inferior understanding of American English connotations. - 27/11/2009 08:23:41 PM 719 Views
Yes. I admit to not being fully familiar with a third rate rip off of a language I speak. So? - 27/11/2009 11:18:39 PM 658 Views
How can Egwene know she's unskilled if she's never Healed? - 28/11/2009 12:19:58 AM 653 Views
Simple... - 28/11/2009 01:16:44 AM 660 Views
I can see that for weaves they aren't stong enough - 28/11/2009 01:35:43 AM 621 Views
Nitpicking. - 27/11/2009 08:18:02 PM 743 Views
Actually it's trying to sort who is to blame for various idiocies. - 27/11/2009 08:25:28 PM 700 Views
hrmm - 27/11/2009 11:12:04 PM 596 Views
Re: Who comes out looking worst in the Egwene-Suana encounter? Egwene, Suana or B-Sand? - 27/11/2009 08:27:29 PM 777 Views
Re: Who comes out looking worst in the Egwene-Suana encounter? Egwene, Suana or B-Sand? - 27/11/2009 08:43:42 PM 747 Views
I agree that B-Sand did an excellent job overall - 27/11/2009 08:51:41 PM 710 Views
Re: I agree that B-Sand did an excellent job overall - 27/11/2009 09:12:14 PM 618 Views
Re: I agree that B-Sand did an excellent job overall - 27/11/2009 09:15:01 PM 639 Views
Re: I agree that B-Sand did an excellent job overall - 27/11/2009 09:20:17 PM 593 Views
You are correct! - 27/11/2009 09:21:08 PM 574 Views
Why would I justify obviously right actions? - 27/11/2009 09:25:45 PM 677 Views
This sounds like the descriptions I've heard of The Sword of Truth. - 27/11/2009 10:01:33 PM 605 Views
Have you actually read that? It's so booooooring. - 27/11/2009 09:23:27 PM 616 Views
Well it's the raving of a lunatic - 27/11/2009 09:26:27 PM 612 Views
like the scene at natrin's barrows? - 28/11/2009 05:56:21 PM 665 Views
This line gave me a laugh... - 28/11/2009 12:44:14 AM 644 Views
Nice one, Mr. Chauvinist, but you do make a point, too - 27/11/2009 09:19:33 PM 652 Views
Re: Who comes out looking worst in the Egwene-Suana encounter? Egwene, Suana or B-Sand? - 28/11/2009 01:32:57 AM 680 Views
Yes. A VERY lame joke. - 28/11/2009 11:20:34 AM 823 Views
Lets look at it in perspective - 28/11/2009 02:23:37 AM 693 Views
Deconstruction of failed comprehension - 30/11/2009 10:04:24 PM 602 Views
I was reminded of Elaida's liking for plants - 01/12/2009 07:51:31 AM 594 Views
Silly Cannoli - 01/12/2009 11:41:21 PM 898 Views
You got to admit, reading Cannoli is fun! *NM* - 10/12/2009 02:46:01 AM 269 Views

Reply to Message