The BA Hunters and their methodology (tGS spoilers)
BlackAdder Send a noteboard - 19/11/2009 02:16:20 PM
So, the method of hunting BA is pretty simple:
1. The Hunters suspected BA reswore some oath to the DO, so they use the Oath Rod to remove that oath (they didn't know what oath it was).
2. Make the BA reswear the First Oath. Then force them to say "I am not BA/Darkfriend"
But here's the rub... let's use Talene as an example. The Hunters "trapped" her. They explained exactly what it is they were doing and how they would do it.
Now, as we learned from Verin in tGS, the Darkfriend/BA oath is to "not betray the DO until the hour of death" (or something similar).
So, wouldn't Talene have been prevented from unswearing her Oath to the DO? Especially since she knew what it meant, after having it explained to her?
The same can be said for Sheriam, and a number of others who "waited their turn" at the end of tGS. Shouldn't they have had some sort of physical resistance to unswearing the Shadow Oath? Like the one when an AS tries to lie or attack an innocent person with the One Power?
Just found it a bit strange (i.e., VERY DISAPPOINTING) that the Oath to the DO could be removed without much ado.
1. The Hunters suspected BA reswore some oath to the DO, so they use the Oath Rod to remove that oath (they didn't know what oath it was).
2. Make the BA reswear the First Oath. Then force them to say "I am not BA/Darkfriend"
But here's the rub... let's use Talene as an example. The Hunters "trapped" her. They explained exactly what it is they were doing and how they would do it.
Now, as we learned from Verin in tGS, the Darkfriend/BA oath is to "not betray the DO until the hour of death" (or something similar).
So, wouldn't Talene have been prevented from unswearing her Oath to the DO? Especially since she knew what it meant, after having it explained to her?
The same can be said for Sheriam, and a number of others who "waited their turn" at the end of tGS. Shouldn't they have had some sort of physical resistance to unswearing the Shadow Oath? Like the one when an AS tries to lie or attack an innocent person with the One Power?
Just found it a bit strange (i.e., VERY DISAPPOINTING) that the Oath to the DO could be removed without much ado.
The BA Hunters and their methodology (tGS spoilers)
- 19/11/2009 02:16:20 PM
876 Views
It probably has to be a direct betrayal
- 19/11/2009 02:53:19 PM
635 Views
Yup, totally.
- 19/11/2009 05:45:45 PM
535 Views
Possible reason for the loophole
- 19/11/2009 06:04:12 PM
572 Views
Re: Possible reason for the loophole
- 19/11/2009 06:36:21 PM
557 Views
Could be in that moment
- 19/11/2009 09:04:59 PM
487 Views
But the DO had Rand's mother - don't think she was a DF *NM*
- 21/11/2009 06:43:17 PM
228 Views
Could have been an illusion. We really know nothing of what happens to souls
- 24/12/2009 08:14:05 PM
449 Views
Re: It probably has to be a direct betrayal
- 19/11/2009 06:41:03 PM
575 Views
But wasn't Talene *forced* to do that?
- 19/11/2009 08:05:48 PM
597 Views
That and any oath on the Oath Rod relies very heavily on the swearer's interpretation of the oath.
- 19/11/2009 07:30:55 PM
495 Views
*NM*
*NM*
True. There's a scene where Cadsuane is told about Aiel in the city and she says "I hadn't noticed."
- 19/11/2009 08:21:52 PM
604 Views
Unless she's Black Ajah 
Just kidding.
- 19/11/2009 08:59:49 PM
496 Views
Just kidding.
- 19/11/2009 08:59:49 PM
496 Views
Maybe that's the real reason she's now taken to wearing a black hood! 
*NM*
- 19/11/2009 09:02:06 PM
199 Views
*NM*
- 19/11/2009 09:02:06 PM
199 Views
There's reason to believe that if any AS removed the Oaths from themselves, it's Cadsuane. *NM*
- 01/12/2009 04:44:00 PM
209 Views
Bigger loophole
- 21/11/2009 06:46:42 PM
515 Views
True, but again perspective seems to determine what is a lie and what isn't
- 21/11/2009 10:19:19 PM
428 Views