and yet forgetting how to test for latent channelers was definitely lost in Seanchan.
Onarishma Send a noteboard - 18/11/2009 05:22:58 PM
But there isn't any great, compelling proof for it. The 'Song' isn't literally one magical song to find, but rather a lost technique.
A lost technique that requires Nym and Ogier who may be leaving this world soon.
What is the purpose of even mentioning a Song and having Egwene using TAR to take her to the Tuatha'an meetingplace in order to 'preserve the people and the world'? The Song is the only thing the Tinkers are useful for, yes? That would be proof enough for me to unbalance all the uncertainties on the other side.
Likely those Tinkers know what the dead Tinkers Mat found knew. I have no idea what that is, but it was apparently worth killing them for. As for "the Song," the point is to give another example of how information gets distorted through the years.
That no one knows how to test for the ability to sing is a fairly weak argument since people seem to be rediscovering lost Talents and techniques all over the show lately.
True, except that Singing doesn't seem to be a Talent that someone will suddenly discover, like seeing visions around people or talking to wolves. No one is going to be walking around singing and suddenly noticing it having an effect on the things around them.
Who's to say that the Voice isn't a latent ability that must be brought out. Also wilders disprove your poing of view as well. They channel the One Power and never recognize something extraordinary is going on. Why couldn't a Tinker or Aiel with the Voice have the same lack of perception?
And finally you agree that the Nym and the Ogier were functional participants. Why wouldn't the Aiel who were clearly screened also be functional participants? Neither the Nym or the Ogier need assistance to grow things on their own. To say that the human participants need the Nym and Ogier seems very unreasonable.
The Song
- 14/11/2009 11:52:18 PM
994 Views
there is no Song
- 15/11/2009 02:55:20 AM
620 Views
Well, we have been saying that for years...
- 15/11/2009 03:15:59 AM
702 Views
the Tinkers know something
- 16/11/2009 08:46:42 PM
560 Views
and yet forgetting how to test for latent channelers was definitely lost in Seanchan.
- 18/11/2009 05:22:58 PM
589 Views
Re: The Song
- 15/11/2009 09:43:58 AM
572 Views
I Don't think it will require that much discovery since Rand has intergrated with LTT
- 15/11/2009 01:03:50 PM
610 Views
why is it possible for Ogier to Sing plants but not humans? The Song may be Singing and the Voice.
- 17/11/2009 08:26:51 AM
522 Views