I forgot to add Sheriam's quote about Mesaana's strength...
Shannow Send a noteboard - 15/11/2009 07:25:48 AM
Like Fionwe, I think there are many meanings to each quote. When Cadsuane refers to Semirhage being one of the most powerful women who ever lived, I don't see really how strength could enter the debate. Strength in the Power does not make you invulnerable to torture and being broken. To me it's more a reference to Semirhage being one of the top leaders in the Shadow - a woman who's done so much evil that there could be nothing that could intimidate her (clearly Cadsuane hasn't met Moghedien).
I think it's reaching to assume that these quotes mean anything, and I did keep a look out for them when I read the book. Semirhage is at the very least as strong as Nynaeve, and that still makes her one of the most powerful channelers in the world. If one adds her major Talent, her lust for pain and her evil intent, it's easy to see why there are very few people who can overcome her. Making her as strong as Alivia will not really add to this.
The way Sheriam referred to Mesaana's incredible strength twice in a short scene (first saying someone of great strength in the Power was outside her tent, and then again exlaiming over "such strength!" was reminiscent of the references we've seen to Alivia's "incredible strength in the Power".
Anyway, as you and Fionwe say, there is of course no conclusive evidence either way. At least, not in this book.
But I maintain that the entire argument used to put Graendal above Semirhage is based on the single comment, made by Graendal HERSELF, about it being very rare indeed to find a woman stronger than herself in the Age of Legends.
There has been nothing to indicate that Semirhage might not be one such woman. In fact, is Semirhage's not by default someone of "very rare strength indeed?"
My point is, we cannot at this point definitively prove that Semirhage is stronger than Graendal. But there is even less of a basis to suggest that Graendal is stronger than Semirhage.
So I have a problem with the fact that the current 21 level list - which is now sitting on 13th depository I think - places Graendal a level higher than Semirhage.
I repeat: There is NO evidence for this whatsoever.
This message last edited by Shannow on 15/11/2009 at 07:27:49 AM
Semirhage's One Power strength revisited - this time with extensive quotes from the new book...
14/11/2009 11:36:24 PM
- 1308 Views
There are other ways to interpret these, though...
15/11/2009 12:15:35 AM
- 813 Views
Can I just ask why on earth it matters so much?
15/11/2009 12:45:48 AM
- 686 Views
List making is a feature of obsessive personalities...
15/11/2009 01:17:47 AM
- 715 Views
Cool, did you really predict it?
15/11/2009 11:36:47 AM
- 683 Views
Not 100% of the way there, unfortunately..
15/11/2009 12:51:04 PM
- 653 Views
Did someone say they had a copy of the old theories somewhere? *NM*
15/11/2009 01:06:42 PM
- 272 Views
Can you clarify - are you saying my reading of the sentence is correct or incorrect?
15/11/2009 07:59:46 AM
- 674 Views
I think you're correct, and one sister was never used to hold Semirhage.
15/11/2009 08:07:55 AM
- 514 Views
I guess
15/11/2009 06:49:49 AM
- 574 Views
I forgot to add Sheriam's quote about Mesaana's strength...
15/11/2009 07:25:48 AM
- 702 Views
Re: I forgot to add Sheriam's quote about Mesaana's strength...
15/11/2009 07:34:38 AM
- 732 Views
I think it's just because Graendal got more "airtime" in the books.
15/11/2009 08:08:02 AM
- 780 Views
Re: I think it's just because Graendal got more "airtime" in the books.
15/11/2009 11:01:04 AM
- 545 Views
I took it as obvious that Nynaeve was actually stronger than Semirhage
12/12/2009 12:41:17 AM
- 535 Views