So, I have scanned the title's of the discussions and have not seen it mentioned before, so let's get this idea of my back. Even thoug I doubt it can be counted as an "idea" since I have the feeling it's so dead obviously.
So, in Ch 48 "Reading the Commentary", Min is bugged by the passage "He shall hold a blade of light in his hands, and the three shall be one". It bugs her, and then finds out that it has also bugged Cadsuane all this time. In fact, it was the very reason that led her to investigate Callandor and to the conclusion that Callandor was flawed.
To me it's very obvious that "the three" is Min, Elayne and Aviendha. Especially coupled with the fact that Callandor needs to be controlled by two channelers. In order to do this, Rand needs to trust the two women controlling the link. The only real trust from Rand will be in his three wives, who have become one after the bond (or are one when linked). Elayne and Aviendha will have Callandor, how Min will be involded I do not know. But it seems to fit.
This also means that Callandor is not flawed, but was deliberately made as such.
Just wondering, is this obvious to others? Other ideas? Anybody else annoyed with Min for not figuring this out?
So, in Ch 48 "Reading the Commentary", Min is bugged by the passage "He shall hold a blade of light in his hands, and the three shall be one". It bugs her, and then finds out that it has also bugged Cadsuane all this time. In fact, it was the very reason that led her to investigate Callandor and to the conclusion that Callandor was flawed.
To me it's very obvious that "the three" is Min, Elayne and Aviendha. Especially coupled with the fact that Callandor needs to be controlled by two channelers. In order to do this, Rand needs to trust the two women controlling the link. The only real trust from Rand will be in his three wives, who have become one after the bond (or are one when linked). Elayne and Aviendha will have Callandor, how Min will be involded I do not know. But it seems to fit.
This also means that Callandor is not flawed, but was deliberately made as such.
Just wondering, is this obvious to others? Other ideas? Anybody else annoyed with Min for not figuring this out?
Below is my post on this subject:
tGS - the three shall be one
Curie Send a noteboard - 02/11/2009 11:52:12 PM
In the "Commentary on the Dragon" by Saijus, dissertation on the Karaethon Cycle, Min found out (tGS, 48 Reading the Commentary) a proposed explanation of the prophetic phrase: “He [Dragon Reborn] shall hold a blade of light in his hands, and the three shall be one.” She told to Cadsuane and her minions, that Saijus was wrong, and "one" should not be rule of the three cities, but management of Callandor. Cadsuane didn’t think that Min discovered something new or important. Of course old bully was right, Min was wrong, but she was wrong as well. The boot is on the other foot, because "the three shall be one" concerns three wenches, Min herself, Aviendha and Elayne.
Merging of Elayne Trakand with Birgitte Trahelion was mentioned by Aviendha in COT (13, High Seats) “I think you two will make each other melt, one day”, she said. IMO, Robert Jordan by such suggestion purposely blurred foreshadowing his real intention, which is the melting of Rand’s lovers. Preparations to this process started with bonding Rand by three of them.
Whole operation may be performed in Tel’aran’rhiod or in TAR-like environment close to SG, and would happen in a final part of MoL, after Elyane's twins are born. TAR has peculiar features, that were probably used by DO (or by his minions) for merging Isam and Luc into one being. Moghedien wanted to use TAR for changing Nynaeve al’Meara into a horse, or even a cricket (FoH, 5 Silver Arrow). I suspect, that introduction of souls of the freshly dead Forsaken to the bodies of enslaved humans is also done with similar technology.
By concept of melting of the three wenches RJ perhaps intended:
i)give readers widely expected happy end of MoL with all main, good characters alive, if not completely intact, up to the beginning of the Fourth Age. Dragon Reborn “must die to be alive” by exchanging body with Moridin. Afterwards, stealthy or posing to be Naebliss, he will be able to disassemble webs maintaining the bore. To do this, if web was spun by Mierin, he will need help from Aviendha or Elayne, who both can see female flows and know how unravel them. Three girls, and one after merger, will recognize him as Rand, because of the bond. After confining the DO, I hope, he will be ready for a quiet and peaceful life with his lover.
ii)Achieve proper reduction of numerous Rand's lovers to one. It would be in accordance with social correctness, majority of us diligently observe. In the real world, polygamy in western culture countries is not accepted by the public opinion, and not permitted by the law. In the USA, male Mormons, whatever their tradition, were officially banned to have more than one wife. Possessing up to four wives, what is still allowed in some muslim societies, is perceived by others like the repugnant habit, remnant of ancient behavior of the savage Arabic tribes. What more, non equal social role of different sexes seems to be very unproductive in modern civilization. In the WoT world, bigamy of Aiel tribes was, without any doubts, established as a remedy to the deficit of young males, permanently killed in clashes with their neighbours. In wetlands, all good boys and girls are monogamic. If you not believe, it is a preliminary list of known or predicted couples:
· Petra and Clarine,
· Perrin and Faile,
· Moiraine and Thom,
· Juilin and Amatherra,
· Nynaeve and Lan,
· Domon and Egeanin,
· Berelain and Galad,
· Darlin and Caraline,
· Gabrelle and Logain (Toveine is not bedded!),
· Gaidal and Birgitte,
· Morgase and Tallanvor,
· Agelmar and Amalisa,
· Deira and Bashere
· Gavin and Egwene,
· Riselle and Yamada,
· Lamgwin and Breane,
· Erith and Loyal
· Ituralde and Tamsin,
· Suan and Bryne,
· Karede and late Kalia
· Tam and late Kiri,
· Latelle and Luca.
Some people, we think they are also waking in the light, are at the moment single (Dobraine, Talmanes, Tam, Karede, Aludra, Kirgan, Leane, Selucia), but all of them, I expect, shall find proper spouses in future. What is especially remarkable, all Forsaken and majority of the Darkfriends, and also big number of bad characters, are not married. Many of them were in debauchery with various partners of different (Rahvin, Hanlon, Nasin, Haidar Sharan, Graendal) or the same (Taim, Galina, Elaida) sex. I do not believe Robert Jordan could allow Rand and his three lovers behave sexually, to the very end of the story, on equal moral footing with servants of the DO.
iii)create personality of Rand's partner with many virtues, like beauty and responsibility (Elayne), rightness and courage (Aviendha), dedication and intellectual reflection (Min). Lews Therin Telamon, Lord Dragon, married Iliena Moerelle Dalisar, Aes Sedai famous for her wisdom, achievements and beauty. He fought Shadow with bravery and skill, but finally lost battle of SG, created disaster, become mad, slain her and their children and committed suicide. Dragon Reborn, mixture of Lews Therin and Rand al’Thor, has a second chance, he is going to get rid Dark One and save mankind. He deserves to be rewarded by the Pattern with the magnificent wife.”If I live again, then she [Iliena] might as well” he said (tGS, 50 Veins of Gold). And he will have her.
If I am right, puzzle of Aviendha healthy, but something odd babies (WH,12, A Lily in Winter) is solved. The oddness applies to motherhood, not babies.
If not, flame me.
Min's riddle
08/11/2009 02:45:09 PM
- 2073 Views
Re: Min's riddle
08/11/2009 03:20:53 PM
- 889 Views
That third isn't so mysterious
08/11/2009 04:45:31 PM
- 892 Views
Re: That third isn't so mysterious
08/11/2009 04:47:10 PM
- 860 Views
It was stated explicitly that the third person is Moridin.
08/11/2009 05:19:16 PM
- 876 Views
Re: It was stated explicitly that the third person is Moridin.
08/11/2009 06:33:22 PM
- 878 Views
Wrong again. Pages 235-236 in The Gathering Storm are very clear about this.
08/11/2009 10:31:13 PM
- 1000 Views
Re: Wrong again. Pages 235-236 in The Gathering Storm are very clear about this.
08/11/2009 11:01:53 PM
- 962 Views
Well, if you want to pull ideas out of your ass there's no way to debate anything.
08/11/2009 11:35:43 PM
- 838 Views
I think you shold know that you are a boor. Bye. *NM*
08/11/2009 11:47:54 PM
- 430 Views
I was more polite to you and your silly theories than you deserved.
09/11/2009 01:32:30 AM
- 746 Views
Nowhere does it state that Moridin is the third. Just one of EIGHT people in Rand's head.
25/11/2009 08:27:31 AM
- 1311 Views
It's been known for... a long time, but like Tom says, it was actually stated in tGS *NM*
08/11/2009 06:04:46 PM
- 551 Views
Min's riddle is perhaps solved
08/11/2009 03:43:27 PM
- 1165 Views
wenches ?
08/11/2009 04:51:19 PM
- 860 Views
Hmmm. Not agreeing or disagreeing...but Min had a "Melting" viewing before
08/11/2009 08:34:36 PM
- 869 Views
Three things...
08/11/2009 08:40:37 PM
- 1169 Views
Uh...Hello...Ilyena...Elayne...see any similarity?
09/11/2009 05:37:45 AM
- 788 Views
You have some far-out theories and seem to think I’m retarded for not thinking the same
09/11/2009 10:16:51 AM
- 817 Views
I didn't "seem" to think it until now. I was AGREEING with you.
09/11/2009 03:02:15 PM
- 686 Views
I don't see how when I disagree with about everything you said
09/11/2009 11:40:19 PM
- 619 Views
Well, ultimately I couldn't care less what you think. Goodbye. *NM*
10/11/2009 03:13:09 AM
- 398 Views
Eh, there's no evidence of that, other than an abundance of vowels in their name.
10/11/2009 06:49:58 AM
- 685 Views
Answer to Crackbranded Asha' man: Where has it ever been shown that Taim is gay?
09/11/2009 06:25:42 PM
- 1030 Views
So... everyone pointing out how terrible this theory is in your original post hasn't disuaded you?
09/11/2009 04:47:25 AM
- 729 Views
Re: So... everyone pointing out how terrible this theory is ...
10/11/2009 12:03:02 PM
- 745 Views
Well, actually- yes! The LTT/Rand thing IS creepy.
10/11/2009 04:33:02 PM
- 917 Views
Channelling sickness, pregnancy-induced difficulty with weaving...
08/11/2009 03:53:26 PM
- 794 Views
Rand + Avi + Elayne = Three Channelers.
08/11/2009 05:59:34 PM
- 663 Views
Do you think, that channeling is cool?
08/11/2009 07:46:18 PM
- 777 Views
We're running out of time for the main characters to not start figuring things out.
08/11/2009 10:33:34 PM
- 607 Views
The riddle was simply a clue about safely using callandor. Nothing else.
09/11/2009 12:45:49 AM
- 817 Views
Too simple and obvious. *NM*
08/11/2009 07:56:05 PM
- 361 Views
Appearantly it wasn't obvious...
09/11/2009 12:51:07 AM
- 664 Views
Well... readers have always been better at figuring out the prophecies than characters
09/11/2009 04:56:23 AM
- 828 Views
But readers get the filtered bits and pieces. The characters have access to whole reams of works.
14/11/2009 03:25:50 PM
- 655 Views
I know- that's my point. It's a lot harder to pick things out for them
14/11/2009 06:47:07 PM
- 750 Views
Re: Min's riddle
08/11/2009 09:24:11 PM
- 888 Views
It's a possibility.
09/11/2009 04:59:33 AM
- 1145 Views
I can see this as a definite possibility
09/11/2009 10:12:23 PM
- 666 Views
It'd be more like David knocking out Goliath by making him punch himself in the face
10/11/2009 06:58:16 AM
- 711 Views
So why...
10/11/2009 10:14:38 AM
- 584 Views
The Dark One is sentient; the CK is just a tool *NM*
10/11/2009 04:33:52 PM
- 305 Views
True, but it wouldn't be the first time in this series... *NM*
10/11/2009 09:34:19 PM
- 414 Views
My point was that you can't really compare it to destroying the CK- it's a totally different
11/11/2009 07:02:54 AM
- 689 Views
How about LTT (loud voice), Old Rand (tiny voice), and New Rand? They have already become "one" *NM*
04/12/2009 06:32:20 AM
- 430 Views