Active Users:1145 Time:23/11/2024 04:53:28 AM
Re: Or logical trains of thought from fionwe1987.... fionwe1987 Send a noteboard - 01/11/2009 04:30:21 AM
That is an inherently fallacious argument from authority. Why don't you point out a place where I ever claim a character is great or flawed because of another character's assessment. Secondly, what is Verin saying, other than noting Egwene's success? Anyone could see how far she had come. That does not make her any less of a scumbag. It is Cannoli here, not Sidious. You need more than success in gaining rank to mean anything to me.

Why doesn't another character's assessment matter, though? And Verin's statement that she riled up her (Black) associates is a statement of fact, backed by the fact that in one of the first instances of Egwene trying to bridge the gaps in the Tower, a Black was present and had to do what Egwene suggested.
You're right that anyone could see sense and do what Egwene did. Heck, Saerin, or Tarna would have come up with these ideas with their eyes closed.
As I said elsewhere, they had two disadvantages. One, they couldn't go from Ajah to Ajah. Two, they were themselves caught up in the pettiness and infighting, and these had come too far along before they realized that had happened to the Tower.
So, Egwene provided fresh perspective, and yes, it was Elaida's blunder which let her do that. But in her position, not every person is going to continue to speak to Aes Sedai and give counsel when doing so results in beatings and penance, rather than reasonable acceptance, more often than not. A Cadsuane or Nynaeve would have provided the same perspcetive, but would have completely lacked the patience to deal with these idiot women. Egwene remained invisible to Elaida, but was able to encourage cooperation by speaking to members of each Ajah in a language they could understand, making each see that their Ajah's purpose was well suited to heal the Tower.
Frankly, the only other character I can see having success in a similar scale is Elayne.
Yes, she does improve herself in this book. But her taking action anyone could take is not inconsistant with what I had said about her previous actions. There is absolutely nothing inconsistant, and the two things you cite have nothing to do with each other, nor are they mutually exclusive, EVEN IF they were true.

You must realize Cannoli, that if your reaction to Egwene improving in this book is to post a pages long rant against her, then your perspective is wonky, and no one can be blamed for thinking you were blindly criticizing Egwene.
As for taking action anyone could take... didn't you praise Elayne for increasing the size of the Queen's Guard and using Gateways to supply Caemlyn? Both are total no-brainers, and any Queen would have taken such actions. It is hardly a stroke of genius to expand your army when you are the leader of the third and weakest faction fighting for a throne! I, however, can see that being absorbed in tradition and a myopic worldview prevented Dyelin from approving such action. Much as so many women in the Tower failed to see how entirely normal Egwene's suggested course of action to heal the Tower was. And so, I too praise Elayne for making these decisions that expedited her ascension to the Lion Throne.
Also, I think you praised Elayne for not running back to the palace and instead using her rescue force to encircle Arymilla? That is a tactical decision that requires no great thought. Anyone whose primary priority was success in the quest for the throne would have suggested that. Birgette did not because she saw protecting Elayne as the primary priority.
Egwene too has done many things that any Aes Sedai could have. But they did not, caught up in tradition or pride or the nets of the Shadow. And she had some of these issues too, but overcame them and rose to the challenge, undoing Mesaana's work and saving the Tower from complete disaster in the hands of the Seanchan.
I blame Egwene because that is all that she has to go on.

It seems to me more like you think Egwene's cause is less worthy than the others, thus her achievements are inherently cheaper, in your eyes.

While it is a whole other debate whether the Aes Sedai are worth the effort of saving, the point remains that Egwene has done a good job of ending strife within this organization. We shall see how she wields its power now.
Reply to message
Well Brandon Sanderson has officially killed off the last volume of the Epic Saga of the Chosen One. - 30/10/2009 02:36:19 AM 2446 Views
Life in unfair, just let Egwene have it already. - 30/10/2009 03:11:04 AM 851 Views
I skimmed cannoli's predictable rant. I disagree. I LOVED EVERY CHAPTER! - 30/10/2009 03:29:24 AM 806 Views
Agreed! *NM* - 30/10/2009 03:47:52 AM 504 Views
I liked her chapters. Mainly because they gave her something to do. - 30/10/2009 09:43:58 PM 724 Views
I adore Brandon Sanderson. - 30/10/2009 05:05:11 AM 836 Views
Me too - 30/10/2009 10:38:52 AM 890 Views
Exactly. - 30/10/2009 04:33:11 PM 737 Views
Re: I adore Brandon Sanderson. - 30/10/2009 02:45:03 PM 903 Views
Re: I adore Brandon Sanderson. - 30/10/2009 04:34:53 PM 757 Views
I think he meant Cannoli, not you, Seriana. *NM* - 30/10/2009 05:30:17 PM 432 Views
Ahhh. - 30/10/2009 09:15:14 PM 731 Views
Re: Ahhh. - 31/10/2009 03:51:14 AM 734 Views
Re: Ahhh. - 01/11/2009 06:37:41 AM 756 Views
Ditto. Thought he was a breath of fresh air to the series. - 30/10/2009 03:27:43 PM 720 Views
If renewal means someone grossly unfamiliar with the series, sure. - 30/10/2009 06:26:19 PM 1244 Views
Everything up to tGS - 30/10/2009 06:25:28 PM 944 Views
Re: Everything up to tGS - 30/10/2009 08:21:33 PM 925 Views
What on earth makes you think I dislike it? - 31/10/2009 05:25:07 AM 832 Views
General impression lately I guess. - 31/10/2009 04:38:29 PM 769 Views
Re: General impression lately I guess. - 31/10/2009 10:41:06 PM 765 Views
Thanks. - 01/11/2009 06:32:12 AM 843 Views
double post, hate my computer. - 30/10/2009 08:24:12 PM 835 Views
Don't agree completely but what I do want to see is - 30/10/2009 07:12:54 AM 756 Views
so I guess ... - 30/10/2009 02:48:10 PM 938 Views
You want a friend like Mat - 30/10/2009 06:33:47 PM 737 Views
might I add.. - 30/10/2009 08:30:24 AM 685 Views
Re: might I add.. - 30/10/2009 10:41:39 AM 783 Views
Re: might I add.. - 30/10/2009 06:47:17 PM 790 Views
There is a difference between defending your home from attack - 31/10/2009 03:34:57 PM 710 Views
I sit somewhere in the middle, she's improved, but still many flaws - 30/10/2009 11:35:47 AM 784 Views
Like others don't have flaws? - 30/10/2009 02:58:08 PM 780 Views
EVERYTHING is handed to her on a platter! - 30/10/2009 06:41:02 PM 802 Views
Touched a nerve did I? - 30/10/2009 07:19:00 PM 894 Views
Re: Touched a nerve did I? - 30/10/2009 07:24:41 PM 817 Views
Re: Touched a nerve did I? - 30/10/2009 07:31:14 PM 874 Views
Re: Touched a nerve did I? - 31/10/2009 06:36:33 AM 766 Views
Re: Touched a nerve did I? - 31/10/2009 09:33:34 AM 774 Views
And you aren't? - 01/11/2009 12:42:50 AM 738 Views
Seems to me you're both right. - 01/11/2009 07:45:12 PM 718 Views
Bah - 30/10/2009 03:36:42 PM 814 Views
wait a sec... - 30/10/2009 04:31:56 PM 880 Views
Now now! Let's take off the rose-tinted glasses for a minute. - 30/10/2009 05:21:07 PM 713 Views
Re: Bah - 30/10/2009 06:49:47 PM 842 Views
Rant on! Rant on! - 30/10/2009 12:54:16 PM 690 Views
Re: Rant on! Rant on! - 30/10/2009 03:18:44 PM 746 Views
A personal question: Cannoli, are you threatened by a powerful woman? - 30/10/2009 07:13:30 PM 819 Views
Obviously. - 31/10/2009 05:37:52 AM 704 Views
Well... - 31/10/2009 05:56:56 AM 668 Views
Countries are real, normal and natural things. The White Tower has no proven value. - 31/10/2009 06:52:48 AM 750 Views
Tar Valon is a nation - 31/10/2009 09:20:43 AM 735 Views
The "Elaida's election was illegal because of Black Ajah Sitters" is really an absurd argument - 01/11/2009 12:06:32 AM 801 Views
It wasn't absurd. Just clever... - 01/11/2009 03:33:22 AM 823 Views
I wasn't saying the rebels had no cause for rebellion. Just that the election *was* legal. - 01/11/2009 10:38:59 AM 827 Views
Hmm..... - 06/11/2009 04:18:14 PM 676 Views
I take it she'll carefully avoid bringing up the war vote, then. *NM* - 08/11/2009 12:47:21 AM 316 Views
Not a problem... - 08/11/2009 06:17:39 AM 743 Views
Are you blinded by a pair of teats? - 31/10/2009 07:17:44 AM 912 Views
Re: Well Brandon Sanderson has officially killed off the last volume of the Epic Saga of the Chosen - 30/10/2009 11:38:24 PM 835 Views
The harbor chain incident was no less stupid because it helped her - 31/10/2009 05:40:20 AM 688 Views
It must be embarassing to be on the same side as such dingbats. - 31/10/2009 07:18:42 AM 822 Views
*snort* *NM* - 31/10/2009 07:19:49 AM 438 Views
Re: It must be embarassing to be on the same side as such dingbats. - 31/10/2009 09:28:16 AM 807 Views
Don't expect rationality from Cannoli... - 31/10/2009 02:01:45 PM 868 Views
Or logical trains of thought from fionwe1987.... - 01/11/2009 01:07:06 AM 841 Views
Re: Or logical trains of thought from fionwe1987.... - 01/11/2009 04:30:21 AM 835 Views
Re: Or logical trains of thought from fionwe1987.... - 01/11/2009 08:41:58 AM 786 Views
Re: Or logical trains of thought from fionwe1987.... - 05/11/2009 02:40:16 AM 759 Views
Re: It must be embarassing to be on the same side as such dingbats. - 01/11/2009 12:31:10 AM 739 Views
I have one question - 01/11/2009 07:12:23 AM 778 Views
Capture, NOT kill, and she herself said the sa'angreal made that impossible. - 01/11/2009 07:59:44 AM 769 Views
Capture OR kill - 01/11/2009 09:12:08 AM 813 Views
Egwene isn't ta'veren - 31/10/2009 05:57:54 AM 722 Views
Re: Egwene isn't ta'veren - 31/10/2009 11:01:54 AM 711 Views
Events do seem to suggest otherwise. *NM* - 31/10/2009 04:40:42 PM 449 Views
I see Cannoll is still going strong about Egwene... - 01/11/2009 08:40:17 PM 774 Views
There were a few instances in the book where Egwene really bothered me. - 02/11/2009 12:54:10 AM 719 Views
Egwene's always been a hypocrite - 02/11/2009 02:06:58 PM 905 Views

Reply to Message