Active Users:1203 Time:19/12/2024 02:47:44 AM
The stuff with her early portrayal was explained (or could be understood) later on. Cannoli Send a noteboard - 09/08/2016 11:33:53 PM

I hated Nynaeve when I first started the series (why? I don't even recall, maybe because she was the bossy oldest of the "kids" ). She quickly became a favorite of mine. She was bossy and brash sometimes, and completely not Aes Sedai material, because she would have never conformed. And that was why she was the perfect person to be by Rand's side. A powerful female magic user without being sucked into the Tower's cult, who didn't view Rand as a tool, didn't over or under estimate him, and knew she would likely lose him in the end, and so stuck by his side to help him to his destiny.


Nynaeve was really into overcompensating at Wisdom. That's the kind of job, which as Moiraine points out, usually goes to women much older than she, like 40s at the earliest. She got the job at 18. So even though people pretty much understood that she could do the job and respected her abilities, they still could not help treating her like a young, inexperienced person. There is simply no precedent for such a thing. The very name implies experience and other qualities at accrue over time. But even though the skepticism and second guessing might be understandable, Nynaeve still had the responsibilities of her job, which included the health of the community, and to a large extent, their economic well-being, since she was in charge of giving farmers their weather reports. Her job and her responsibilities required people to listen to her, and she was usually right, thanks to certain advantages the mundane type of Wisdom did not possess, but people were still inclined to doubt her. Nynaeve had to come on strong and had to be abrasive, and never give and inch, and leave no doubt about her authority, because if she let them get into the habit of disobedience or ignoring her, people could starve or die, and it would be her fault.

We will see this sort of thing repeated in Egwene's storyline later on, with a lot of the same principles of leadership laid out. This of course makes it that much more galling when Egwene criticizes Nynaeve saying that if she fell into a pigsty, she'd try to make everyone think she did it on purpose. Duh. Because if they think she's a klutz, or a spas, that's more reason to blow her off or take her less seriously. But if she had a reason for it, which ordinary people can't understand, that might add credibility to her mysterious sources of knowledge. And when Egwene makes that assessment, it is in regard to Nynaeve having to deal with the Wise Ones, who were trying to force her not to use Tel'Aran'Rhiod. A simple list of Nynaeve's accomplishments in that area from that point forward will show how utterly stupid that was of the Wise Ones. When it came to T'A'R, they were as hidebound and inflexible as the Aes Sedai were about all sorts of other developments. Nynaeve implied by omission that she figured out what Ronde Macura was up to, because she was trying to keep up the facade of competence, to prevent the Wise Ones from cutting her off from whatever crumbs of advice she & Elayne might still be able to get, because short of gentling Rand at that point in the story, few handicaps would have been as disastrous for the cause of the Light as banning Nynaeve & Elayne from Tel'Aran'Rhiod that early in tFoH.

This is true with most things for which people criticize Nynaeve - there are very good reasons, and she isn't nearly as contradictory or hypocritical as people like to make her out to be. In the 2nd through 5th books, she is far and away the most competent and accomplished of the so-called Wondergirls, with Egwene only a member of that group by association, and Elayne not much more so.

Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
Dead ends and disappointments in the series - 05/08/2016 03:37:13 AM 1488 Views
Let me think about this some more, but..... - 06/08/2016 10:24:07 PM 833 Views
Sanderson might be the answer to a lot of these - 09/08/2016 12:26:22 AM 941 Views
Re: Sanderson might be the answer to a lot of these - 09/08/2016 01:00:52 AM 935 Views
The stuff with her early portrayal was explained (or could be understood) later on. - 09/08/2016 11:33:53 PM 868 Views
So the question is..... - 09/08/2016 04:42:17 AM 747 Views
Re: So the question is..... - 09/08/2016 11:18:57 PM 759 Views
A day late but here I go. - 19/08/2016 06:43:31 PM 783 Views
I updated my placeholder! Read it!... if there's 30m to spare. *NM* - 20/08/2016 08:47:50 PM 356 Views
I really thought this was going to happen too! *NM* - 01/09/2016 08:28:58 PM 346 Views
Trying to think of ones to add to the list, and the main one that comes to mind... - 26/08/2016 05:25:11 AM 710 Views
That's very interesting - 26/08/2016 06:06:38 PM 823 Views
The entire series ended up being a disappointment for me - 30/08/2016 03:15:40 AM 949 Views

Reply to Message