Active Users:1108 Time:23/11/2024 12:08:12 AM
Oops sorry... haven't been here for a few months! Sidious Send a noteboard - 22/11/2015 02:50:15 AM

View original post
We know Cadsuane is not stronger than the wonder girls for example.

And the actual absolute strength comparisons between different people on what is supposed to be a linearly distributed list (yeah right), make no sense whatsoever compared to what was presented in the novels.

In short, "Team Jordan" had no clue what was going on in Jordan's mind as far as the One Power is concerned.

EDIT

Also, regarding Taim's strength, there was no need to provide it, because Terez has revealed that in Jordan's actual notes in the library, it is revealed that he lied to us all, seeing as Taim was actually Demandred, at least up to the end of Lord of Chaos.

Sometime after that, possibly even after Crown of Swords, he changed his mind, once he realized people had figured it out quite easily.

Yeah, I know, shocking, but true nonetheless.


I do find it rather shocking. It's actually worth some sort of violent protest, but I think most of us don't care that much about the series anymore. It's just plain sloppy and a bit of a slap in the face of the original author.

Personally, I like the Rahvin strength - I always liked Rahvin. I think it's likely incorrect though, and merely the inattentive mistake of some brainless minion who got the power to write this Companion.

Very disappointing...

On the other hand, I think after all our years of debating we got quite close

Wheel of Time board admin
Fan of Lanfear
Reply to message
Here you have it : the strength in the Power lists - 21/11/2015 01:23:58 PM 2031 Views
Hey Sid, we've been debating this on here for the last month or so..in short, the credibility sucks. - 21/11/2015 04:52:40 PM 1088 Views
Oops sorry... haven't been here for a few months! - 22/11/2015 02:50:15 AM 947 Views
Some points - 21/11/2015 06:58:17 PM 848 Views
Re: Some points - 21/11/2015 11:19:39 PM 873 Views
Re: Some points - 22/11/2015 01:09:43 AM 798 Views
Re: Some points - 22/11/2015 01:53:23 AM 960 Views
No - 22/11/2015 03:31:30 AM 799 Views
Re: Some points - 22/11/2015 03:09:35 AM 1143 Views
Re: Some points - 22/11/2015 02:55:30 AM 769 Views
Re: Some points - 22/11/2015 03:34:04 AM 758 Views
Should be 72 levels including the men - 21/11/2015 10:34:59 PM 950 Views
Question about Forkroot... - 22/11/2015 01:07:18 AM 795 Views
Re: Question about Forkroot... - 22/11/2015 01:09:51 AM 850 Views
Question about Forkroot... - 22/11/2015 01:07:19 AM 762 Views
Yikes - 22/11/2015 02:59:04 AM 953 Views
Hopefully Dom will chime in here... - 22/11/2015 03:28:24 AM 1432 Views

Reply to Message