Re: AMOL - A mess of plot holes and spelling arrears - PUBLISH THE NOTES
muppet Send a noteboard - 28/01/2013 07:26:20 PM
Knight Rider, LOL!
I agree that I'd like to see the notes. I don't think Harriet will allow it, and honestly, in her position, I don't think I would either.
I think people would find that there's a lot of bluffing and blustering to an author's presentation of a work like this, and the hardcore theory geeks would be pretty upset that their pet theories are far more intricate and self-corroborating than RJ's notes are likely to be.
I do agree that Sanderson uses contemporary English WAY, WAY too much in his bits of the last 3 books. Mat's personality changes pretty drastically. He talks like he was ripped from a modern sitcom. I think he could have made a better effort at aping Jordan's style rather than trying to put his own stamp on things. Maybe Harriet told him to go ahead and do that, but I think most fans would have preferred he not.
I agree that I'd like to see the notes. I don't think Harriet will allow it, and honestly, in her position, I don't think I would either.
I think people would find that there's a lot of bluffing and blustering to an author's presentation of a work like this, and the hardcore theory geeks would be pretty upset that their pet theories are far more intricate and self-corroborating than RJ's notes are likely to be.
I do agree that Sanderson uses contemporary English WAY, WAY too much in his bits of the last 3 books. Mat's personality changes pretty drastically. He talks like he was ripped from a modern sitcom. I think he could have made a better effort at aping Jordan's style rather than trying to put his own stamp on things. Maybe Harriet told him to go ahead and do that, but I think most fans would have preferred he not.
AMOL - A mess of plot holes and spelling arrears - PUBLISH THE NOTES
28/01/2013 06:37:04 PM
- 2111 Views
Re: AMOL - A mess of plot holes and spelling arrears - PUBLISH THE NOTES
28/01/2013 07:26:20 PM
- 1186 Views
Re: AMOL - A mess of plot holes and spelling arrears - PUBLISH THE NOTES
28/01/2013 07:54:03 PM
- 899 Views
What's wrong with contemporary English? *NM*
30/01/2013 02:46:46 AM
- 394 Views