I think it would have been much more satisfying if it had been Gawyn, Logain, and then Lan, with Galad either not finding Gawyn, not going after Demandred, or getting struck down and taken with the injured before he reached Demandred.
The way it played out with Gawyn was perfect - not only highlight his stupidity at using the Bloodknives, but also delve to his core character, which is to do self-aggrandizing bullshit actions that actually are useless and threaten to undermine the entire cause that he is ostensibly trying to support. Challenging Demandred one-on-one was perfect for that.
For Galad, fine if he finds Gawyn. He should have been sad, and then carried out his duty in continuing to kill as many channellers as possible. That was not only his best use, what was RIGHT, but also his goddamn orders. He wouldn't just brush that aside lightly because he's pissed that Demandred killed his bro. Come on. And if he had to fight Demandred, it should have been an opportunity while he was carrying out his duty, like he was killing channellers and spotted Demandred and decided he should try to kill the most important channeller, and maybe get a bit extra mad because his brother was dead. But, much as I enjoyed seeing his arm 'flop' in front of him, he shouldn't have faced Demandred as he did, and live. That was horse shit.
Plus, the whole Gawyn-Galad-Lan buildup felt a bit too much of a forced 'I'm a teenage fanboy trying to figure out who the toughest sword fighter in the series is' resolution. Gawyn, followed by Logain was sufficient to prove Demandred's bad-assery. The triple-single-combat thing got a bit tired.
Anyway, I was mostly satisfied with that whole angle, and especially loved Gawyn's failure and Logain's prudence/cowardice. Adding Galad, I felt, overstretched it just enough to be irksome.
The way it played out with Gawyn was perfect - not only highlight his stupidity at using the Bloodknives, but also delve to his core character, which is to do self-aggrandizing bullshit actions that actually are useless and threaten to undermine the entire cause that he is ostensibly trying to support. Challenging Demandred one-on-one was perfect for that.
For Galad, fine if he finds Gawyn. He should have been sad, and then carried out his duty in continuing to kill as many channellers as possible. That was not only his best use, what was RIGHT, but also his goddamn orders. He wouldn't just brush that aside lightly because he's pissed that Demandred killed his bro. Come on. And if he had to fight Demandred, it should have been an opportunity while he was carrying out his duty, like he was killing channellers and spotted Demandred and decided he should try to kill the most important channeller, and maybe get a bit extra mad because his brother was dead. But, much as I enjoyed seeing his arm 'flop' in front of him, he shouldn't have faced Demandred as he did, and live. That was horse shit.
Plus, the whole Gawyn-Galad-Lan buildup felt a bit too much of a forced 'I'm a teenage fanboy trying to figure out who the toughest sword fighter in the series is' resolution. Gawyn, followed by Logain was sufficient to prove Demandred's bad-assery. The triple-single-combat thing got a bit tired.
Anyway, I was mostly satisfied with that whole angle, and especially loved Gawyn's failure and Logain's prudence/cowardice. Adding Galad, I felt, overstretched it just enough to be irksome.
Well, that was fun
09/01/2013 09:32:09 AM
- 1931 Views
Here there be spoilers for the Mistborn trilogy and other thoughts.
09/01/2013 10:13:03 AM
- 1102 Views
Packing so much into Chapter 37 was Sanderson's brain child. *NM*
09/01/2013 11:25:30 AM
- 562 Views
I read that one little line about You Know Who and I pictured you whooping with unbridled glee. *NM*
09/01/2013 07:05:54 PM
- 530 Views
You didn't enjoy Gawyn?
09/01/2013 11:13:07 PM
- 1179 Views
I laughed too. That was hilarious.
09/01/2013 11:40:12 PM
- 1176 Views
I was actually expecting that...
10/01/2013 12:02:01 AM
- 1056 Views
I think the whole thing was mishandled
10/01/2013 01:27:44 AM
- 1220 Views
I feel similar, but switch Galad for Gawyn
10/01/2013 06:24:43 PM
- 1368 Views
I felt it was fitting, but not funny...
10/01/2013 12:05:30 AM
- 981 Views
By all out, you mean throwing away what she believes to be the sine qua non of the Tower's survival?
10/01/2013 01:00:14 AM
- 1016 Views
What else was she supposed to do?
10/01/2013 01:20:46 AM
- 971 Views
I'm just saying that Egwene's actions give the lie to her expressed priorities.
10/01/2013 01:29:06 AM
- 893 Views
It doesn't at all...
10/01/2013 01:39:53 AM
- 1000 Views
I don't fault her for PTSD, but for pursuing power despite valid reasons why she might botch it
10/01/2013 01:46:05 AM
- 856 Views
Re: I don't fault her for PTSD, but for pursuing power despite valid reasons why she might botch it
10/01/2013 01:52:22 AM
- 1112 Views
That's a good question. I can't think why I left him off the list
10/01/2013 12:58:53 AM
- 1043 Views
Re: That's a good question. I can't think why I left him off the list
10/01/2013 04:04:44 AM
- 956 Views
Nah, tGS consisted largely of people talking smack to Gawyn and setting him straight.
10/01/2013 04:43:16 AM
- 917 Views