the problem is that the Mean is not going to tell us much really
darius_sedai Send a noteboard - 22/11/2012 02:55:03 AM
the Mean is where the highest number of individuals will fall statistically. The Units of Saidar an individual can wield is not what makes them "100" or "1" its the relative rarity of which that strength appears in nature. We do not have a single real number that maps an individuals actual strength in the power so we cannot do more than guess at this.
With that Said we can make the assumption that Lanfear is also 5.730729 SD from the Mean, but it doesn't tell us how much stronger she is than Morgase or the individual at the Mean. Or what number the Mean falls at on the scale.
Realistically Lanfear may be able to wield 1000 units of Saidar and Morgase 1 unit, but that tells us nothing of how many units the individual at the Mean can wield. RJ told us there is a Bell Curve distribution, but he gave us vague descriptions of actual power ... things like "considerably" or "very weak" but no indication of what that really means.
Personally I've placed the 21 level list as the Bell Curve, which would make the level 11 channelers at Mean with 10 SDs on each side (yes I know this isn't perfect). If you place all the FS at levels 20-21 and women of significant strength, from 16-19 you can then place Morgase at level 1 and the significantly weak channelers on levels 2-6 meaning AS all fall between 7-15 (levels 7 and 8 being Accepted). Which would square with the series quotes etc ... most AS will be Mean and below levels 9-11 or Daigian-Merilille (too weak to Travel) women AS consider strong falling at levels 12-15 or probably Verin-Moiraine in strength.
Another way to consider this is from RJs comments about levels
Forsaken Level ... Nynaeve, Sharina, the Forsaken
One Step Lower we have
"Exceptional"Level ... Egwene, Cadsuane, Bode, Nicola, Mielyn, Kerene
One step below that we have
"Very Strong" Level ... Moiraine, Siuan, Lelaine, Romanda, Elaida, Sheriam, Leane, and the other very strong Sisters like Kiruna, Bera and Galina I'd estimate that the weakest women at this range are likely Nesune, Katerine or Coiren.
Below that we have "Above average Sisters", women of influence in the Tower, but not at the very top rung ... likely Tarna or perhaps Masuri and Rafela at the top of this level, in the mid-range of that would be Verin, Seonid, Merana, Alana and someone like Merilille, Eldrith, Covarla etc.. at the lower range of the level
Middling sisters would encompass women like Adeleas and Vandene (who I would consider the MEAN level Channelers) This is where I believe the vast majority of the unnamed AS sit.
Weak Sisters would be women like Siuan and Leane are now, Cabriana, Kumira and, of course, Daigian.
Then there is the 37.5% of women who pretty much fall under the "negligible" category, I'd say there are actually many levels within this category ... New Moiraine, Alise, Sorilea, Morgase etc... perhaps Moiraine is 2x Alise who is in turn 3x Sorilea etc... but these are all Channelers of insignificant power. To do anything of real note they would need to have an angreal or lead a circle.
We can benchmark certain things at certain power levels such as Egwene level is about 2x Moiraine level, and that Moiraine level is about 3x Weak Sister level ... and we can assume that Weak Sister level is probably many times greater than even the highest level of "negligible" ... Daigian maybe 5x Sorilea who may be 15x Morgase ... but that doesn't really tell us a whole lot
Personally I think each level on the 21 level list comprises a smaller range of power (in terms of units) so Morgase level can wield 1 unit, but Sorilea's level may vary more and encompass women who can wield between 11-14 units, Alise level between 35-50 units, on the flip side level 21 may encompass women who can wield anywhere from 400-450 units, Level 20 would be women who can hold 365-400 units, that would allow for Graendal to be a 21 but still noticeably weaker than Lanfear, and Moghedien being at level 20 and still being much weaker than Lanfear, and also allows for Merana, Alana and Verin being on the same level and being unsure of which is stronger without an actual contest.
With that Said we can make the assumption that Lanfear is also 5.730729 SD from the Mean, but it doesn't tell us how much stronger she is than Morgase or the individual at the Mean. Or what number the Mean falls at on the scale.
Realistically Lanfear may be able to wield 1000 units of Saidar and Morgase 1 unit, but that tells us nothing of how many units the individual at the Mean can wield. RJ told us there is a Bell Curve distribution, but he gave us vague descriptions of actual power ... things like "considerably" or "very weak" but no indication of what that really means.
Personally I've placed the 21 level list as the Bell Curve, which would make the level 11 channelers at Mean with 10 SDs on each side (yes I know this isn't perfect). If you place all the FS at levels 20-21 and women of significant strength, from 16-19 you can then place Morgase at level 1 and the significantly weak channelers on levels 2-6 meaning AS all fall between 7-15 (levels 7 and 8 being Accepted). Which would square with the series quotes etc ... most AS will be Mean and below levels 9-11 or Daigian-Merilille (too weak to Travel) women AS consider strong falling at levels 12-15 or probably Verin-Moiraine in strength.
Another way to consider this is from RJs comments about levels
Forsaken Level ... Nynaeve, Sharina, the Forsaken
One Step Lower we have
"Exceptional"Level ... Egwene, Cadsuane, Bode, Nicola, Mielyn, Kerene
One step below that we have
"Very Strong" Level ... Moiraine, Siuan, Lelaine, Romanda, Elaida, Sheriam, Leane, and the other very strong Sisters like Kiruna, Bera and Galina I'd estimate that the weakest women at this range are likely Nesune, Katerine or Coiren.
Below that we have "Above average Sisters", women of influence in the Tower, but not at the very top rung ... likely Tarna or perhaps Masuri and Rafela at the top of this level, in the mid-range of that would be Verin, Seonid, Merana, Alana and someone like Merilille, Eldrith, Covarla etc.. at the lower range of the level
Middling sisters would encompass women like Adeleas and Vandene (who I would consider the MEAN level Channelers) This is where I believe the vast majority of the unnamed AS sit.
Weak Sisters would be women like Siuan and Leane are now, Cabriana, Kumira and, of course, Daigian.
Then there is the 37.5% of women who pretty much fall under the "negligible" category, I'd say there are actually many levels within this category ... New Moiraine, Alise, Sorilea, Morgase etc... perhaps Moiraine is 2x Alise who is in turn 3x Sorilea etc... but these are all Channelers of insignificant power. To do anything of real note they would need to have an angreal or lead a circle.
We can benchmark certain things at certain power levels such as Egwene level is about 2x Moiraine level, and that Moiraine level is about 3x Weak Sister level ... and we can assume that Weak Sister level is probably many times greater than even the highest level of "negligible" ... Daigian maybe 5x Sorilea who may be 15x Morgase ... but that doesn't really tell us a whole lot
Personally I think each level on the 21 level list comprises a smaller range of power (in terms of units) so Morgase level can wield 1 unit, but Sorilea's level may vary more and encompass women who can wield between 11-14 units, Alise level between 35-50 units, on the flip side level 21 may encompass women who can wield anywhere from 400-450 units, Level 20 would be women who can hold 365-400 units, that would allow for Graendal to be a 21 but still noticeably weaker than Lanfear, and Moghedien being at level 20 and still being much weaker than Lanfear, and also allows for Merana, Alana and Verin being on the same level and being unsure of which is stronger without an actual contest.
Domani Drag Queen in the White Tower ... Aran'gar watch out!
This message last edited by darius_sedai on 22/11/2012 at 04:19:29 AM
How many standard deviations is Lanfear
15/11/2012 06:04:39 PM
- 2071 Views
Hmm...
15/11/2012 07:25:34 PM
- 1206 Views
see we CAN agree on stuff
15/11/2012 07:56:12 PM
- 1063 Views
18/11/2012 08:37:22 PM
- 957 Views
Re:
18/11/2012 11:07:17 PM
- 1163 Views
Re:
19/11/2012 05:16:00 AM
- 989 Views
Re:
19/11/2012 03:13:01 PM
- 995 Views
They only reject 37.5%, not 62.5%
19/11/2012 03:19:19 PM
- 997 Views
Re: They only reject 37.5%, not 62.5%
19/11/2012 04:01:43 PM
- 1204 Views
Re: They only reject 37.5%, not 62.5%
19/11/2012 09:04:04 PM
- 950 Views
Hmmm...
20/11/2012 02:08:40 AM
- 1016 Views
Perhaps, but Egwene is also being a bit dramatic in the scene as she managed
20/11/2012 04:28:57 AM
- 974 Views
Nope...
20/11/2012 03:13:13 PM
- 1025 Views
I believe she is being over dramatic
20/11/2012 03:26:24 PM
- 922 Views
Keep believing that...
20/11/2012 03:30:14 PM
- 1051 Views
*shrugs*
20/11/2012 03:49:10 PM
- 1002 Views
Tired and forkroot are the same now?
20/11/2012 03:55:22 PM
- 909 Views
No it's the literary device
20/11/2012 04:04:28 PM
- 1029 Views
Impossible. Daigian is exactly 0.32SD below the mean
19/11/2012 11:06:04 AM
- 973 Views
You keep saying that, but it is either a linear or a non-linear distribution
19/11/2012 09:09:32 PM
- 1030 Views
That's the whole point. Thanks for finally seeing it.
19/11/2012 09:43:27 PM
- 991 Views
keep believing that ... but you making up numbers isn't really relevant *NM*
20/11/2012 04:29:44 AM
- 653 Views
Please show me a number that is made up. The 0.32SD for Daigian is a rule of statistics.
20/11/2012 07:15:48 AM
- 954 Views
Ugh. I hate power level discussions. For real world applications, it should be kind of meaningless
16/11/2012 10:28:49 PM
- 943 Views
I don't really agree
18/11/2012 08:40:53 PM
- 888 Views
Perhaps, but we've seen that a MUCH weaker Channeler can win in a duel
19/11/2012 09:13:48 PM
- 959 Views
Re: Perhaps, but we've seen that a MUCH weaker Channeler can win in a duel
20/11/2012 08:10:01 AM
- 930 Views
Since I've proven that it's not a normal distribution in units of absolute strength, SDs don't apply
17/11/2012 07:48:21 PM
- 989 Views
You have proven nothing, except that you have an opinion *NM*
18/11/2012 02:21:35 AM
- 636 Views
You simply don't get it. It is mathematically a fact. There is no opinion involved.
18/11/2012 02:19:40 PM
- 833 Views
Only because you've assigned numeric values. That you created.
18/11/2012 02:40:51 PM
- 958 Views
It doesn't matter what figure you use...
18/11/2012 03:01:56 PM
- 837 Views
What if Daigian is one third Lanfear's strength?
18/11/2012 04:37:58 PM
- 979 Views
Sure you can
18/11/2012 10:09:31 PM
- 991 Views
Re: Sure you can
18/11/2012 10:54:50 PM
- 940 Views
You're right, though its 37.5%
19/11/2012 12:21:29 AM
- 905 Views
Oops, typo!
19/11/2012 02:54:25 AM
- 975 Views
Again, not possible, due to Daigian being just 0.3SD below the Mean
19/11/2012 08:37:01 AM
- 928 Views
Egwene is definitely not 2x Amys...
19/11/2012 04:05:12 PM
- 870 Views
Re: Egwene is definitely not 2x Amys...
19/11/2012 05:55:02 PM
- 798 Views
Egwene is about as strong as Melaine and Amys combined
19/11/2012 09:19:50 PM
- 915 Views
Re: Egwene is about as strong as Melaine and Amys combined
20/11/2012 02:11:26 AM
- 943 Views
Forkroot in every case
20/11/2012 04:32:26 AM
- 924 Views
No!
20/11/2012 03:15:16 PM
- 907 Views
I'm not going to go re-read the books to you on this
20/11/2012 03:39:46 PM
- 923 Views
You need to read it for yourself, since you're completely confused.
20/11/2012 03:54:26 PM
- 888 Views
Not going to argue this with you.
20/11/2012 04:09:44 PM
- 861 Views
Your own example disproved your point...
20/11/2012 04:39:25 PM
- 952 Views
let's see, she's both asleep and would need hours to regain her strength
20/11/2012 04:43:17 PM
- 848 Views
Enough!
20/11/2012 05:04:06 PM
- 936 Views
LOL ... whatever. You go on believing that ... no one else sees it this way. *NM*
20/11/2012 05:20:52 PM
- 623 Views
Re: Your own example disproved your point...
20/11/2012 05:10:15 PM
- 981 Views
Barasine + Katerine isn't that much less than
20/11/2012 05:26:31 PM
- 983 Views
Re: Egwene is definitely not 2x Amys...
20/11/2012 02:26:47 AM
- 857 Views
Re: Egwene is definitely not 2x Amys...
20/11/2012 09:03:40 AM
- 905 Views
Re: Egwene is definitely not 2x Amys...
20/11/2012 02:59:08 PM
- 940 Views
None of this is backed by any evidence...
20/11/2012 03:24:12 PM
- 858 Views
who said Cadsuane was 1.5x Moiraine or more?
20/11/2012 04:03:13 PM
- 860 Views
Nope...
20/11/2012 04:41:35 PM
- 902 Views
wrong
20/11/2012 04:48:50 PM
- 835 Views
Better evidence? LOL!
20/11/2012 03:18:55 PM
- 907 Views
Huh? How did you come to that conclusion?
20/11/2012 04:40:56 PM
- 899 Views
BEcause Cadsuane is close on the heels of Egwene?
20/11/2012 05:10:50 PM
- 816 Views
I'm not arguing that. I agree that Cadsuane is pretty close to Egwene
20/11/2012 05:50:34 PM
- 921 Views
Interesting, but let's go with your figures...
19/11/2012 06:54:54 AM
- 971 Views
Indeed
19/11/2012 08:16:44 AM
- 1010 Views
Rand is sort of a special case
20/11/2012 04:25:02 AM
- 835 Views
Regarding Mesaana...
20/11/2012 08:42:56 AM
- 908 Views
You continue to mix two things
20/11/2012 03:24:44 PM
- 837 Views
No
20/11/2012 04:54:19 PM
- 1058 Views
You are mistaken
20/11/2012 05:04:40 PM
- 918 Views
Probably, but the AS have no idea what 37.5% means
19/11/2012 02:59:26 AM
- 862 Views
It's irrelevant
19/11/2012 03:46:42 AM
- 931 Views
Agreed. Daigian is the marker of the absolute bottom of Aes Sedai strength.
19/11/2012 06:55:41 AM
- 898 Views
Daigian
19/11/2012 08:12:19 AM
- 918 Views
It is a direct marker due to RJ's quote
19/11/2012 08:50:26 AM
- 943 Views
You missed my point
19/11/2012 09:08:42 AM
- 879 Views
Asmodean would never have made the comment about 13 weakest AS
20/11/2012 04:41:11 AM
- 886 Views
Re: Asmodean would never have made the comment about 13 weakest AS
20/11/2012 09:07:49 AM
- 862 Views
Re: Sure you can
19/11/2012 09:22:09 AM
- 1007 Views
Care to explain this...
19/11/2012 05:06:28 PM
- 848 Views
Indeed
20/11/2012 07:16:37 AM
- 1069 Views
Explained far better than I ever could. Bravo.
20/11/2012 07:30:29 AM
- 884 Views
Well duh.
20/11/2012 02:57:24 PM
- 992 Views
Incorrect.
20/11/2012 04:28:07 PM
- 978 Views
No
20/11/2012 04:44:16 PM
- 954 Views
You're integrating without lower limits...
20/11/2012 02:55:06 PM
- 929 Views
We are not talking about a normal distribution in any case
20/11/2012 04:44:24 AM
- 771 Views
Re: We are not talking about a normal distribution in any case
20/11/2012 07:02:47 AM
- 959 Views
You must tell me of this special math...
20/11/2012 03:10:09 PM
- 858 Views
Re: You must tell me of this special math...
20/11/2012 04:29:40 PM
- 894 Views
Morghase is a placeholder...
20/11/2012 04:45:42 PM
- 962 Views
Well...
18/11/2012 08:43:59 PM
- 994 Views
Re: Well...
19/11/2012 03:40:44 PM
- 975 Views
Wow.
19/11/2012 03:53:47 PM
- 1018 Views
Well then you're both wrong I'm afraid
19/11/2012 06:09:36 PM
- 870 Views
Re: Well then you're both wrong I'm afraid
19/11/2012 07:42:58 PM
- 771 Views
this is why I think all of the Forsaken are very close in Power
20/11/2012 04:51:20 AM
- 965 Views
Re: this is why I think all of the Forsaken are very close in Power
20/11/2012 02:45:18 PM
- 906 Views
I think RJ went out of his way to keep strength a bit of a mystery
20/11/2012 08:42:44 PM
- 913 Views
Math gurus...Is it possible to find the missing variable...
21/11/2012 05:12:24 PM
- 914 Views
the problem is that the Mean is not going to tell us much really
22/11/2012 02:55:03 AM
- 981 Views
Re: the problem is that the Mean is not going to tell us much really
22/11/2012 03:15:33 AM
- 1267 Views
I do not think you can calculate the Mean without knowing the Units of Power
22/11/2012 03:53:59 AM
- 1069 Views