Active Users:973 Time:15/11/2024 05:06:20 PM
You're impossible... DomA Send a noteboard - 30/05/2012 10:02:59 PM
What I am saying is that I find it a poorly worked out scenario filled with bad decisions. Galad as a Damodred did nothing for the Mantear line without Laman guaranteeing him the Sun Throne.


That garanteed Taringail a male heir to continue his line if Tigraine bore him a son. What did it give Mantear? The fucking approval by Laman for the wedding!

What's so hard to understand about this?

In effect Modrellien allowed her line of the Mantear family to ie out by not having Galad inherit the High seat when Tigraine vanished. This potentially weakened Mantear for future successions since they track back connections to Ishara which Galad's line of the family in theory would have more of than other Mantear lines.


I'm a just hair away from insulting your intelligence. ;)

- Lines from Ishara are matrilinear. It means men don't pass bloodlines from Ishara. They pass exclusively from mother to daughter only. Galad's offspring don't inherit any line from Ishara from him, only from his wife if she has any. Considering who Gawyn and Galad mean to marry, their children are out of Ishara's succession and the only chance their descendants ever re enter it would be by marrying a woman from Ishara's lines.

- Galad was a FUCKING TODDLER when Mordrellen died. He would never have been considered for the High Seat of Mantear anyway. Mordrellen had lost her only heir, and her last female relative within Mantear. Her closest female relative with enough lines from Ishara was a distant one, Morgase from Trakand. The dynasty of Mantear was ended with Tigraine's disappearance. Mantear's female line was finished, the bloodlines to Ishara were lost (they would reappear only when a male member married a woman who had some she would then pass to her daughter. There was no surviving Mantear woman closer to Mordrellen than Morgase, who we know was fairly distantly related, not a cousin as common folk understand it, rather a cousin removed a few times). Mordrellen died soon after of grief. We know Taringail was well disliked by Mantear (and the rest of Andor), why would Mordrellen or the Mantears would even want to pass the High Seat and all the lands and revenues attached to that to a baby boy who would obviously be controlled by his disliked scheming foreigner of a dad who was judged to have been a bad husband to Tigraine beside? Galad was much too young to show he wasn't his father's son! The HS passed to one of the former Queen's male Mantear relatives, not a close one as we know she had no surviving brother or close female relative. A male cousin or uncle thus, at best. It's as simple as that. Out with Taringail, the lands and revenues stay in Mantear.

And no way Taringail marries into Trakand if he is Hier to the Sun Throne.


He wasn't. By Cairhienin law as it stood then he couldn't even be! Perhaps Laman meant to his son his heir if the scheme to turn him into the ruler of Andor ever succeeded, but if he meant to make Taringail himself his heir eventually that would have involved changing the law of Cairhien that excluded Taringail because of his marriage to a foreign ruler (that had nothing to do with Taringail marrying into Trakand, Fionwe invented that. That's Andoran custom because of the matrilinear system, not Cairhienin. All the books say on this issue is that when Laman died Taringail was not eligible under Cairhienin Law because he was the husband of the Queen of Andor. He would have been in the same position if Tigraine had ascended the throne). Even if that was his plans (a very big IF), changing the succession law to make Taringail his heir is not something Laman would have done until closer to his death, otherwise his rivals would have plot to counter this, or would murder Taringail! He wasn't that old anyway, he could still have children. He died an untimely death at war, him and his two surviving brothers.

I suspect something else went down between Tigrain vanishing and Morgase becoming Queen that at least put doubt on the succession to the Sun Throne and clearly had Taringail in an uncertain enough situation to renounce his lineage and potential for the Crown in order to marry Morgase as a Trakand


What happened is plain as day. Taringail and Laman saw all their hopes of power in Andor vanish with Tigraine being declared dead at Mordrellen's death. The only way he could salvage anything in Andor was by agreeing to Morgase's offer of marriage, and because she held the bigger end of the stick she made it a sine qua non condition that Taringail married into House Trakand. Laman saw an opportunity there Taringail would co-rule with Morgase or gain enough influence with his extremely young wife(she was like 16-18 y.o. only) to even rule in her place. Laman was still young, he could eventually have made Galad his heir if he still had no children by his old age. The prospect Taringail would soon co-rule Andor or more, that was how the advantage of his wedding to the very young Morgase was perceived in Cairhien (Laman had let this leak on purpose, it's implied). When it became apparent to the Cairhienin Taringail would never come close to that status, that undermined Laman's prestige so much there were rumors he might lose the Sun Crown to plots from rival Houses, and this lead him to launch a prestigious project involving cutting Avendoraldera to make a new Sun Throne. That lead to the Aiel War.

In Andor, it was believed House Riatin had murdered Taringail to forestall any scheme of his to regain the Sun Throne for Damodred for himself or though his son. Of course that wasn't true, Thom had Taringail killed.

probably hoping Laman would eventually name Galad Hier if Laman saw political advantage in the Trakand union ... Thus leading to his hope of his children each being Monarchs.


Not necessarily. Laman had no children, and the next two men in the line of succession had no children and likely were not much younger than Laman himself. That made it very likely an opportunity for Galad would open eventually. He would likely have been an adult when Laman died, an adult Taringail could have sent back to his House long before Laman's death. Taringail didn't have to have Laman named Galad his heir (we never heard anything about Laman naming an heir, only that any claimant needs support in his own House first to hope to put forward a claim to the throne. Support from the late King would certainly count) to have big hopes he could manage to make his House support Galad's claim one day.


I believe we are missing quite a bit of information on how Galad ended up with a "standard" inheritance.


No we're not. It's all there in NS and the series. In NS neither Moiraine nor the Grey Sitter even mentioned Galad as a possibility, nor Anvaere's children. It's PAINFULLY OBVIOUS children stood no chance whatsoever of being supported for the throne, just like in Andor Luan's granddaugther stood no chance of gaining the support of ten Great Houses and that's why he didn't put it forward.

Taringail's dreams for Galad ended with Laman's untimely death when Galad was still only a small child. An Andoran noblewoman told Rand it was thought this is what embittered him and made him plot against Morgase (though I still don't believe it's necessarily the real story, I think Taringail may very well have fallen in competing traps set for him by Elaida and Thom, both seeking to get rid of him).


Not to mention Moiraine doesn't exactly love her family so I can't see her dropping in to see her half brother at the Caemlyn court.


Moiraine was nearly killed by an assassin (more likely sent by Taringail than by House Riatin, if you ask me...), and she would have lived a long AS life. Whenever she heard of rumors of Taringail's ambitions of course she would have kept an eye on him from afar, she stood ahead of his son in the line of succession and would have the WT's backing... Moiraine had all the reasons to plant spies near Taringail and watch her own back for his assassins. And Riatin's, that might have feared the WT would scheme to place her on the Throne.

And yeah, she didn't visit Caemlyn under Morgase before Thom's exile. Thom would have remembered her visit if she did. He knew her by name, but had never met her. She likely saw Elayne on her way to the Two Rivers. Pure specualtion, but I think Siuan managed to get a meeting with Moiraine (those were very difficult to organize except in official capacity) by asking her formally to visit Elaida and pass her and Morgase all the details concerning the arrangements for Elayne coming to the White Tower. A formal little visit from an envoy from the Amyrlin. That was the excuse to deflect any suspicion from Elaida about Moiraine's presence in Andor.

Galad's daughter would have been a very likely candidate to succeed, but if she was a Damodred she would be ineligeable.


NOT. A. CHANCE. IN. HELL. Matrilinear system. Galad brings no a single line to Ishara to his daughter. The only way Galad's daughter would ever inherit the throne would have been by marrying the Queen of Andor or her daughter-heir, or a woman who managed on her own to claim the throne. That's no doubt what Morgase would have done with her daughter if Tigraine had ruled but never had a daughter, if Dyelin, Ellorien or Luan for his granddaughter didn't beat her to it, that is. Marriage to Tigraine's son, plus the woman's bloodlines from Ishara, plus perception of competence of the woman in question would then have made her a slamdunk to succeed Tigraine.

Otherwise Galad is not of much worth politically in Andor. His real worth to anyone was his Cairhienin connection, and with the ascension of Riatin and Galad's disinterest in politics and distinct lack of ambition in that regard, that worth was actually fairly low, unless an ambitious Andoran noblewoman married him and convinced him to re enter Cairhienin politics, trying to displace Barthanes or succeed him as High Seat and so on.

Otherwise in Andor itself Galad's worth is not terribly high. He would tie a woman to House Trakand, but only as adopted son. It's not nothing, but not that much either. The real catch of the family was Elayne - any nobleman marrying his son to her would have his grandaughter Queen one day. And then Gawyn, but beside a very close alliance with Trakand and a prominent place at court for your grandchildren, that's about it (unless a house has sufficient daughters with good claims and hoped for Elayne not to have any female issue, in which case as niece of the Queen by her brother, that woman stood a good chance to succeed her, under the name Trakand).

No way Trakand would let Gawyn marry outside the House. He holds Trakand lands and their revenues - which Trakand wouldn't want to pass to the children of another House at the detriment of their own, and only during the succession Elayne might have been in a beggar position enought that might have convinced her to "sell" Gawyn to another House if a House made it the price of their support to her claim.





Reply to message
aMoL UK cover and Blurb (SPOILERS!!!!!!!!!) - 21/05/2012 06:44:26 PM 2693 Views
Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 06:46:41 PM 1203 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 08:04:29 PM 1128 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 08:45:41 PM 1034 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 09:04:09 PM 1236 Views
*nods in agreement* *NM* - 21/05/2012 10:46:48 PM 404 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 11:08:50 PM 1077 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 22/05/2012 01:02:16 AM 1062 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 09:35:29 PM 1134 Views
Mat and the madness... - 21/05/2012 10:30:09 PM 1077 Views
Nynaeve's revelation may make the AS even more worried of Rand being mad - 21/05/2012 10:58:37 PM 1100 Views
Not Egwene though... - 21/05/2012 11:02:41 PM 906 Views
Maybe, maybe not ... Nynaeve just gave everyone proof of the extent of his possible madness - 21/05/2012 11:26:41 PM 902 Views
Fair enough. - 21/05/2012 11:31:10 PM 919 Views
Agreed that it's an odd blurb - 21/05/2012 11:45:03 PM 960 Views
Re: Maybe, maybe not ... Nynaeve just gave everyone proof of the extent of his possible madness - 22/05/2012 01:14:05 AM 973 Views
I was thinking about that... - 22/05/2012 02:35:25 AM 871 Views
Re: I was thinking about that... - 22/05/2012 03:41:48 AM 949 Views
Re: Mat and the madness... - 22/05/2012 02:29:31 AM 1024 Views
Rand's dreams... - 22/05/2012 02:42:36 AM 942 Views
She assumes he's mad just like most people assume a 19 year old boy is horney - 22/05/2012 03:47:49 AM 1098 Views
I'd like some evidence for this. - 22/05/2012 04:14:27 AM 901 Views
It's still ingrained in the society - 22/05/2012 01:28:05 PM 1004 Views
Moridin and the link - 28/05/2012 01:45:43 AM 834 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 23/05/2012 01:06:10 PM 874 Views
What caught my eye there was "Trollocs seize Caemlyn." - 22/05/2012 02:12:25 PM 973 Views
As much as I would love Moiraine to go with him to Ebou Dar - 22/05/2012 07:20:40 PM 1044 Views
At this stage, all roads lead to Rand. - 22/05/2012 09:08:42 PM 889 Views
Re: At this stage, all roads lead to Rand. - 23/05/2012 08:07:56 PM 928 Views
Well, like I say, there is no reason they could not ALL meet up with Tuon. - 23/05/2012 08:53:53 PM 911 Views
Re: Well, like I say, there is no reason they could not ALL meet up with Tuon. - 24/05/2012 02:41:55 PM 1041 Views
Aviendha's visions from Rhuidean indicate he will kneel... - 24/05/2012 07:04:02 PM 1304 Views
Re: Aviendha's visions from Rhuidean indicate he will kneel... - 26/05/2012 09:42:20 PM 1445 Views
Agreed... - 26/05/2012 09:57:06 PM 1003 Views
I think you are extrapolating some of his actions into more than he intends - 26/05/2012 10:37:44 PM 881 Views
Re: Agreed... - 27/05/2012 04:26:15 AM 948 Views
I think you're both wrong... - 27/05/2012 08:41:50 AM 953 Views
Re: I think you're both wrong... - 27/05/2012 07:10:08 PM 956 Views
I can't believe Galad will be accepted as a ruler since he is the Lord Captain Commander - 28/05/2012 02:48:26 AM 962 Views
Re: I can't believe Galad will be accepted as a ruler since he is the Lord Captain Commander - 28/05/2012 04:54:46 PM 887 Views
That makes no sense - 28/05/2012 05:50:16 PM 931 Views
Taringail was Laman's heir... - 28/05/2012 07:20:07 PM 876 Views
You are answering the wrong question - 29/05/2012 02:19:48 PM 865 Views
No. I've answered the exact question. You seem to have missed it. - 29/05/2012 04:40:17 PM 915 Views
Yet not one of these things actually happened - 29/05/2012 10:13:35 PM 906 Views
You're being absurd... - 30/05/2012 01:04:36 AM 858 Views
Explain why Taringail didn't become King after Laman's death then - 30/05/2012 05:48:48 AM 829 Views
- 30/05/2012 06:11:02 AM 828 Views
Why then would Taringail, an ambitious man, renounce a Throne? - 30/05/2012 06:22:08 AM 983 Views
We don't fully know... - 30/05/2012 06:43:30 AM 738 Views
You just flipped your last statement - 30/05/2012 06:55:36 AM 974 Views
You seem extremely confused... - 30/05/2012 09:56:30 AM 900 Views
Not confused, simply not satisfied with the information we have - 30/05/2012 12:15:59 PM 868 Views
Re: Not confused, simply not satisfied with the information we have - 30/05/2012 03:34:06 PM 1034 Views
I am not contesting the information we have - 30/05/2012 04:48:08 PM 970 Views
You're impossible... - 30/05/2012 10:02:59 PM 897 Views
Wow ... Not sure what is bringing out the aggression - 30/05/2012 10:19:18 PM 819 Views
*sigh* - 30/05/2012 11:45:28 PM 885 Views
DomA swore *NM* - 31/05/2012 03:39:24 PM 990 Views
Re: That makes no sense - 29/05/2012 04:39:45 PM 1033 Views
Only one other thing... - 29/05/2012 04:53:29 PM 766 Views
Re: Only one other thing... - 30/05/2012 12:32:58 PM 842 Views
Bryne was Captain General not First Prince and Taringail was Prince Consort not FP - 30/05/2012 06:07:48 AM 879 Views
Bryne was First Prince Regent. - 30/05/2012 06:19:33 AM 852 Views
Fair enough ... Thanks for providing a quote - 30/05/2012 06:22:52 AM 1039 Views
Re: Fair enough ... Thanks for providing a quote - 30/05/2012 04:38:29 PM 900 Views
No he wasn't - 30/05/2012 04:16:02 PM 834 Views
No Forsaken will go near that Ter'angreal - 26/05/2012 10:33:20 PM 796 Views
Re: No Forsaken will go near that Ter'angreal - 27/05/2012 03:23:12 AM 876 Views
Aviendha reprogrammed the ter'angreal - 27/05/2012 01:50:19 PM 842 Views
Re: Aviendha reprogrammed the ter'angreal - 27/05/2012 06:44:41 PM 990 Views
I'd have to re-read to be 100% certain, but the way I read the passage - 28/05/2012 02:10:14 AM 953 Views
He might not literally kneel before the ter'angreal, but almost certainly must meet with Tuon soon. - 25/05/2012 03:40:54 AM 1180 Views
Soon might be relative... - 27/05/2012 02:08:53 AM 1373 Views
Sul'dam - 27/05/2012 09:03:57 AM 1228 Views
Re: Sul'dam - 27/05/2012 05:54:57 PM 961 Views
Right, then; here we go.... - 03/06/2012 08:45:20 AM 835 Views
Re: As much as I would love Moiraine to go with him to Ebou Dar - 23/05/2012 05:28:17 PM 890 Views
I think I read a fan fiction like that once *NM* - 23/05/2012 08:04:42 PM 470 Views

Reply to Message