Active Users:432 Time:06/11/2024 04:05:37 AM
So it's better to not bother?! At least by stilling, you force them to make the effort. Cannoli Send a noteboard - 08/05/2012 06:53:17 AM
Stilling may not be all it's cracked to be. A Darklord in the rescue party can undo the stilling and the shadow doesn't lack in dark Ashaman in the Caemlin neighborhood.


I don't know how to say this any more clearly - I am not proposing severing as an alternative to imprisonment, guards and eventually, execution! I am prosposing it SOLELY as an alternative to SHIELDING. With shielding, you have to work to maintain that status, and with any disruption of your efforts, the prisoner can abruptly revert to his or her default status of "dangerous channeler." By severing them, all efforts (or at least an exponentially greater proportion of them) can be turned to guarding against external threats such as a rescue. Not only that, it forces the other side to make the effort to restore the captives when they are rescued. If the bad guys have a channeler handy who is capable of Healing severing, they still do not have any advantage that makes shielding the superior tactic.

If your point was to argue for execution over stilling, well that goes without saying. I'm more of the "cut them down on sight like rabid dogs" school of thought and much prefer the Children of the Lights' response to discovery of Darkfriends to the Aes Sedai treatment of Ispan. The only drawback with summary execution is the finality and the unlikelihood of reversing a mistaken sentence if the suspect is later discovered to be innocent. Stilling, however, is a perfectly acceptable technique to restrain suspects until their guilt can be absolutely proven at a trial. Thanks to Nynaeve and Flinn, it is now possible to restore the ability to the severed captives, for good if they prove to be innocent and arrested by mistake, and temporarily in the case of the guilty if the more obtuse Aes Sedai insist on going through the formal procedures of an "official" stilling before the execution. What is more, severing will free Black sisters of their Oaths, rendering interogation much more practicable.

The fact that the bad guys could reverse such a condition if they rescued the prisoners does not change one iota the practical advantages of severing over shielding.
Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
Elayne - 02/05/2012 11:36:52 PM 1629 Views
Re: Elayne - 03/05/2012 12:15:35 AM 746 Views
Re: Elayne - 03/05/2012 02:36:14 PM 746 Views
Re: Elayne - 03/05/2012 02:47:58 PM 898 Views
Yes, I posted a proposition with that solution years ago. - 06/05/2012 07:25:55 PM 767 Views
With the new healing technology - 07/05/2012 12:08:50 AM 770 Views
So it's better to not bother?! At least by stilling, you force them to make the effort. - 08/05/2012 06:53:17 AM 3190 Views
Although... - 08/05/2012 08:14:55 AM 652 Views
Not to mention that Elayne KNOWS that Stilling them would also have broken their Oaths - 08/05/2012 01:11:31 PM 684 Views
Tower Law is very strict - 08/05/2012 02:12:36 PM 720 Views
See DomA's thoughts below ... - 08/05/2012 11:26:43 PM 787 Views
Not that much - 08/05/2012 10:07:24 PM 714 Views
Torture in WoT - 09/05/2012 05:37:37 AM 852 Views
Huh? - 09/05/2012 03:24:25 PM 745 Views
Many times Elayne remarks on obeying the law - 07/05/2012 06:31:58 PM 698 Views
Re: Many times Elayne remarks on obeying the law - 08/05/2012 10:22:48 PM 780 Views
Re: Elayne - 03/05/2012 03:38:15 PM 1028 Views
The timeline of ToM is messed up... - 03/05/2012 04:43:22 PM 824 Views
Re: Elayne - 03/05/2012 03:38:18 PM 952 Views
Yes, too bad the viewing was wrong and she died...oh, wait.... - 06/05/2012 07:34:43 PM 918 Views
I agree - 07/05/2012 02:25:06 AM 908 Views
Elayne sharing the invasion news... - 07/05/2012 03:38:57 PM 714 Views
I forgot that, thanks - 07/05/2012 05:20:25 PM 837 Views
I don't know that we agree about Elayne... - 08/05/2012 06:40:56 AM 825 Views
Actually, I think we do on most a lot of points - 08/05/2012 08:53:43 PM 719 Views
Re: Actually, I think we do on most a lot of points - 08/05/2012 09:18:01 PM 687 Views
Agree with all of that. Some points to consider... - 09/05/2012 05:45:24 AM 754 Views
Re: Agree with all of that. Some points to consider... - 09/05/2012 09:48:28 PM 808 Views

Reply to Message