Active Users:1128 Time:01/11/2024 12:57:43 AM
I agree... DomA Send a noteboard - 07/03/2012 09:38:18 PM
It's not amazing, but it's not bad, and it's pretty obvious he's not just trying to "cash in"- he's a fan, he's doing the best he can with what he has, and he has a different style.

I definitely don't have the passion for WoT I had 12 years ago when I first started reading PoD, and I can't even imagine how fans from book 1 are feeling. But it's still a good story, still one of the great works of "modern" fantasy, and worth finishing out.


I don't enjoy much the WOT books written by Sanderson personally, but associating them with "fan fiction" is wrong-headed and plain stupid. The fact Sanderson is a fan himself is a plus, it's obvious he has the greatest respect for RJ's work and RJ's intentions, not to mention he's working with RJ's editor and RJ's support team. He's also been a model of generosity, selflessness and openness through the whole process.

The books were released too fast, and there's all sort of little things that are OK for many readers and undermining the reading experience for others, and IMO so far Sanderson/Harriet have made one or two really bad calls (mostly by deciding to publish TGS instead of postponing the release to give Brandon time to finish the four storylines up to TG. 75% of the problems with TGS/TOM have arisen from not doing that, IMO).

But none of that make the books "fan fiction". FF is written by amateurs stealing a setting and characters from a writer for their own "creation", and not in any way concerned with respecting the original work. The Sanderson books are giving us RJ's story in a form that would not have been RJ's, but it's still for the most part what RJ intended for AMOL (not in the right order, and with story holes filled by Sanderson using the notes when he could and his imagination when he was forced to).
Reply to message
Where will you stop? (after the last book, of course) - 03/03/2012 05:20:14 AM 1353 Views
(after the last book, of course) - Yup *NM* - 03/03/2012 07:28:05 PM 339 Views
looks like your friends have some terrible opinions *NM* - 04/03/2012 03:23:36 AM 276 Views
Shrug, I'll read the series. I think calling BS's work "fan fiction" is doing it a disservice - 06/03/2012 09:12:23 PM 647 Views
I agree... - 07/03/2012 09:38:18 PM 717 Views
Agreed. We're lucky to have Sanderson - 10/03/2012 06:40:57 PM 668 Views
there will come a time when I will re-buy and re-read all books. - 07/03/2012 08:59:35 PM 662 Views
After the last book - 09/03/2012 06:40:44 PM 651 Views

Reply to Message