Active Users:1174 Time:22/11/2024 10:57:31 AM
No, you are not. Cannoli Send a noteboard - 19/02/2012 03:44:04 AM


Incidentally, am I the only one who finds it strange that in a novel written by an American, during this threat or revolution against a distant, irresponsible monarch we are expected to side with the monarch?


What's more, although Texas gets all the attention, Robert Jordan's home state, South Carolina, was the cradle of the notion that the smaller components of a country can tell the overall government to go f*** themselves. South Carolina was the first state to secede from the USA in 1860, and they had several times threatened to leave prior to that in response to taxes on imports (like Elayne plans to impose on the Sea Folk who seek to bring goods inland from their enclave) and which were imposed in order to protect industries in other parts of the country (in the USA, it was northern manufacturers, which did not benefit SC at all - meanwhile, we have that quote from tSR where Elayne is recalling that her mother taught her which crafts she had to "protect". Any sane economist or historian could tell the Trakands that in a pre-industrial tech level THERE IS NO SUCH THING as a craft that needs protection! ).

Anyway, the issue regarding the Two Rivers vis a vis Andor is highly analogous to that of the American colonies vs. England. England left them alone to govern their own affairs for a while (known as statutory neglect), and then, when they had begun building up into a sizable economy that was more profitable to exploit, and England was able to acquire a lot more land adjacent to them in the Seven Years War, they decided they should start telling the colonies how to manage their affairs. Despite holding their loyalties to the king even as they deplored the illegal actions his government took against them, the colonies finally fought back in defense of their natural rights, upon which the British were infringing. The Two Rivers have managed their own affairs, seen to their own defense, and have received no benefits from Andor, nor acknowledged its rule. By all the principles of natural law, "they are and of right out to be (a) free and independent state..." Elayne has the same moral right to rule the Two Rivers that an armed robber has to the goods in your house.
Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
Bad Elayne! No biscuit! - 18/02/2012 10:13:54 PM 2146 Views
You are assigning your 21st century view onto people with totally different circumstances - 18/02/2012 11:33:56 PM 877 Views
The Queen of Andor lost all authority over the Two Rivers when she failed to protect it. *NM* - 25/03/2012 02:53:23 PM 438 Views
Which is why they elected their own lord - 25/03/2012 06:25:31 PM 790 Views
Feudal law. - 25/03/2012 07:52:25 PM 842 Views
Not quite... - 25/03/2012 08:34:49 PM 766 Views
All that, PLUS.. - 25/03/2012 09:55:26 PM 969 Views
Re: Not quite... - 26/03/2012 03:53:46 PM 1013 Views
And she has not tried to exert authority over them - 25/03/2012 10:33:44 PM 856 Views
Yes, absolutely. I remember saying this back when I first read the book. - 18/02/2012 11:44:19 PM 1147 Views
No, you are not. - 19/02/2012 03:44:04 AM 890 Views
Re: Yes, absolutely. I remember saying this back when I first read the book. - 20/02/2012 03:11:14 AM 1240 Views
Re: Yes, absolutely. I remember saying this back when I first read the book. - 20/02/2012 06:22:21 AM 789 Views
Failed to click "Edit" instead of "Reply". - 20/02/2012 06:23:18 AM 874 Views
"Damn sister married the Pope instead of my chosen Lord Ohsoimportant" - 25/03/2012 03:50:06 PM 935 Views
Nobles and Ishara's blood - 03/04/2012 02:59:03 PM 833 Views
Okay, I admit it, there is no way I am reading such a long post about Elayne..... - 19/02/2012 08:14:53 PM 835 Views
it was a bear to read but enlightening none the less. *NM* - 20/02/2012 08:49:35 AM 456 Views
The Caraline treatment. - 25/03/2012 02:41:12 PM 800 Views
Do you Colavaer Saighan? I don't recall Caraline having her lands and titles stripped - 25/03/2012 10:44:57 PM 854 Views
Yes, sorry about the mixup. Names sound the same. *NM* - 26/03/2012 02:52:18 PM 558 Views
Re: Bad Elayne! No biscuit! - 27/03/2012 07:39:05 PM 785 Views
Perrin is Rand's servant, so TR belongs to Rand *NM* *NM* - 12/04/2012 07:30:46 PM 593 Views

Reply to Message