Active Users:1226 Time:23/11/2024 07:00:24 AM
Re: That cliffhanger was similar to what GRRM does... DomA Send a noteboard - 18/08/2011 12:23:55 AM
...and it really pisses me off. He'll often end a chapter with words to make it sound as though someone died, but you can't really tell, and you just spend the remainder of the book wondering.

To me, it's just a stupid case of the author taking advantage of the fact that he's telling the story--it has nothing to do with plot cleverness.


When it's done well, it can be a clever device (John Irving is a master of a variation of this, and it works really well in his books). But I agree it's very gratuitous in most cases with GRRM, and irritating. And I thought of the same comparison as you when I reread ASOIAF last spring.

What I really disliked about Graendal isn't exactly the same, though. I am just convinced this episode would have been far more exciting and far more effective dramatically if it switched back and forth between Rand and Graendal. The way Brandon wrote it, it leaves you with the impression Rand was right or had achieved something. It's really obvious RJ meant this moment to show that Rand was losing his mind, using the CK as a weapon and balefiring away to boot. Graendal's reaction scenes, and her escape, complemented this and drove the point home. They came too late for that in TOM and became all about Graendal's escape as a result. It was too late for most readers to reflect on Rand, as they already knew about his breaking point and his epiphany and didn't care anymore to be shown he had been losing it back then. Brandon traded good dramatic construction for losing half a chapter in TGS and getting a useless cliffhanger (but I suspect his real reason is that he had not figured out back then how he'd use Graendal after her escape, and so decided to tell her fate only in her re introduction scene)
Reply to message
Was Graendal turned? - 14/08/2011 10:12:08 PM 1450 Views
Re: Was Graendal turned? - 14/08/2011 11:12:49 PM 889 Views
Re: Was Graendal turned? - 15/08/2011 01:34:51 AM 1259 Views
Yep - pretty much what I was going to say. - 15/08/2011 04:45:26 PM 727 Views
Yeah. It's too bad BS kind of ruined her character. - 15/08/2011 06:28:55 PM 822 Views
*NM* - 15/08/2011 07:34:31 PM 337 Views
Re: Yeah. It's too bad BS kind of ruined her character. - 15/08/2011 08:52:29 PM 977 Views
That cliffhanger was similar to what GRRM does... - 17/08/2011 10:51:00 PM 820 Views
Re: That cliffhanger was similar to what GRRM does... - 18/08/2011 12:23:55 AM 868 Views
I think this is most obvious with the Perrin at Dragonmount scene. - 18/08/2011 12:45:51 AM 682 Views
Re: I think this is most obvious with the Perrin at Dragonmount scene. - 18/08/2011 01:16:09 AM 832 Views
Not quite correct timing - 18/08/2011 01:10:21 PM 602 Views
Re: Not quite correct timing - 19/08/2011 03:38:21 AM 703 Views
Re: Yep - pretty much what I was going to say. - 15/08/2011 09:33:41 PM 836 Views
Completely agree! *NM* - 15/08/2011 11:13:46 PM 271 Views

Reply to Message