Well, her first choice was made when she chose to flee the palace instead of standing up to Rahvin. And this was realistically her only choice - she tried standing up to him and ended up being very publicly humiliated, and her actions under compulsion had both alienated her allies and weakened her legal position. While she put it down to being lovestruck, she deserves a little credit for at least being able to see that she could not fight Gaebril, even if she didn't understand why.
After fleeing she also only had two choices: she could attempt to oust Gaebril and retake her throne, or she could abdicate and live the rest of her life as an anonymous commoner. Again here I think she made the right choice, though I disagree with the way she went about it. In abdicating she would have turned her back on her duty and let the whole mess fall onto Elayne's shoulders, and though she had really, really screwed up, she was still the queen, with a duty to do whatever it took to remove a traitor from the throne. And as a mother she should have been willing to do pretty much anything to protect Elayne from Gaebril; she was his logical next target.
These decisions, obviously, were made before Morgase knew Gaebril was dead.
After finding out that Gaebril was dead and Elayne had taken the throne, the best thing Morgase could do for her realm - and her daughter - was to abdicate. Merely by being alive she rendered Elayne's claim to the throne false. It was at this point that she should have married Tallanvor and quietly gone to live on some farm in the Black Hills. Accepting service with Perrin, on the basis that she could somehow benefit Elayne by doing so, was to presume on a role and a duty she no longer had, and - as did in the end happen - it made her vulnerable to being recognised.
And in any case she should never have come back to Caemlyn, or let it be publicly known she was still alive. Elayne and Gawyn could have been told privately, and discreet arrangements could have been made to find her somewhere comfortable (and isolated) to live, with a few servants and a bit of an income. Elayne had struggled to overcome conflicts and divisions, and Morgase's mere existence could tear open those barely-healed antagonisms.
The biggest mistakes Morgase made were that, and going to the Whitecloaks. But it must be pointed out that she had spent months under intense and repeated compulsion and that her judgement was very definitely impaired, then and thereafter. I get as irritated as anyone when I have to read her POVs, but I can't help thinking that what Rahvin did to her - the long-term effects it could have had were not unlike some form of brain damage.
After fleeing she also only had two choices: she could attempt to oust Gaebril and retake her throne, or she could abdicate and live the rest of her life as an anonymous commoner. Again here I think she made the right choice, though I disagree with the way she went about it. In abdicating she would have turned her back on her duty and let the whole mess fall onto Elayne's shoulders, and though she had really, really screwed up, she was still the queen, with a duty to do whatever it took to remove a traitor from the throne. And as a mother she should have been willing to do pretty much anything to protect Elayne from Gaebril; she was his logical next target.
These decisions, obviously, were made before Morgase knew Gaebril was dead.
After finding out that Gaebril was dead and Elayne had taken the throne, the best thing Morgase could do for her realm - and her daughter - was to abdicate. Merely by being alive she rendered Elayne's claim to the throne false. It was at this point that she should have married Tallanvor and quietly gone to live on some farm in the Black Hills. Accepting service with Perrin, on the basis that she could somehow benefit Elayne by doing so, was to presume on a role and a duty she no longer had, and - as did in the end happen - it made her vulnerable to being recognised.
And in any case she should never have come back to Caemlyn, or let it be publicly known she was still alive. Elayne and Gawyn could have been told privately, and discreet arrangements could have been made to find her somewhere comfortable (and isolated) to live, with a few servants and a bit of an income. Elayne had struggled to overcome conflicts and divisions, and Morgase's mere existence could tear open those barely-healed antagonisms.
The biggest mistakes Morgase made were that, and going to the Whitecloaks. But it must be pointed out that she had spent months under intense and repeated compulsion and that her judgement was very definitely impaired, then and thereafter. I get as irritated as anyone when I have to read her POVs, but I can't help thinking that what Rahvin did to her - the long-term effects it could have had were not unlike some form of brain damage.
This message last edited by redqueen on 16/05/2011 at 10:38:16 PM
What do you think Morgase should have done?
16/05/2011 08:42:20 PM
- 2048 Views
Much as she did, really.
16/05/2011 10:34:11 PM
- 1061 Views
Agreed. Elayne's most unfortunate trait in ToM is excessive & impolitic loyalty
17/05/2011 02:39:32 AM
- 1014 Views
To be fair, I don't think Elaynes playing "Who's the daddy?" for political reasons.
19/05/2011 08:32:03 AM
- 845 Views
Re: To be fair, I don't think Elaynes playing "Who's the daddy?" for political reasons.
24/05/2011 02:50:30 PM
- 1003 Views
Honestly, Galad joining the Whitecloaks was indictment enough for me.
27/05/2011 11:15:54 AM
- 859 Views
The Children have been entirely seen through the perspectives of their enemies - hardly a fair shot
02/06/2011 11:48:53 PM
- 813 Views
Because the world conveniently divides into "the Children" and "their enemies", by mutual agreement.
03/06/2011 01:44:09 AM
- 801 Views
Re: What do you think Morgase should have done?
18/05/2011 12:32:30 PM
- 1165 Views
Well, Amador wouldn't have been my first choice.
19/05/2011 08:52:46 AM
- 988 Views
Re: Well, Amador wouldn't have been my first choice.
19/05/2011 12:43:21 PM
- 950 Views
I thought Morgase intended to not involve the Whitecloacks at all when she went to Amadicia
19/05/2011 02:08:40 PM
- 825 Views
Re: I thought Morgase intended to not involve the Whitecloacks at all when she went to Amadicia
19/05/2011 08:29:55 PM
- 867 Views
In terms of what I would've done, attempting to regain the throne would not have been it.
20/05/2011 12:21:05 AM
- 727 Views