Active Users:1142 Time:23/11/2024 03:18:33 AM
Re: Mesaana and the Foretelling... DomA Send a noteboard - 13/10/2010 01:32:12 AM
I almost completely agree with what our wrote, except that Mesaana actually doesn't know the right prophesy. Alviarin embellished it a lot, with some points about the Rebels being broken like a rotten melon.

Since that didn't come true at all, it is likely that Mesaana may discount the Prophesy, to her cost.


Mesaana knows foretelling always come true, but her (low) opinion of the talent comes from her belief that they usually become understandable only when it's too late for them to be useful, and them they're all too clear. It's Lanfear who dismissed prophecies as wishful thinking.

Alviarin did not embellish at all (she knows better than to do anything like that - she is trained to report verbatim and her POV states that she does). She reported exactly what Elaida said, including her claims that Alviarin could not differentiate from the foretelling (like the rebels breaking). That's the bit that attracted Mesaana's immediate attention (it touched on her plans) and she asked Alviarin right away if it had been part of the foretelling or not. Then Alviarin (who didn't have the answer - she couldn't tell) was saved as Mesaana mused it wasn't important to know if it was part of the foretelling or not, that either outcome she could use.

So Mesaana was aware from the start that the bit about the breaking of the rebellion wasn't necessarily part of the foretelling. It's more a matter of whether she (or Alviarin) remembers or not the rest about the purge and reunification and the BT which was part of the foretelling, but both Alviarin and Mesaana seem to have an excellent memory.

I wouldn't bet too early that Mesaana or Alviarin didn't remember the foretelling and that it didn't factor into either's late TGS plans.. That could be the explanation how the BA/Mesaana understood lightning fast what was about to happen and decided to escape from the WT, that either figured out they had hours at mos, before the whole game was up. Elaida's foretelling would reveal the only way out left for the BA was flight... Elaida gone and Egwene saved there was only one Amyrlin left, and the foretelling said she'd win and make the Tower whole and stronger than ever, and the BT would be rent in flames...

Consider that this occured hours after the Tower leadership collapsed (Elaida captured, and previously the Keeper and Red Sitters vanished), the Hall no doubt in an emergency meeting, and Egwene had escaped after turning the Seanchan back, opening the door open for a precipitated reunification (if you are willing to see things as they stand for real instead of delusion yourself, Elaida-style.. Either Mesaana or Alviarin was very lucid about how things really stood at that point), and only a shortwhile after envoys were sent to the BT. With their knowledge of Elaida's foretelling,

Mesaana (or Alviarin) could puzzle out, especially if they were warned something was happening at the rebel camp that night, that their games were over and "the tower whole" was about to happen, and.... that a remnant forcibly would escape... to be cast out and scorned... Elaida's foretelling might have factored in the decision to send the rest of the BA out immediately, especially if we discover in TOM Mesaana didn't show up when a panicked Alviarin called her (Mesaana might have concerned herself that night with how she'd manage to remain hidden in the Tower), and Alviarin made the final decision herself to order the flight and warn SH. It seems many BA were caught, because even with an emergency measure of some kind to communicate (that'd be something like Alviarin Travelling to the bedroom of each SC members to order them to go wake their heart and fourth, and order them to pass the order down in person then flee), the BA system was still not up to the task of achieving this in hours, not with so many broken hearts in the chaos after the Seanchan attack. Some BA might also well have panicked and fled before passing the message.

That a rebel BA who escaped gave the alarm in the WT is not so likely (they couldn't know this wasn't also happening in the WT, for one thing), at least unless one of them had a way to reach Alviarin or Mesaana directly, which is unlikely as both are security freaks. As for non BA spies (DF), though it's extremely likely there are some among the rebels, it's hard to see how they could have learned what Egwene planned (the assault, I mean), as Egwene played this very close to the vest and acted damn fast. it's not obvious a non AS spy could reach Mesaana that fast in the wee hours... There remains the possibility Mesaana herself came to spy (visit Sheriam, for eg - and found her not) the second she learned Egwene was gone, to find out if Egwene had gone to the camp, if she knew Elaida had been captured, and what she planned next, and Mesaana realized what was going on. But would Mesaana have cared much to save Alviarin's cohorts, though? Make it a priority? In fear of SH's wrath, maybe...

It's a pity that storyline didn't run in parallel to Egwene's. It would have made it all more suspenseful/exciting in "real time". Now the real mystery left is where the BA has gone. How the BA managed to escape remains quite interesting, but we'll know the final outcome all along.



Reply to message
Jason's review... Looks like DomA was right (Review is now removed) - 25/09/2010 05:40:18 AM 3425 Views
Re: Jason's review (spoilerish thoughts from me, so BEWARE!). Looks like DomA was right - 25/09/2010 06:00:46 AM 1249 Views
Pretty sure it's not Egwene... - 25/09/2010 07:07:00 AM 1181 Views
Oh well - I was wrong - 27/09/2010 03:56:59 PM 891 Views
Ituralde - 25/09/2010 06:29:26 AM 1012 Views
Read the ToM rules - 25/09/2010 07:44:22 AM 933 Views
I officially hate reviews of WoT (in general) - 25/09/2010 08:10:43 AM 1011 Views
I take Jason's reviews with a pinch of salt - 25/09/2010 09:45:10 AM 1077 Views
Re: I take Jason's reviews with a pinch of salt - 25/09/2010 03:50:40 PM 920 Views
Perrin will probably gather the wolves... - 25/09/2010 09:57:06 AM 1069 Views
I suppose Olver could be the one who takes off Mat's eye *NM* - 25/09/2010 10:01:17 AM 492 Views
The review is now gone. *NM* - 25/09/2010 04:10:59 PM 501 Views
Unfortunately, there's not much left for Elayne to do. - 25/09/2010 07:14:09 PM 1113 Views
I haven't read the review but... - 25/09/2010 07:22:48 PM 1501 Views
That's not what I meant... - 25/09/2010 08:25:42 PM 1096 Views
It's odd, I didn't see any reference to Rand descending from DM in his review. - 25/09/2010 08:39:33 PM 937 Views
It was the very last line... - 25/09/2010 08:55:49 PM 1036 Views
Re: It was the very last line... - 25/09/2010 09:03:14 PM 923 Views
Re: It was the very last line... - 25/09/2010 09:54:28 PM 907 Views
Re: It was the very last line... - 25/09/2010 10:09:58 PM 1171 Views
Mike quit being obsessed about 6 years ago (maybe longer?) - 25/09/2010 10:46:23 PM 1005 Views
Re: Mike quit being obsessed about 6 years ago (maybe longer?) - 26/09/2010 01:11:52 AM 1006 Views
I blame JordanCon too. - 26/09/2010 02:17:50 AM 1064 Views
Regarding the WOTFAQ, Tam, - 26/09/2010 10:04:40 PM 978 Views
Re: Regarding the WOTFAQ, Tam, - 27/09/2010 07:20:11 AM 963 Views
Re: Regarding the WOTFAQ, Tam, - 27/09/2010 11:03:35 AM 977 Views
Re: I blame JordanCon too. - 27/09/2010 01:07:59 AM 1046 Views
Re: I blame JordanCon too. - 27/09/2010 07:35:04 AM 1007 Views
Re: That's not what I meant... - 25/09/2010 09:49:17 PM 1205 Views
Some thoughts on a potential meeting... - 26/09/2010 05:11:06 AM 1121 Views
Regarding Brandon's messing up of the timelines... - 25/09/2010 11:34:06 PM 1065 Views
To me it's two different things - 26/09/2010 01:48:13 AM 1156 Views
I agree - 26/09/2010 03:09:04 AM 955 Views
My thought was not that they "dumbed it down" - 26/09/2010 03:50:36 AM 1029 Views
Re: My thought was not that they "dumbed it down" - 26/09/2010 11:42:12 PM 1220 Views
KOD and TOM show where TGS could have been 'fixed' - 26/09/2010 10:27:04 AM 960 Views
Re: KOD and TOM show where TGS could have been 'fixed' - 26/09/2010 09:35:41 PM 1090 Views
Whose really to blame though? - 27/09/2010 03:43:30 AM 941 Views
A suggestion? - 26/09/2010 11:39:08 AM 1089 Views
Is there a copy of the review somewhere? *NM* - 27/09/2010 01:40:22 AM 579 Views
The review is back up... - 27/09/2010 01:59:50 AM 936 Views
It wasn't quite identical... It was missing the line about Rand walking down from DM - 27/09/2010 06:42:47 AM 940 Views
The line about Rand wasn't there when I read the review Saturday morning either. *NM* - 27/09/2010 01:57:00 PM 428 Views
It was... - 27/09/2010 04:22:24 PM 794 Views
I must have missed it then. It does fit with Tor's not releasing Chapter 1 early. *NM* - 27/09/2010 05:06:36 PM 439 Views
What do you mean? - 27/09/2010 11:33:15 PM 850 Views
It was at the very bottom of the post and hard to find - 28/09/2010 12:44:56 AM 742 Views
Olver - 27/09/2010 11:34:40 AM 1090 Views
He's Demandred, natch. - 27/09/2010 03:54:09 PM 836 Views
Re: Olver - 27/09/2010 05:42:25 PM 890 Views
Re: Olver darkfriend? - 28/09/2010 12:02:11 AM 950 Views
'Tis a shame. I love spoilers. - 27/09/2010 03:16:02 PM 956 Views
One problem with the idea of a Rand-Egwene meeting in Chapter 1 beyond timeline issues - 27/09/2010 10:29:15 PM 873 Views
Not true... - 28/09/2010 01:00:40 AM 861 Views
Good call. I assumed, and still do, that the two events are one in the same. - 28/09/2010 01:10:13 AM 939 Views
I don't think so... - 28/09/2010 01:47:40 AM 788 Views
Re: I don't think so... - 28/09/2010 02:00:59 AM 848 Views
Re: I don't think so... - 28/09/2010 03:07:08 AM 1681 Views
Not true indeed... and.... - 28/09/2010 02:24:00 AM 1098 Views
Mesaana and the Foretelling... - 28/09/2010 03:31:24 AM 827 Views
Re: Mesaana and the Foretelling... - 13/10/2010 01:32:12 AM 1160 Views

Reply to Message