Active Users:1175 Time:22/11/2024 04:50:50 PM
Re: Its way too specific for that... DomA Send a noteboard - 19/09/2010 01:57:10 AM
Mat noted it, but said it could be the result of reports about raken from the south. But most raken have been in Arad Doman for a long time.


Not a long time. A few weeks. Suroth sent them west at the beginning of KOD, and right before Malden they were back in Altara, after Galgan had them recalled. The returned scouts spotted Galad at the end of KOD, and Tylee could have to'raken again to send the Shaido captives to Ebou Dar. Northern Altara and the passes to Murandy are crawling with Seanchan armies and patrols. It's hardly surprising that rumours of the flying beasts have reached Caemlyn, and the Seanchan's hatred of AS is well-known.

The beasties assigned to the east had been back in the east for quite some time when Tuon launched the attack on the WT.

That the Mat scene could take place after the battle at Tar Valon and Egwene's reunification doesn't make any kind of sense.

Calculate it any way you want, this would contradict not only the timeline of TGS that we can figure it out, but also everything Brandon has said not only about the timeine, but also about the structure of TOM... with Perrin having a lot of catching up to do, and Mat a bit less but still some catching up to do. You have Mat already ahead of Egwene and Rand by chapter 8. This doesn't make any sense, and even less when you consider there's so much "recap" and bringing up to speed in this chapter that it almost certainly is the first Mat chapter in TOM.

For Mat to be in Caemlyn for much less than 30 days, and this to coincide with the reunification of the Tower, he would have had to spend many weeks between Hinderstap and meeting Verin...

I mean... we know exactly when Mat's first scene in TGS happened, to the day. We also know to the exact day when Tuon reached Ebou Dar. Brandon stated there were weeks between her meeting with Rand and the attack on the Tower. He also stated clearly that TGS covered about or slightly over 3 months, and that Mat reached Caemlyn 30 days before the climaxes of TGS (also that Egwene's and Rand's endings coincided to the day...), and in chapter 8 Mat mentions he's weeks away from the end of those 30 days... Do the math. Unless Brandon and Maria did a MASSIVE screw-up of the timeline, the attack of the Seanchan on the Tower is weeks away from that Mat scene.

That wouldn't be a first that rumours are used for ironic foreshadowing in WOT by being all too close that what will happen. Jordan used that device a few times (incl. at the end of TPOD, IRRC - foreshadowing the reunification and the Seanchan attack, and stuff that hasn't yet come about war between the Asha'man)

Had the Seanchan attack happened, there would be a lot more than just a rumour floating in Caemlyn. Pigeons from Tar Valon would have flown to most cities with the specifics, especially to Caemlyn. There's a big hole in the White Tower, for crying out loud... Elayne would already be on the war path, preparing for the eventuality of a similar attack on the BT or on Caemlyn. Everybody was counting on the Seanchan avancing slowly... Tar Valon changes all that, and it won't escape Elayne that the Seanchan may well have stolen the secret of Travelling if they attacked the Tower. Keep in mind that with the reunification and her freedom, Egwene has no motive not to contact Elayne.

Nah... clearly those rumours are just rumours. I can't believe Brandon and Maria could mess it up so massively. That's no little mistake, it would screw up the whole continuity since KOD!!

Further elements that suggest you're wrong is that no rumour concerns a large group of AS arriving in the city (the rebel envoys). On the timeline as described by Brandon, they should arrive soon, but they shouldn't be there yet.
This message last edited by DomA on 19/09/2010 at 01:59:26 AM
Reply to message
*SPOILERS* Discussing Chapter 8 (chapter revealed by the great hunt) - 17/09/2010 07:01:34 AM 2610 Views
I noticed the timeline thing right away. - 17/09/2010 07:15:49 AM 865 Views
It has been confirmed that the rumors are just that - rumors. - 19/09/2010 12:43:57 AM 969 Views
long arse post - 17/09/2010 07:18:13 AM 1205 Views
Disagree. Mat is still off. Can't really point out why... - 17/09/2010 05:12:55 PM 735 Views
He was just slightly off. Much, much closer than TGS though. - 17/09/2010 05:19:07 PM 734 Views
That golden haired woman in the inn (Clare?) is Birgitte in disguise. Mark me. *NM* - 17/09/2010 09:51:28 AM 380 Views
Oh snap!! - 17/09/2010 10:20:07 AM 870 Views
Elayne could just be trying to hide her pregnency from Mat - 17/09/2010 10:57:22 AM 920 Views
Re: Elayne could just be trying to hide her pregnency from Mat - 17/09/2010 12:30:32 PM 806 Views
Re: Elayne could just be trying to hide her pregnency from Mat - 17/09/2010 02:32:11 PM 933 Views
Well your post is dammning the possibility of Graendal being involved with Elayne - 17/09/2010 04:43:31 PM 1275 Views
#2 ---not enough info - 17/09/2010 05:08:17 PM 808 Views
But speculation is so fun.... - 17/09/2010 06:13:19 PM 973 Views
Also, something is very wrong with this suggested timeline in your post - 17/09/2010 05:03:50 PM 900 Views
Yes and... - 17/09/2010 10:26:48 PM 926 Views
Tinkers and Rhuidean - 20/09/2010 12:38:28 AM 634 Views
AOL I-Pod... very funny *nm* *NM* - 23/09/2010 07:24:44 PM 320 Views
Seems like Verin and Moiraine are already on balance scales. - 17/09/2010 05:17:35 PM 791 Views
It's either Verin or Elayne and Moiraine, but... - 17/09/2010 05:22:06 PM 795 Views
The rumour is almost certainly just a rumour.... - 17/09/2010 07:41:48 PM 941 Views
Occam's razor suggests you're right... - 17/09/2010 09:27:48 PM 758 Views
Re: Occam's razor suggests you're right... - 17/09/2010 09:45:36 PM 825 Views
<waves hands placatingly> - 17/09/2010 10:36:20 PM 827 Views
Its way too specific for that... - 18/09/2010 04:16:31 AM 750 Views
Re: Its way too specific for that... - 19/09/2010 01:57:10 AM 1251 Views
Just a general question, some admin/mod/whoever can explain. - 18/09/2010 01:06:37 AM 766 Views
Nice chapter! - 18/09/2010 11:01:44 AM 911 Views
Wow, someone really likes using Mat's name! - 19/09/2010 11:08:02 PM 675 Views

Reply to Message