RJ and BS said it should be possible to figure it out
Etzel Send a noteboard - 01/08/2010 06:51:03 PM
BS just recently said:
Okay, @DirektorDoom asks a question I get on tour. "Is it possible to figure out Demandred's identity with the information we have?
And now, Theoryland is holding its breath. I think I might have actually answered on tour. I'm not sure what RJ said on the matter, but... I will say only this. There ARE clues. I think it could be figured out. Maybe. It's much, much harder than Asmo's killer. Obviously, I must be tight-lipped. Can it be figured out: Yes. Will it make you smack your heads & say "I should have seen it!" Probably not."
Let me add the official clarification onto what I've said: Basically, I'm not merely talking about "Alter Ego" here when I reply to the "Figure out Demandred's Identity" question. I look at that question as a larger "What he's been up to, what he's been influencing, where he's hiding" that sort of thing.
Why make this distinction? Well, it's because of things that (likely) others have figured out already. Demandred hasn't been in-guise in the books at least up to KoD. So energies focused on "exactly who is he" would be pointless, to an extent. If he is indeed imitating someone, you haven't seen that someone through most of the series. At least not in person. You may have seen them now, but if so, they haven't been on-screen for long.
So, what I'm saying is basically this: There are clues as to what Demandred is up to. You could figure that out. I think it would be hard, but not so hard that someone won't guess it. (And, knowing WoT fandom, someone probably has.)
And now, Theoryland is holding its breath. I think I might have actually answered on tour. I'm not sure what RJ said on the matter, but... I will say only this. There ARE clues. I think it could be figured out. Maybe. It's much, much harder than Asmo's killer. Obviously, I must be tight-lipped. Can it be figured out: Yes. Will it make you smack your heads & say "I should have seen it!" Probably not."
Let me add the official clarification onto what I've said: Basically, I'm not merely talking about "Alter Ego" here when I reply to the "Figure out Demandred's Identity" question. I look at that question as a larger "What he's been up to, what he's been influencing, where he's hiding" that sort of thing.
Why make this distinction? Well, it's because of things that (likely) others have figured out already. Demandred hasn't been in-guise in the books at least up to KoD. So energies focused on "exactly who is he" would be pointless, to an extent. If he is indeed imitating someone, you haven't seen that someone through most of the series. At least not in person. You may have seen them now, but if so, they haven't been on-screen for long.
So, what I'm saying is basically this: There are clues as to what Demandred is up to. You could figure that out. I think it would be hard, but not so hard that someone won't guess it. (And, knowing WoT fandom, someone probably has.)
i'm doing it, it's the reread!
- 31/07/2010 10:28:54 AM
815 Views
Re: i'm doing it, it's the reread!
- 31/07/2010 11:20:53 AM
583 Views
Or maybe the apparently even more difficult question, who and where Demandred is. *NM*
- 31/07/2010 12:28:48 PM
217 Views
I forget, did RJ ever say we should be able to work this one out? *NM*
- 01/08/2010 06:46:09 PM
189 Views
RJ and BS said it should be possible to figure it out
- 01/08/2010 06:51:03 PM
479 Views