Active Users:1098 Time:22/11/2024 10:11:07 PM
Physical limitations make sense, BUT...: Joel Send a noteboard - 29/06/2010 12:30:33 PM
Cadsuane and the WO aren't the only ones who could deduce Cadsuane kept the domination band and where. She intended to test it eventually on an Asha'man, but still had to convince Rand to let her (she had made another attempt in chapter one). Her followers and probably pretty much everyone present at Semirhage's capture probably knew about that (it's when Cadsuane grabbed the objects...). Cadsuane had promised Rand it was safe.

Most importantly, notice that at the first meeting with Cadsuane upon their arrival, Bair and Sorilea already knew Cadsuane had male/female a'dam and took the initiative to ask her about that. Cadsuane wasn't in any way surprised that they knew. They knew she was the one keeping them. So, it wasn't a secret that Cadsuane had the DM.

Her hiding place wasn't quite "clever": in her room, in a trunk. Riiiight. No one would search her room first, no one would look in her trunk after trying her jewels box. Cadsuane sinned by overconfidence. She thinks she has everyone under control, and that inverted weaves can't be detected. She was wrong.

The other obvious fact: Cadsuane has not even wondered (nor Nynaeve, nor the WO) how the Shadow could find the DM. There was no hunt for the DF who led Elza/Semirhage to it, for the good reason everyone knew Elza needed no one telling her Cadsuane had the DM, and Cadsuane's hding place had been all too obvious to any BA in the group, and Elza/Semirhage just had to wait until Cadsuane was out of the building to steal it. Had Bair and Sorilea been the only ones to know, Cadsuane would have suspected them immediately.

We also know it's Shaidar Haran who made Elza steal the DB. It's probably him who could detect wards. Most likely he asked Elza in the first place where the a'dam taken from Semirhage were. Elza answered "probably in Cadsuane's room". SH made her search it, they found the warded trunk, and SH taught Elza how to unravel the ward (yes, she probably used the TP for that. SH couldn't do it itself because of limitations to its interaction with the physical world).


I find that supremely unlikely for several reasons.

1. Even in the WoP and the Collapse only 29 people were ever allowed access to it, and from Moghedien's POV that was seen as a great honor.

2. At this point only Moridin is allowed access, why make a big point of telling us this if the DO was going to hand a peon like Elza access for a minor task?

3. Bsand's comments that Elza had been taught weaves not used since the AoL in explanation seems to indicate that she simply used saidar to unravel Cadsuane's ward.


Brandon told us that Elza was taught some rarely known weaves. There's no reason to doubt that they were weaves of saidar. We don't even know who taught her.


Taught by whom? Who but a Forsaken would know those "rare weaves" to teach Elza?

Not Semirhage, she was a prisoner then. There's no evidence another female Forsaken was involved, and it makes little sense to use Elza to free Semirhage if another Forsaken was there and could do it, or to let Semirhage deal with Elza's compulsion if the all-time specialist Graendal was with SH. Mesaana? Unlikely, after what happened in the prologue. The mindtrapped pets? It makes even less sense than the others that SH would not simply have had one of them do the deeds if he had one with him.

There's also the matter of Cadsuane's inverted wards. In the Forsaken know "rare weaves" to unravel them, what's all the fuss they're making about Rand's wards? Demandred and the others have had like forever to loot the vaults in Tear, and take Callandor, and there they don't have Mesaana's motive not to raise the alarm in the Tower unless she needs something really badly.

So, that leaves Shaidar Haran. How likely is it that he can teach rare weaves of saidar? To quote you, the chance of that is zero. But what are the odds he can teach and give permission to tap the True Power? Excellent odds, I would say. "Rarely known weaves" can perfectly be an euphemism for TP weaves, all the more since Brandon also said the whole experience was most unpleasant for Elza. Let her use the TP this once for a special mission for SH is pretty harmless too - she won't be able to tap it anymore without express permission. We also know SH didn't do all this himself and he had to use Elza because, as Brandon explained, he is limited in how he can interact with physical reality. That suggests strongly SH was acting alone in this mission.

Semirhage felt nothing of what Elza did to kill the two women outside. No other woman around did either. All Semirhage noticed was that her shield was gone all of a sudden. No one in the manor felt any of Elza's channelling either. She stole the DM in complete immunity.

There's a whole lot speculative stretching to do to have her learn rare saidar weaves, and while there's no definitive proof she was taught to use the TP, the chance it's precisely what she did are much higher than zero. Over 50% is more like it...

we do know that SOME physical interaction is possible. Raping Mesaana, for example. We further know that he can negate the ability to channel the OP. Given those two things and the fact that he's evidently "Uber-Fade" it's not hard to see how he could kill an Aes Sedai the old fashioned way. This goes back to my concerns about Rand losing the benefits of being a blademaster when he lost his hand: Without the ability to just slap SH around with balefire or something he'd be forced to resort to conventional combat, and in conventional combat SH could literally rip most people apart with his bare hands.
Honorbound and honored to be Bonded to Mahtaliel Sedai
Last First in wotmania Chat
Slightly better than chocolate.

Love still can't be coerced.
Please Don't Eat the Newbies!

LoL. Be well, RAFOlk.
Reply to message
So, Is Bair a Darkfriend, or Sorilea? - 27/06/2010 09:19:22 AM 3672 Views
Maybe they found it with need? - 27/06/2010 11:28:44 AM 1001 Views
But Semirhage didn't find it. Elsa did, or SH. - 27/06/2010 01:18:52 PM 1290 Views
I brought up the potential for Sorilea in the past - 27/06/2010 03:02:51 PM 1116 Views
Another good point. - 29/06/2010 11:43:11 AM 1074 Views
A good point. - 29/06/2010 11:38:51 AM 866 Views
Re: But Semirhage didn't find it. Elsa did, or SH. - 29/06/2010 09:36:03 PM 1042 Views
yeah, Verin Compelled all the captive AS in the Aiel camp - 29/06/2010 09:41:33 PM 1129 Views
Would that work, I wonder? - 29/06/2010 11:24:42 AM 916 Views
Re: Maybe they found it with need? - 08/07/2010 07:18:04 AM 711 Views
What if it was Shadar Haran that found it? - 27/06/2010 05:01:52 PM 950 Views
It's possible, but not likely, IMHO. - 29/06/2010 11:46:08 AM 880 Views
Ĵust to point out the obvious... - 27/06/2010 05:58:55 PM 1048 Views
You really think Elza used the TP? - 28/06/2010 05:35:20 AM 826 Views
I think the chance of that is zero - 28/06/2010 07:56:10 AM 954 Views
Re: I think the chance of that is zero - 28/06/2010 01:48:10 PM 987 Views
Re: I think the chance of that is zero - 28/06/2010 06:50:57 PM 918 Views
I agree - 28/06/2010 10:10:04 PM 924 Views
Re: I think the chance of that is zero - 28/06/2010 11:17:19 PM 914 Views
I agree as well - 29/06/2010 09:20:10 AM 859 Views
Sensing the TP - 01/07/2010 07:12:26 AM 730 Views
Re: Sensing the TP - 01/07/2010 08:56:42 AM 699 Views
Physical limitations make sense, BUT...: - 29/06/2010 12:30:33 PM 885 Views
It seems... - 29/06/2010 01:30:17 PM 843 Views
Re: It seems... - 29/06/2010 06:45:19 PM 864 Views
Hmmm.... - 29/06/2010 07:08:30 PM 665 Views
Good points - 29/06/2010 08:16:43 PM 987 Views
That's a good observation - 29/06/2010 08:36:24 PM 858 Views
Yeah, that would make some sense! *NM* - 30/06/2010 09:59:07 AM 770 Views
Some thoughts - 30/06/2010 12:15:25 PM 748 Views
Elza didn't use the true power - 28/06/2010 05:42:29 AM 828 Views
Re: Elza didn't use the true power - 28/06/2010 01:53:32 PM 982 Views
It doesn't appear that anything else in her room was searched. - 29/06/2010 12:23:42 PM 803 Views
Re: It doesn't appear that anything else in her room was searched. - 29/06/2010 06:12:14 PM 907 Views
About use of the TP - 29/06/2010 08:59:47 PM 953 Views
UR WRONG - 27/06/2010 11:09:35 PM 845 Views
AM NOT111 - 29/06/2010 12:32:09 PM 668 Views
I tend to doubt that one of them is a DF - 29/06/2010 09:45:58 AM 744 Views
"Helping" can be a very subjective term. - 29/06/2010 12:37:09 PM 833 Views
Re: "Helping" can be a very subjective term. - 29/06/2010 06:31:11 PM 642 Views
I think it is Sorilea - 29/06/2010 06:40:49 PM 770 Views
Re: I think it is Sorilea - 29/06/2010 07:57:38 PM 842 Views
I like the Melaine theory, but a pregnant WO DF? RJ likes to punish his bad guys too much - 29/06/2010 08:31:01 PM 756 Views
I agree that seems a bit too nasty for RJ - 30/06/2010 08:43:00 AM 777 Views
Re: I like the Melaine theory, but a pregnant WO DF? RJ likes to punish his bad guys too much - 08/07/2010 02:20:32 PM 897 Views
you are likley correct - 08/07/2010 03:09:33 PM 768 Views
Yes, Ingtar - wrong guy lol (posting from work) - 30/06/2010 12:30:54 PM 852 Views

Reply to Message