Active Users:1176 Time:22/11/2024 04:48:42 PM
Re: Quick thoughts on a couple of your complaints. Nate Send a noteboard - 19/05/2013 01:13:08 AM

View original postOn Kirk's death: From what I could tell, there was no indication of how much time passed between "death" and Tribble-eureka. Presumably they'd have taken Kirk out of that compartment and directly to sick bay; it might have been a matter of a few minutes. Even with 2013 medicine, people can be dead for several minutes (even an hour or two if they pass out in a frozen lake or something) and still be revived. It doesn't seem like a huge stretch to imagine that superblood could stave off acute radiation poisoning just long enough to get Kirk to a future-hospital. You don't really have to assume that the blood was capable of fully regenerating a decaying dead body.

Still a cheap deus ex machina to let you kill a character without any consequences. Kirk died before the big ship even went past the Enterprise, if I remember, so it would have been quite a few minutes for that, the crash, Khan to get out of the wreckage, Spock to beam down and chase him and subdue him, and then get him back up there. I know that they froze Kirk to keep him from "dying any more", I guess. The tribble didn't die of radiation poisoning, so it suggests the super blood cures more than just that. Not to mention that they had 72 other super-dudes too, and didn't actually specifically need Khan so badly. And even beyond any of that, I'm pretty sure the Star Trek world will conveniently forget that a good dose of superblood can save someone who has technically died of radiation poisoning.


View original postOn Starfleet headquarters: are you sure that was Starfleet headquarters? The computer stated that because of the malfunctions (or whatever) the target could not be guaranteed. And the ship crashed initially into the ocean, which probably wasn't Khan's intention; that says to me that maybe he missed. Unless I'm forgetting some piece of evidence, which is certainly possible. Anyway it obviously destroyed some buildings and stuff, but I don't remember anything about them being Starfleet buildings in particular.

I did notice the bit with the computer, but if you're going to set a big, tense, spaceship-aiming-for-Starfleet destruction sequence, you really need more than that if the crash was actually nowhere near Starfleet headquarters. It's possible someone mentioned it and I just missed it, but it bugged me a fair bit. I figured the reason it hit the water first was because that was the only way Khan could have credibly survived the crash landing.

Again, I did like the movie. Just not that ending sequence. It felt like entertainment for entertainment's sake, like the movie wanted to do big things without earning them first.

Warder to starry_nite

Chapterfish — Nate's Writing Blog
http://chapterfish.wordpress.com
Reply to message
Star Trek Into Darkness - 09/05/2013 11:21:06 PM 2130 Views
Thanks for the review! Looking forward to this movie big-time. - 10/05/2013 03:43:37 AM 862 Views
You really love getting spoiled, don't you? - 10/05/2013 02:37:39 PM 867 Views
I do like spoilers! - 10/05/2013 03:36:00 PM 820 Views
Re: You really love getting spoiled, don't you? - 11/05/2013 11:38:06 PM 1438 Views
This review really has my fingers itching - 11/05/2013 06:33:58 PM 872 Views
I could write a reply with lots of spoilers, I suppose - 11/05/2013 08:30:06 PM 847 Views
Alright, let's talk massive Spoilers. You really shouldn't...until you've seen it. - 15/05/2013 03:27:41 PM 954 Views
is it wrong I was lauging my ass off when ... ((SPOILER)) - 17/05/2013 07:38:09 PM 893 Views
I think, as a fan of the original story, this was very well-done. - 18/05/2013 02:04:22 AM 1143 Views
Amazing...I completely agree with Cannoli's post. - 30/05/2013 04:58:39 PM 853 Views
It's because I like movies... - 31/05/2013 04:02:38 PM 871 Views
I think you just like summer Hollywood blockbusters. *NM* - 10/06/2013 05:16:55 PM 482 Views
How is David Marcus of "Wrath of Khan" such a pussy when he's the grandson of Thor & Robocop? - 18/05/2013 01:30:24 AM 1045 Views
Starfleet's militarization - 18/05/2013 06:12:44 PM 1019 Views
I found that to be 90 percent of a fun movie. (spoilers) - 18/05/2013 10:58:30 PM 875 Views
Quick thoughts on a couple of your complaints. - 19/05/2013 12:57:28 AM 1162 Views
Re: Quick thoughts on a couple of your complaints. - 19/05/2013 01:13:08 AM 1019 Views
Re: Quick thoughts on a couple of your complaints. - 19/05/2013 08:25:36 AM 1117 Views
The film was an acceptable, but unremarkable addition to the franchise - 19/05/2013 04:01:41 PM 1004 Views
Loved the homage to Wrath of Khan..... - 22/05/2013 04:26:07 AM 825 Views
It was more humorous than serious, came off wrong to me - 22/05/2013 05:01:56 AM 901 Views
To me it came off as a nice homage, but that was precisely my problem with the film. - 10/06/2013 05:12:13 PM 1007 Views
I couldn't agree more - 10/06/2013 05:52:52 PM 888 Views
I thought the same. *NM* - 06/06/2013 10:11:43 PM 394 Views
Just saw it.....one of the best Star Trek movies ever! - 22/05/2013 04:20:22 AM 832 Views
Definitely. Even though competition isn't that big - 22/05/2013 04:05:19 PM 974 Views

Reply to Message