Active Users:1144 Time:22/11/2024 07:55:51 PM
Yes Cannoli Send a noteboard - 25/08/2011 07:31:25 PM
Cannoli, had you posted it before, I did I see it somewhere else?

I'm pretty sure I posted it here or on the appropriate MB on wotmania. In longer form, of course.

If Tarkin had deciced to take the Death Star to say the capital and try to blow up the Emperor the officers may have gone along with it but that's when Vader's role would have kicked in and no more Tarkin.


Yes. If you think about it, their command functions more closely resemble that of a Soviet commanding officer (Tarkin) and a commissar or political officer (Vader). Also, I maintain that the "weak point" in the original Death Star served a similar purpose, especially for the scenario you describe. From the attitudes of the Death Star's command staff, deciding that as the men who control "the Ultimate Power in the Universe", THEY should be running the Empire and not the geezer in the bathrobe, whose only claim to rule (now that he has undermined his Senate-granted authority by disbanding said Senate) is his theoretical possession of a power they do not even believe in. From there, it is a matter of flying the Death Star to Coruscant and ordering the administration to ignore bathrobe-boy if they don't want to get blown up. The hole you could blow up the Death Star by shooting, was claimed by the actual pilot to be an impossible-to-hit shot and only the guy who had never flown an X-wing disagreed with him. We later see that the leader of the team tasked with hitting the weak spot fails to make his shot. When Luke is going for it, ObiWan comes back from the grave to tell him to switch off the computer and use the Force, which Luke has never done in his life, in a life-or-death situation. Plainly the Force was required or the computer would have been a better bet. Otherwise, it looks like Obi-Wan is endangering the mission and the survival of the entire rebellion just to get Luke some more practice.

Therefore, if the weak spot was made so that only the Force could hit it, it seems highly likely that the Emperor or Vader had it deliberately installed as a fail-safe just in case their Force-agnostic military command (and you don't put anyone but your most trusted and loyal commanders in charge of weapons like a Death Star) decides to turn their toy against the Sith Lords. TIE fighters are supposedly short-range fighters that could not be out in space alone, but Vader has a special one that allows him to get back to the Imperial Fleet or territory after the Death Star blows. Why give him such a fighter based out of an "indestructible" battle station? Unless the plan was for him to use it if he had to destroy the Death Star...

Also note how Vader takes the threat of the rebel fighters seriously, while Tarkin scoffs at the possibility of them doing any harm. Almost like he knew they could do it, but Tarkin was kept in the dark.
Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
This message last edited by Cannoli on 25/08/2011 at 07:36:25 PM
Reply to message
Star Wars: The Prequels Strike Back - 23/08/2011 05:22:54 PM 1631 Views
Heh, Anakin = Mark Zuckerberg *NM* - 23/08/2011 05:53:16 PM 476 Views
The music - 23/08/2011 11:00:13 PM 776 Views
point 4 of the "bad things about the original movies" is kind of weak - 24/08/2011 01:07:01 AM 763 Views
They'll have to refer to these notes when they remake all of them in 10 years - 24/08/2011 04:31:39 AM 858 Views
Re: Vader and Tarkin - 24/08/2011 04:20:43 PM 1216 Views
I like that take. *NM* - 24/08/2011 05:18:21 PM 446 Views
That's kind of how I saw it. *NM* - 24/08/2011 11:00:32 PM 494 Views
Also, it makes the military guys feel better if they see the chain of command at work. - 25/08/2011 01:53:02 AM 942 Views
On that last statement... - 25/08/2011 09:27:01 AM 784 Views
Yeah, I've seen that theory before - 25/08/2011 02:27:29 PM 799 Views
Yes - 25/08/2011 07:31:25 PM 780 Views
Nice theories *NM* - 26/08/2011 08:26:20 AM 899 Views
Good stuff. And there are many more. I like the PT better than the OT. - 24/08/2011 07:48:19 PM 794 Views
I don't want to alarm you, but you might be a monster. - 24/08/2011 07:54:17 PM 737 Views
Most people I know under age 22 or so prefer the PT. *NM* - 24/08/2011 09:07:10 PM 444 Views
So the real question is ... - 24/08/2011 09:19:51 PM 860 Views
I'm 26, but it's pretty close. - 24/08/2011 11:46:39 PM 806 Views
No offense - 25/08/2011 12:10:17 AM 859 Views
I'm 38, and I do love the PT - 25/08/2011 12:45:11 AM 758 Views
I agreed with so much of what you said, then I cried. - 25/08/2011 01:39:45 AM 910 Views
Traviss's Mandalorian fan-fiction makes Kevin J Anderson almost tolerable by comparison - 25/08/2011 02:11:41 AM 995 Views
Ugh Zahn was so boring. *NM* - 25/08/2011 04:00:28 AM 435 Views
Four of his five books are among my favourite Star Wars entries. - 26/08/2011 01:42:29 PM 749 Views
I, too, loved the Thrawn trilogy *NM* - 26/08/2011 02:15:18 PM 383 Views
He actually wrote at least eight. - 12/09/2011 07:33:28 PM 776 Views
Thankyouverymuchindeed. - 24/08/2011 09:04:54 PM 790 Views
I'm not even going there. - 24/08/2011 09:26:11 PM 826 Views
my biggest complaint about the prequels is - 25/08/2011 12:48:13 AM 736 Views
I mostly agree - 25/08/2011 01:37:28 AM 902 Views
I tend to consider the prequels to be inferior - 26/08/2011 08:41:46 AM 1029 Views
I still think that James Franco would have been awesome as Anakin - 26/08/2011 09:05:48 AM 938 Views
I'd never really thought about it before, but I agree! *NM* - 26/08/2011 02:22:00 PM 490 Views
I'd have to agree as well *NM* - 28/08/2011 12:01:18 AM 473 Views
I've said that before. And they look almost exactly the same. *NM* - 28/08/2011 12:26:29 AM 575 Views
except, imo, Franco looks like a MAN *NM* - 28/08/2011 08:01:03 AM 534 Views
Re: I tend to consider the prequels to be inferior - 26/08/2011 10:26:15 PM 1096 Views
Re: I tend to consider the prequels to be inferior - 27/08/2011 08:25:45 AM 841 Views
It's the Force, stupid. - 25/08/2011 02:46:38 AM 1077 Views
Woah, woah. - 25/08/2011 03:26:02 AM 799 Views
Oops. Sorry. Will fix soonest. - 25/08/2011 07:32:37 PM 905 Views
I still remember how much I adored Episode I - 25/08/2011 08:05:02 PM 1001 Views
The one thing about the PT that I could never get over is..... - 26/08/2011 05:24:12 AM 975 Views
That issue is over four hundred years old. - 26/08/2011 06:09:37 PM 863 Views

Reply to Message