Active Users:1103 Time:22/11/2024 01:16:47 PM
Re: Gotcha, but I don't agree DomA Send a noteboard - 16/07/2011 09:29:52 PM
Except I did two weeks ago.

I must have read those scenes a bit fast, though you mistake me a bit. I didn't get the impression Snape had "a plan", simply that when Voldemort came up with his reasoning that he had to kill Snape because Snape was the master of the wand, Snape could have saved himself (he wasn't the master) but decided no to.


Snape held his wand up at the end, but didn't react quick enough. I don't think there was any decision in the matter. He would have saved himself if he could have. The problem was he was never going to attempt to kill Voldemort or escape Voldemort before being certain that Voldemort had turned on him. When he realized Voldemort's intention, it was too late.


That doesn't work for me (and I think it doesn't fit so well with how Rowling is referring to Snape's death scene as his redemption either. It implies there's a self-sacrifice involved, IMHO).

What you describe is precisely what Voldemort was meant to assume, because Snape played his role to the end and acted exactly as you'd expect a Death Eater about to be betrayed by Voldemort would do. Snape was a consumate expert at lying to Voldermort. To stay true to his mission to the end, Snape had to die without raising any suspicion in Voldemort. He couldn't escape either, let alone appear to sacrifice himself. All Snape could accomplish by his death was convince Voldemort he was now invulnerable to Harry as master of the elder wand, which among other things would mean he might finally relax the protection set around Nagini, a crucial point as Snape knew Harry couldn't face Voldemort before Nagini was killed (something Harry knew as well), or it would all be for nothing, back to square one and this time with a Voldemort who knew how to come back, and knew his horcrux(es) were in danger. When he was forced out of the castle and witnessed that Voldemort no longer let Nagini out of his sight - a big problem - Snape was probably thinking he would eventually be forced to kill Nagini himself while Voldermort's attention was on Harry. Who else could?

I don't really buy either that Snape was so obsessed with telling Harry he had to die, as the last horcrux. Dumbledore had already left Harry that final clue with the snitch and the deathly hallows quest, and Snape was too intelligent to have believed he could convince Harry of anything, as Harry would never have trusted him again (Dumbledore would never have planned things up so part of the plan rely on Snape giving Harry any crucial information. He knew Harry would never trust Snape ever again after Snape killed him). The only reason Harry believed Snape's memories is the fact Snape gave them to him right as he died. It wasn't because they were crucial information to finish Voldermort that he passed those memories to Harry, it was just the last desire of a dying man that Harry finally learned the truth (and they were also the real reason why Snape was so frustrated with Harry's attitude with occlumency, and why he put an end to it after Harry's indiscretion. His indiscretion could have made him find the truth, which would be open for Voldermort to find, ruining Snape's redemption, and it also meant Snape could not reveal himself as an ally to Harry before Voldermort, or as it turned out before himself, died.)
Reply to message
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part Two - 13/07/2011 11:17:42 PM 2863 Views
I'm really, really looking forward to seeing this - 14/07/2011 01:43:17 AM 930 Views
I did read them, I was just fooling around - 14/07/2011 08:10:55 AM 964 Views
It was AWESOME! - 16/07/2011 06:45:41 AM 905 Views
I saw it last night and I agree - 20/07/2011 02:46:18 PM 869 Views
I'm going to the midnight show tonight - 14/07/2011 09:38:28 PM 901 Views
That was freaking awesome! *NM* - 15/07/2011 08:55:48 AM 518 Views
I thought it was just wonderful - 15/07/2011 02:20:43 PM 946 Views
Thinking about the film I found only two things to complain about *major spoiler* - 15/07/2011 03:17:29 PM 1011 Views
Re: Thinking about the film I found only two things to complain about *major spoiler* - 15/07/2011 04:35:07 PM 967 Views
Really?? - 15/07/2011 05:26:25 PM 948 Views
No. Dom needs to re-read me thinks. *NM* - 15/07/2011 08:15:11 PM 537 Views
Re: No. Dom needs to re-read me thinks. - 15/07/2011 08:32:44 PM 982 Views
Gotcha, but I don't agree - 15/07/2011 09:03:50 PM 986 Views
Agreed mostly - 16/07/2011 04:23:07 PM 955 Views
Re: Gotcha, but I don't agree - 16/07/2011 09:29:52 PM 1031 Views
That's how I saw it too *NM* - 16/07/2011 11:38:03 AM 533 Views
There wasn't more to it. - 15/07/2011 08:21:31 PM 1114 Views
Draco - 18/07/2011 07:10:23 PM 984 Views
I sure hope it was better than part one - 15/07/2011 03:47:16 PM 821 Views
I have a nitpick about eye color - 15/07/2011 08:25:18 PM 1071 Views
Yes! - 16/07/2011 11:39:29 AM 919 Views
At the end... - 16/07/2011 06:34:56 AM 1053 Views
I actually did really enjoy it, but (spoilers obv) - 16/07/2011 03:55:08 PM 927 Views
It's a great movie but... - 16/07/2011 04:31:21 PM 1056 Views
Re: It's a great movie but... - 16/07/2011 05:24:43 PM 1130 Views
That change had to be made, just like Frodo/Gollum/Mount Doom..... - 16/07/2011 05:51:39 PM 1065 Views
I didn't want it to be like the book - 16/07/2011 06:39:30 PM 932 Views
I agree completely. - 16/07/2011 07:36:25 PM 1056 Views
You know, I kind of like that better than what happened in the book. - 16/07/2011 10:27:47 PM 955 Views
Re: It's a great movie but... - 16/07/2011 10:00:39 PM 975 Views
Good, but not great. (spoilers) - 17/07/2011 12:19:35 AM 936 Views
Re: Good, but not great. (spoilers) - 18/07/2011 06:06:19 AM 1107 Views
Saw it yestarday, I was f**** crying at the end *NM* - 17/07/2011 04:14:50 PM 513 Views
My only main thrust of complaint ... - 17/07/2011 06:07:50 PM 998 Views
it was alright *NM* - 18/07/2011 08:41:16 AM 564 Views
For me it was incredibly forgettable - 18/07/2011 10:32:59 AM 919 Views
The trick is to not read the books before.. - 18/07/2011 07:16:11 PM 815 Views
Hahahaha - 20/07/2011 02:57:09 PM 1025 Views
Re: Hahahaha - 20/07/2011 09:09:40 PM 880 Views
Very much enjoyed - 19/07/2011 01:00:22 AM 1210 Views
Predictably disappointing, sad to say. - 20/07/2011 11:31:38 PM 932 Views
Re: Predictably disappointing, sad to say. - 31/07/2011 03:58:19 AM 879 Views
Yes, no surprise that you'd have more tolerance for the changes. - 31/07/2011 11:22:41 AM 890 Views
Never read any of the books, but - 30/07/2011 09:35:03 PM 1019 Views
Re: Never read any of the books, but - 31/07/2011 02:35:02 AM 870 Views
The film in one word: Meh. - 10/08/2011 11:25:54 PM 779 Views
Something better like reading the books? *NM* - 13/08/2011 05:46:53 PM 491 Views

Reply to Message