they make Phillip K Dick short stories into movies al the time and it is twice as long as those
random thoughts Send a noteboard - 03/03/2011 09:41:01 PM
There really isn't much fluff in the book so they won't need to cut much out. It seems two movies could be reasonable.
First movie: Introduce Bilbo and Gandalf (the movies have to work as stand alones from LOTR). The whole unexpected party thing will take longer on film then it did in writing. Then you have the trolls, then Rivendell and the trip up the Misty Mountains. I assume the will want to stretch out the scenes with the goblins and Sméagol. Then the escape and the worgs. Then meeting the bear guy whose name I forget. That is a lot of stuff.
Second movie: getting captured first by the spiders then the elves is going to take some time. It will take some time to tell the whole elf story and while that is going on they will want to introduce the humans. To make it mesh with the LOTR better he will need to play the elves more sympathetically and as grander creatures then book did. Then they have to escape the elves and sneak into the lonely mountain. Killing Smaug and the war over the treasure afterwards will take up a huge amount of time. Then you have to bring him home and set up the lead into LOTR.
Sounds like two movies easy and of course they are doing it for the money. You don’t spend hundreds of millions of dollars just to make fan boys happy, you want to make hundreds of millions more.
First movie: Introduce Bilbo and Gandalf (the movies have to work as stand alones from LOTR). The whole unexpected party thing will take longer on film then it did in writing. Then you have the trolls, then Rivendell and the trip up the Misty Mountains. I assume the will want to stretch out the scenes with the goblins and Sméagol. Then the escape and the worgs. Then meeting the bear guy whose name I forget. That is a lot of stuff.
Second movie: getting captured first by the spiders then the elves is going to take some time. It will take some time to tell the whole elf story and while that is going on they will want to introduce the humans. To make it mesh with the LOTR better he will need to play the elves more sympathetically and as grander creatures then book did. Then they have to escape the elves and sneak into the lonely mountain. Killing Smaug and the war over the treasure afterwards will take up a huge amount of time. Then you have to bring him home and set up the lead into LOTR.
Sounds like two movies easy and of course they are doing it for the money. You don’t spend hundreds of millions of dollars just to make fan boys happy, you want to make hundreds of millions more.
Hobbit films may be given separate titles
03/03/2011 02:28:07 PM
- 1069 Views
Interesting
03/03/2011 03:26:21 PM
- 500 Views
Re: I'm not sure they're appropriate titles. Unless he takes a very long time getting back. *NM*
03/03/2011 03:27:19 PM
- 311 Views
I wasn't aware that it was going to be in two parts.
03/03/2011 08:58:30 PM
- 581 Views
they make Phillip K Dick short stories into movies al the time and it is twice as long as those
03/03/2011 09:41:01 PM
- 448 Views
As said many times before: it's not just the plot of the Hobbit. *NM*
03/03/2011 10:18:49 PM
- 212 Views