Just about everyone has been kind of quiet so far, and that's going to make things a lot harder for us. I have gone over everything in Day 1 to look for clues, but there's just not much there.

Like you said, everyone (except Murtach ) benefited from lynching Murtach, so that doesn't help us narrow it down at all.

My problem now is that no one really stands out as being suspicious. I agree that Napoleon's outsider status is probably significant, but it could just as easily (maybe even more easily) mean that he has an important townie role as that he's a darkfriend.

And it looked to me like Blaine was just trying to get some discussion going. I can't fault him for that, because that is what this game really needed.

I really don't know. I had thought I was getting good at finding patterns and inconsistencies from the other game, but there doesn't seem to be anything here.

I will still vote for anyone if a good case is started, because I greatly prefer to do something than nothing.

Does anyone have any good ideas?