Isaac made a quite simple table of post counts, he even counted words (why is more words less scummy btw?)
Artsapat inserted categories:
he wrote:
A - Questions
B - Answers to said questions
C - Accusation (incl Votes and Unvotes)
D - Discussion of Accusation (incl Defense)
E - General discussion of the game mechanics, theme, strategy, etc.
If I do that, I have the following list (Ordered alphabetically by name):
Artsapat (5 posts): 1 B, 3 E and 1 B+E
beetnemesis (2 NM): 1 B and 1 E ("Sorry not much to add" )
Dannymac (1 post, 1 NM): 1 C, 1 B
Fanatic-Templar (3 NM): 1 B, 1 D, 1 E
Fox and Ravens ( 8 posts and 1 NM): 2 B, 2 C (a Vote and an Unvote), 5 E
Hobo (3 posts and 2 NM): 2 B, 3 E
Isaac (11 posts and 2 NM): 1 A+B, 1 B, 3 D, 7 E, 1 E+B
Praziquantel (4 posts and 2 NM): 1 B, 5 E
ranagrande (2 posts and 1 NM): 1 B, 1 C (Vote immediately followed by Unvote),1 E+A+B
Sacrilicious Toast (2 posts): 1 D, 1 E
Taiga (2 posts and 2 NM): 1 B, 1 D, 2 E
Yunalesca (3 NM): 2 B and 1 E
These numbers were the main reason for the witch hunt on FT and Beet at the moment. When I looked back at this post and reviewed the categories it struck me that categorie E is fun to read and gives us a good feeling of playing together, but does nothing for the game reallly. If we distract this category we get the following numbers (name - total posts/total posts without E):
Artsapat – 5/2
Beetnemesis –2/ 1
Dannymac – 2/2
Fanatic-Templar -3/2
Fox and Ravens – 9/4
Hobo – 5/2
Isaac – 13/6
Praziquantel -6/ 1
Ranagrande – 3/2
Sacrilicious Toast –2/ 1
Yunalesca – 3/2
The last number is the thing to look at, because those are posts that have more or less contributed to the progress of the game, being questions, answers, accusations or discussion about accusiations. Beet still stands out at that moment, but also Praziquantel and Sacrilicious Toast have only 1 real contribution, in both cases an answer to Isaac's question. Why didn't anybody jump on them??
Besides those rather outdated numbers, Fanatic-Templar and Beet have contributed extensively since. ST and Prazi have not made a real contribution since the making of those tables IMHO...