Gher's 'lie' reads like a Darkfriend trap, not like trying to deceive the town. It's not like he revealed something and then was found out to have lied. It was more like setting up bat.

Actually, what it really reads like is that he had an idea for what Light and Darkness meant aside from alignment, and upon seeing the results, figured that was impossible, and decided that maybe it alignment after all.

But if you want to lynch Gher, I'll go with it. I don't really have a reason to lynch Hobo, or strong suspicion about him, unlike in the other games, I just know as a concrete fact that lynching no one is worse than lynching someone, and Hobo's just as good a victim as anybody else. If you want to lynch Gher, I'll join up on that too. Just as long as somebody gets lynched.



I don't especially care one way or the other, I don't think it's especially useful, it's just the kind of pointless decision that takes time away from the important stuff. Like lynching someone. I'm from Twilight.