Active Users:1111 Time:22/11/2024 09:08:03 PM
the Hamas Ministry of Stats is likely an under-count Roland00 Send a noteboard - 14/12/2023 12:57:46 PM

View original post
I'm surprised someone as thoughtful as you would buy those.

First, I don't expect you to take IDF reporting, but surely the Hamas ministry of health and UNWRA reporting is at least as biased.

Second, some 60% of the population of Gaza is under 18. I expect they have many fighters who could be classified as children. Many IDF troops are barely more than children.

But really, there is no other option. The US and western governments get that. Elon Musk, god bless him, said he hoped Israel would turn the other cheek. Impossible. But even if you just do a routine, by the numbers, tit for tat, who would be crazy enough to return to living anywhere near Gaza ?
So that would make the massacre a huge win for Hamas and invite more of the same.

But, at the same time, the 7.10 massacre was in a way a blessing.
Israel got off easy, because it seems the Iranian plan was probably to coordinate the same from the North and Gaza at the same time. Imagine 10000 Syrian-war veteran Hizbullah fighters descending on a thinly manned border while people are protesting a judicial reform. Might have taken 6 months to drive them off if at all. Who knows how many dead.

This thought alone, that the north could be captured while I am at the office, makes the ground shake under our collective feet.

So now there is really nothing to it but to kill as many Hamas and friends as possible. And yeah, the hard part will come after, because I have no idea what to do with that black hole.
Personally, I think the PA should control it with IDF backing, sort of reversing the 2005 withdrawl. But that doesn't have much support, so I don't know.




this is due to the 1990s, Palestine and Israel set up the a government beaurcracy that keeps track of things like birth and death records, drivers licenses, etc. It is called the Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories.

Thus when a person dies, and they can identify the body (not always the case), this bureaucracy is supposed to update the death records in both Palestine and Israel, and thus dead person X can not get a work permit and so on. Thus the “official” death count is likely an undercount. For when Hamas was releasing names Israel can confirm that person actually at one time did exist. Now Israel can not confirm that person is actually dead, humans and bureaucracies can lie after all, but it is not out of thin air, and their are other ways to estimate if we want raw numbers instead of treating human beings as unique souls who have now perished.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coordinator_of_Government_Activities_in_the_Territories

=====

Of Course those 2 previous paragraphs are now completely out of date, for those Hospitals and Record Keeping buildings have been bombed, records destroy (on the Gaza side), and the places with partial records still will be slower for there is a war still going on

Likewise with 1.8 million people displaced to different parts of Gaza what is going to kill a whole lot of people is not guns or bombs, but instead water, disease, and starvation. For there is a war still going on, and accounting records are real but they are still a fiction, an item of record we “make” we fabricate to have a better understanding of larger systems. It is merely [ac]-counting.

=====

So I repeat ,with too many words in between, the Hamas Ministry of Stats is likely an under-count. And I do not have total trust in those numbers but I acknowledge if they are in error it is almost certainly the error of undercount. War is happening after all.

Reply to message
The false narrative of the double standard - 09/12/2023 02:33:25 PM 439 Views
ok *NM* - 09/12/2023 07:27:01 PM 67 Views
Is this a good summary, NYT? - 10/12/2023 01:20:47 AM 162 Views
It's as good as any. - 10/12/2023 04:38:59 PM 133 Views
I noticed the OP was mostly opinion - 10/12/2023 05:02:11 PM 136 Views
They dug their own graves - 11/12/2023 12:24:16 AM 142 Views
Re: They dug their own graves - 11/12/2023 03:15:59 AM 135 Views
rhetorical question Mookie (it does not matter the answer) - 11/12/2023 03:45:11 AM 136 Views
I have not - 11/12/2023 02:49:55 PM 150 Views
Yeah that is why I asked - 11/12/2023 04:24:40 PM 126 Views
There's a lot of double standards involved, aren't there? - 11/12/2023 07:02:06 PM 138 Views
We could go on and on with this - 11/12/2023 08:58:28 PM 142 Views
that has NOT been my experience - 11/12/2023 09:18:43 PM 133 Views
Yep, I know. - 12/12/2023 06:18:49 PM 142 Views
Re: Yep, I know. - 12/12/2023 08:04:57 PM 127 Views
Re: Yep, I know. - 14/12/2023 01:33:53 PM 106 Views
Where do you get your stats ? - 14/12/2023 07:09:02 AM 128 Views
the Hamas Ministry of Stats is likely an under-count - 14/12/2023 12:57:46 PM 122 Views
Given the nature of Hamas, the numbers are likely an overcount - 14/12/2023 01:16:00 PM 122 Views
whatever - 14/12/2023 02:50:53 PM 116 Views
Given the choice between believing a Democracy and an Autocratic Terrorist Gov - 14/12/2023 04:01:54 PM 117 Views
Chora I believe both are capable of lying - 14/12/2023 04:16:14 PM 130 Views
To quote you, gurlfriend, "whatever". - 14/12/2023 04:19:10 PM 116 Views
Obviously, anyone is capable of lying. - 14/12/2023 04:30:29 PM 119 Views
the names that Hamas was releasing in October - 14/12/2023 04:49:06 PM 123 Views
What stats are you contesting, exactly? - 14/12/2023 02:12:18 PM 122 Views
Re: What stats are you contesting, exactly? - 17/12/2023 02:34:34 PM 124 Views
Yeah, I'm still confused what you're trying to claim about the numbers - 17/12/2023 10:51:00 PM 116 Views
Out of curiosity, what do you think the best way forward is? - 18/12/2023 03:52:34 AM 145 Views
I'm not sure your view of me on this is that accurate. - 20/12/2023 08:06:23 PM 117 Views
Because no one in the Arab world wants the "Palestinians" - 14/12/2023 01:18:31 PM 125 Views
GDP per capita in Palestine is almost exactly equal to Egypt - 14/12/2023 05:36:55 PM 127 Views
There's always Antarctica - 16/12/2023 03:22:01 AM 110 Views
From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free - 13/12/2023 03:01:21 PM 129 Views
The idea is free from foreign oppression - internal freedom is, indeed, another story. - 14/12/2023 02:33:21 PM 116 Views
It means free of Jews - 17/12/2023 02:41:09 PM 114 Views
Re: From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free - 14/12/2023 03:32:17 PM 120 Views
Is the point to imply that 'pre-1948' meant no Israeli state at all? - 14/12/2023 03:56:59 PM 119 Views
Exactly - 14/12/2023 04:28:01 PM 133 Views
Those 3 Presidents are Bureaucratic Scum. - 14/12/2023 01:21:56 PM 129 Views
So Claudine Gay, Harvard Pres resigns - 02/01/2024 05:55:09 PM 110 Views
Re: So Claudine Gay, Harvard Pres resigns - 03/01/2024 04:38:14 PM 112 Views
Hey that’s not fair! - 03/01/2024 10:51:43 PM 109 Views

Reply to Message