Active Users:1120 Time:14/11/2024 06:13:16 AM
I had been wondering the same thing, about the show making them lovers. Legolas Send a noteboard - 04/09/2023 09:19:52 PM

View original postI don't think Jordan was all that interested in showing people falling in love so much as exploring what it's like to be a relationship in these situations. A lot of fantasy has a prince charming or the hero getting the princess, right at the end of the story, so what's it actually like to be married to a noblewoman from a badass family, or the heir to a throne or the heir to the Evil Empire or the heroic dispossessed king or a charming prince who is good hearted and devoted to the women in his family? Perrin is having to cope with a wife who has expectations for how a leader is supposed to act and how a husband who is a leader is supposed to behave and what marriage between leaders entails. Min has to deal with having a subordinate place in Rand's life due to the demands of his prophesied duty and has to watch him suffer to save the world. Mat can't simply reform the Evil Empire because the new Empress is his wife, even if she likes and respects him. Gawyn's devotion to his female relatives puts him at odds with Egwene and her loyalties. Lan's royal status traps him until there is almost no way he can see to pursue a relationship with Nynaeve. And politics can put Elayne and Rand at odds, regardless of their shared beliefs and similar agendas, while other duties separate them. That small amount of time they have together is, I think, an intended feature of their relationship arc (though I think the story did get away from Jordan a bit, and it wasn't supposed to be quite so long, or their time together was intended to be such a small portion of the story). I wouldn't say the lack of opportunities for physical intimacy diminish the relationship, since both of them make rather serious choices due to their feelings for each other. They are a lot more alike than either is to Aviendha or Min, and honestly, the most alike of any of the major couples, with Mat & Tuon coming closest, though with a much greater cultural and social gap. They are both driven by duty, putting it ahead of even their own well-being or wishes, both consider their own personal desires selfish and unworthy of consideration next to their duties (though Elayne is much better at handling the work-life balance) and both share with their brother a hard-line perspective on right and wrong, however willing to make necessary compromises for the greater good (which Galad is also more willing to do than he gets credit for). Narratively, I think the ta'veren driven love-at-first sight was to enable Jordan to skip the drawn out process getting to know each other past the gulf of rank and status would have been, and within the story, it was connecting two kindred spirits whose ability to work together would be critical to uniting humanity for the Last Battle (especially under an author who understood the themes of the story and saw unity & leadership as something more than political allegiance and offices). I've said elsewhere, that I think ta'veren doesn't make people fall in love so much as it helps couples overcome social constructs that would obstruct a relationship and obfuscate their personal compatibility, just as it doesn't change one's allegiance or priorities, so much as it shows why a particular leader is the best way to serve a cause you think is important, or how that leader is the right one for you, despite those same social constructs that tell you otherwise (eg Bashere & Rand).

Interesting point about Jordan wanting to explore various kinds of relationships - but still, in many of the romances they have more to work with at least. I think you're right about the story getting away from Jordan a bit part. But when you say lack of opportunities for physical intimacy, I don't mean just that - it's a lack of opportunities to get to know each other at all. After the few hours in the Caemlyn palace garden and a few days in the Stone of Tear, they're rarely in touch in any way, not even writing letters other than Elayne's two letters that so confuse Rand. Though of course, characters failing to be in touch when you'd really expect them to is WoT's whole thing...

So yeah, certainly they both make serious choices and do take the relationship very seriously, but it's really not convincing me.

View original postWith Elayne & Aviendha, I think the non-sexual aspect of their relationship is important to Jordan's intentions, of showing that friendship is just as significant and just as meaningful as sexual partnerships. Elayne and Aviendha's arc cannot be called anything other than a courtship. They deliberately start feeling each other out and make an effort to get to know each other, culminating in a formal commitment that was the stated goal of at least one party from the outset. It's Jordan saying that your friendships are as important as your marriage/partnership in some ways, and that sex or the lack is not the defining feature giving meaning to a relationship.

Absolutely. Though since you mention Aviendha's goal from the outset, I have to say that from what we see of sister-wives prior to that point, notably Bael's two wives or the whole Bain-Chiad-Gaul thing, it's more than friendship in most of the cases we see. Not quite a polyamorous 'throuple' situation like some people are doing nowadays, perhaps, but not far off either. In more than one case, you get the idea that the sister-wives care more about each other than about their mutual husband - including Elayne and Aviendha's case, really. Though you're right, not in a sexual way.
View original postAnd I would put money on the show making Aviendha and Elayne lovers if the show gets that far into the story, because the fans of that dynamic fall squarely into the segment of the fandom that the writers are part of or pandering to. Judkins expressed interest in portraying Rand's relationships, though I have heard he has talked about making the polyamorous instead of polygamous and has expressed a delight in altering the sexuality of characters especially in response to objections based on their canonical status in the books. I don't know if this is just wishful thinking from the shipping fans, but I have seen people claim that Ceara Coveney and Ayoola Smart have hinted at something of that nature for their characters' arcs, and flirt with each other on social media as if promoting it.

Yeah, was wondering the same thing while writing that. I can't say it would really bother me if it happened (if done right), since in some ways it wouldn't deviate all that much from the books considering what we just discussed. The big question would be whether they'd sleep with each other in addition to Rand, or instead of, if they give up on the whole polygamy/polyamory thing and just have Rand be with Min only (which, in fairness, for large parts of the book series, he is). If they do go the polyamory route, I hope they don't push it too far - Elayne and Aviendha being lovers is sort of credible, but Min and Aviendha for instance, not so much.

But yeah, you're right that it's also valuable to show how close and intimate Elayne and Aviendha's relationship can be without that sexual aspect. Going by their track record so far, I'm not convinced Judkins or the writers would think so, though.

Reply to message
Season 2 Episode 3 - 03/09/2023 04:50:09 AM 241 Views
Many good points again. - 03/09/2023 10:42:05 AM 99 Views
Holy fuck, that's supposed to be Moiraine's sister - 03/09/2023 07:53:59 PM 112 Views
Interesting... though yeah, they're unlikely to do much good with it. - 03/09/2023 09:47:10 PM 96 Views
Re: Interesting... though yeah, they're unlikely to do much good with it. - 04/09/2023 01:56:59 PM 94 Views
I had been wondering the same thing, about the show making them lovers. - 04/09/2023 09:19:52 PM 90 Views

Reply to Message