Active Users:1103 Time:23/11/2024 01:57:46 AM
They are no different than Eisenhower, MacArthur or Pershing, all of whom led slave soldiers Cannoli Send a noteboard - 20/12/2017 12:09:33 AM

View original post
Not once did they raise a moral objection or question that one of their own would have order such abominations. The Senate and the Republic were left but no choice but to use the army the Jedi offered them. All those planets including Mandalore and there were no mercenary armies to be had?
Presumably the TRADE Federation and BANKING Clans could outbid them.
But given the choice of allowing a the Trade Federation to take a few planets
Those are some mighty easy principles to espouse at the cost of OTHER people's lives. They were on Naboo like five minutes before they started setting up concentration camps and even driving the submarine Gungans out of their cities and into secret places of refuge. Each one of those "few planets" is an atrocity worse than anything in the whole bloody murderous 20th Century.

And that was not the choice, the choice for Yoda was to let the cream of the Jedi order be slaughtered TODAY on Geonosis while he waited to acquire an army more acceptable to this sort of barracks lawyer nonsense. People who were irreplaceable and who were vital to keeping peace and order in the Republic and preventing it from succumbing to the eventual doom of a militarized state with an army. People who might be the only hope the galaxy had against the Sith Lord moving in the shadows.


until a real army could be built or accepting genetically modified slaves clones that lack the will to resist and would serve no purpose once the war was ended and who would not be fit for society yes they should have taken the hard road. They were not aware that the Chancellor could order the clones to kill them even though that had every reason to suspect this army of horrors that just happen to conveniently be ready when they needed them. So the not only slave masters but fools.
Eh, that's presentism talking. That was a pretty big jump, and you've completely overlooked my point that the army was ALREADY in the hands of the Republic, and commissioned by Sidious' henchmen, so it's not like Palpatine would not have been able to take control anyway. The option would be turning it over to the Republic's bureaucrats, to appoint political officers with no real experience to lead them into the slaughterhouse, or take command themselves, ameliorate the abuses and prevent the army from being misused, or becoming an instrument of tyranny. They were already way in over their heads, and it's only with the benefit of hindsight that you see how their actions doomed themselves. Also, Sidious had been working on this plan a long time, presumably as the consummation of a long-term Sith strategy. He almost certainly had other plans to nudge the Jedi into the much if they held themselves aloof from the fighting. They doomed themselves however many generations previously when they took up the cause of the Republic in the first place, and became an institution of the state.
You can argue that the lack of free will disqualifies them as slaves but only because they are something much worse. Sentient emotionless killing machines that following any order without question?
What difference does emotion make? Possession or application of emotions is not good or bad. Nor do emotions have anything to do with free will. If they have no will, they are basically biological machines or robots, and morally no different than a gun.
That is worse than Janissaries. The Janissaries were highly affective but they were formed but stealing and abusing children. You could use the to attack and slaughter their own people. Clones are worse.
IDK what your point is here, if the clones are people, they are EXACTLY like Janissaries, because they basically ARE Janissaries.

As far as slave soldiers go, all of Europe used them in just about every war since 1789, and the US in every war of the 20th Century until we abolished military conscription. Clone troopers are no different than draftees, they just have a couple of superfluous steps removed between being born in the control of the enslaving power and the formalization of their compulsion to fight.

Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
Star Wars E8 - The Last Jedi - Tomorrow!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! - 14/12/2017 06:11:46 PM 906 Views
Let me know how it ends - 14/12/2017 11:52:15 PM 539 Views
It opened tonight. Just got back from seing it - 15/12/2017 04:57:22 AM 821 Views
I found it very underwhelming to be honest. - 15/12/2017 06:57:39 PM 825 Views
But you don't like anything..... *NM* - 15/12/2017 08:14:39 PM 235 Views
very minor spoilers - 15/12/2017 08:43:44 PM 508 Views
Big spoilers. - 16/12/2017 12:55:05 AM 616 Views
I think the two go hand it hand (still spoliers) - 16/12/2017 01:43:00 AM 530 Views
Fair point. - 18/12/2017 06:42:54 PM 566 Views
Agreed with everything you wrote here. - 18/12/2017 12:22:56 PM 501 Views
Well, I hope they are. - 18/12/2017 06:32:29 PM 502 Views
The story being pretty weak? - 15/12/2017 10:03:51 PM 547 Views
Well, in the computer games, for one. - 16/12/2017 12:29:31 AM 491 Views
I have mixed feelings about it. - 18/12/2017 12:18:05 PM 514 Views
I found it confusing, terrible and kind of boring *spoilers* - 16/12/2017 10:41:34 PM 517 Views
I very much agree with this review - 16/12/2017 11:06:55 PM 574 Views
Regarding number 7. - 18/12/2017 12:26:41 PM 582 Views
Good post..... - 18/12/2017 06:37:58 PM 495 Views
Re: Regarding number 7. - 20/12/2017 05:02:11 AM 961 Views
The Jedi were slave owners - 18/12/2017 01:42:19 PM 478 Views
They weren't the owners, that was the Republic/Senate - 19/12/2017 01:38:05 PM 491 Views
stop making excuses for the slave masters - 19/12/2017 03:22:54 PM 402 Views
They are no different than Eisenhower, MacArthur or Pershing, all of whom led slave soldiers - 20/12/2017 12:09:33 AM 488 Views
draftees are not biologically modified slaves - 20/12/2017 02:49:33 PM 469 Views
No, they're just ill-prepared slaves - 21/12/2017 11:34:02 AM 495 Views
No the Jedi sucked - 21/12/2017 04:18:48 PM 517 Views
Re: No the Jedi sucked - 25/12/2017 03:39:25 AM 449 Views
I got up and walked out. *spoilers* - 18/12/2017 07:48:42 PM 538 Views
I'm confused. - 18/12/2017 08:19:48 PM 491 Views
You may have walked out a bit early... *NM* - 21/12/2017 09:41:00 PM 245 Views
It's kind of hilarious how divided opinion is on this movie... - 18/12/2017 07:53:12 PM 637 Views
That would explain much *NM* - 19/12/2017 07:15:36 AM 294 Views
I really liked it as a deconstruction of Star Wars. - 19/12/2017 10:34:59 PM 581 Views
You're going to have to elaborate on that one... - 19/12/2017 11:22:01 PM 629 Views
Re: You're going to have to elaborate on that one... - 21/12/2017 09:45:09 PM 453 Views
It is JJ Abrams and the idiot critics love him - 20/12/2017 02:51:06 PM 495 Views
Abrams didn't do this film. Rian did. *NM* - 21/12/2017 09:46:21 PM 257 Views
It's not real opinion that's divided. - 20/12/2017 02:59:59 PM 680 Views
Did anyone else think... *spoilers* - 20/12/2017 05:04:44 AM 940 Views
Well it was original fan-fic...first half tedious, second half quite enjoyable - 21/12/2017 06:14:35 AM 622 Views

Reply to Message