Active Users:1013 Time:14/11/2024 05:59:11 AM
Regarding your last question The Shrike Send a noteboard - 27/10/2015 01:57:04 PM


My brother is a US Army Captain stationed in Germany, and his opinion is that President Obama has made a wise choice by not contesting the annexation of Crimea and the subterfuge in Eastern Ukraine. As a person who obviously knows more of the situation than myself, what is your opinion of the current discontent in the area? I am legitimately curious, and very interested in seeing more accurate depictions than the US media provides.

To understand the area and the population, think about national identity. The area in question - the Crimean Peninsula - was a historical part of the Russian Empire and then the Russian SSR during the Soviet period until 1954 when Khrushchev decided to hand it over in some misguided attempt to bind the two "nations" together. Especially considering how important Sevastopol is to the Russian navy.

So the population is ethnically Russian, Russian speaking with a Russian identity. No one in 1954 imagined the dissolution of the USSR in two generations. At the onset of instability in Ukraine, I only wish that the area had been given the chance to have a true referendum on its future. Based on polls, it would have chosen to return to being an integral part of Russia. But democracy and (true) referendums are not currently items that Putin has any belief in. The example that would have set for other parts of Russia would not have been one he would have wanted I imagine.

As for Eastern Ukraine - that area I leave alone completely. Every oblast seems to have a majority of ethnic Ukrainians. Though language politics complicates the picture in cities such as Donetsk. Those are areas that would do well to either be given greater autonomy or be given the chance to have a referendum on their future. Stay in Ukraine or join Russia. The history of the area is complicated and the the Russian policy of Russification has complicated the identity politics of the areas in question.

If you wish to find other media sources that are neither American nor Russian, try looking at English versions of European media like Der Spiegel. You will get a different viewpoint.

Reply to message
Putin is finally doing what Obama couldn't - 19/10/2015 08:31:34 PM 713 Views
That may have been true three or four years ago. - 19/10/2015 09:07:45 PM 430 Views
He's not "viable"? That's silly. - 19/10/2015 10:09:45 PM 356 Views
You're also approaching this from a "consensus-building" conviction. - 20/10/2015 12:51:18 AM 366 Views
All of your examples are missing the salient point here. - 20/10/2015 07:10:13 AM 455 Views
The secular dicator is better argument falls apart if he can't control his country - 20/10/2015 05:46:56 PM 309 Views
Well, but now you're selectively choosing facts - 21/10/2015 02:18:44 PM 286 Views
If you run a junk yard you can tolerate a mena dog that bites only if he keep the thieves out - 22/10/2015 04:22:18 PM 307 Views
Seriously, it's not hard to spell "Assad" correctly. - 22/10/2015 05:43:15 PM 311 Views
Too bad he's an Iranian ally - 22/10/2015 06:35:17 PM 271 Views
Yes, but right now they're fighting the Sunnis - 22/10/2015 06:55:49 PM 313 Views
You say that almost as if he's ever shown any inclination to risk a war with Israel... - 22/10/2015 07:28:43 PM 326 Views
Oh no, he certainly hasn't. - 22/10/2015 09:06:58 PM 291 Views
Thats funny coming the the Russin apologist in chief - 23/10/2015 02:23:44 PM 324 Views
All the information here came from Western sources. - 23/10/2015 03:08:24 PM 379 Views
What are your criticisms ? - 25/10/2015 01:47:51 PM 297 Views
My criticisms - 25/10/2015 07:29:52 PM 304 Views
I'm late to the party, and I have no dog in the Russian fight, but... - 27/10/2015 01:41:27 AM 367 Views
I've lived in the South and in Russia - 27/10/2015 02:39:09 AM 309 Views
Re: I've lived in the South and in Russia - 27/10/2015 05:15:54 AM 460 Views
Regarding your last question - 27/10/2015 01:57:04 PM 376 Views
Russian foreign policy - 27/10/2015 02:00:54 PM 287 Views
Hmmm... - 27/10/2015 11:23:43 AM 329 Views
God no. Putin has very real and easily understood goals. - 27/10/2015 02:05:46 PM 355 Views
assassinate his political enemies? - 21/10/2015 10:36:21 PM 296 Views
Try bombing the terrorists, instead of the actual authorities. - 22/10/2015 05:19:08 PM 274 Views
except Putin is bombing people we've trained, so we're training terrorists? - 22/10/2015 06:18:58 PM 300 Views
We were arming them at a minimum. *NM* - 22/10/2015 06:56:16 PM 126 Views
Duh. - 26/10/2015 12:40:08 AM 365 Views
or put it another way: do we really want to actually wade into ANOTHER war in the Middle East? - 22/10/2015 06:25:37 PM 322 Views
Only two? - 26/10/2015 12:39:03 AM 417 Views
I attempted to watch the Benghazi select committee but... - 27/10/2015 05:26:20 AM 315 Views

Reply to Message