Active Users:1099 Time:23/11/2024 12:57:42 AM
That article has some issues. Legolas Send a noteboard - 12/01/2015 07:43:04 PM

View original post"Je suis Charlie" is a bit misunderstood, I think. That's not meant as a profession of adherence to the ideas of Charlie Hebdo (or a very great deal of people would be hypocritical indeed to use it) nor a way to claim the courage of the CH journalists. It's first and above all a republican ralliement cry for freedom of speech/freedom of press, and a show of defiance: you won't take our freedom of speech, and above all a way to tell the terrorists that if they want to take the freedoms which are the pillars of our democracies and way or life from us, they'll have to do much worse than kill a few journalists, they'll have to kill us all.

I saw an article from an American journalist raising the interesting point, which I had overlooked so far, that "je suis Charlie" could of course be translated just as validly by "I follow Charlie". It then degenerated, rather bizarrely, into a long etymological discussion about how Latin verbs as different as "sequi" and "esse" somehow managed to yield the same first person singular in modern French.

Though I don't really think anyone ever intended the "suivre" meaning.


View original postFor the philosopher Abdennour Bidar, the faithfuls mustn't stop themselves at denouncing the terrorist barbarity to better elude the matter of the origins of those Jihadist aberrations. In the light of the dogmas and of the political instrumentalisation which they are the object of, the muslim world must look at itself with a critical eye and engineer its own reformation.

Three points of criticism:
1) Does he expect anyone to believe this is actually written for a Muslim audience, or that it will reach it?
2) He makes the same mistake that people the world over keep making over and over again - conflating "Islamic world" with "Arab world". Yes, there is terrorism and oppression in the non-Arab Islamic countries as well, but still it's not quite the same - and many of the non-Arab countries are much better performers in terms of democracy, human rights and even economic performance. Can we talk a bit more about Jokowi and a bit less about Assad, when discussing Islam?
3) First he dismisses the Western intellectuals who blame history, politics or economics for most of the ills of the Muslim world. Then he starts talking about the root problems of the Muslim world... most of which are political at heart. Then he moves on to talking about the 18th century. And finally "the global sickness which is the cult of the god Money". One might be forgiven for thinking he doesn't disagree with those Western intellectuals after all.

But of course he's right in the closing point that the solution is education, education and education. The curriculums in the Arab and wider Muslim world need to be purged, firstly of all the nationalist crap in them, and secondly of the Islamist crap. And we need to reopen, once and for all, the famous "Gate of Ijtihad", not just among small minority groups but among the Sunni mainstream. Good luck achieving any of that, though.

Reply to message
So guys, what about Paris? - 10/01/2015 02:00:10 AM 1191 Views
Completely agree. - 10/01/2015 05:39:53 AM 576 Views
Agree with some things. Not all. - 10/01/2015 10:56:59 AM 1030 Views
Yeah. - 10/01/2015 01:17:52 PM 599 Views
Meh. Nobody's going to do anything about it. *NM* - 10/01/2015 07:04:26 PM 276 Views
Re: So guys, what about Paris? - 11/01/2015 04:18:35 AM 885 Views
That article was awesome - 11/01/2015 05:26:46 AM 637 Views
Re: That article was awesome - 12/01/2015 04:59:54 PM 645 Views
That article has some issues. - 12/01/2015 07:43:04 PM 581 Views
It's all such a big mess, and I am getting increasingly pessimistic about it - 11/01/2015 11:21:45 AM 762 Views
What is the problem with Pegida? - 12/01/2015 11:37:49 PM 627 Views
Everything - 13/01/2015 08:41:17 AM 918 Views
Those 19 points do look fairly reasonable, agreed. - 13/01/2015 07:08:13 PM 580 Views
Arguendo, if they raise a valid point shouldn't it be addressed? - 14/01/2015 02:59:28 PM 545 Views
Yeah, it should. - 14/01/2015 08:02:19 PM 558 Views
Yes - 15/01/2015 11:42:58 AM 752 Views
That's what you get when it's cool to corner Israel - 11/01/2015 05:33:56 PM 631 Views
For the record... - 12/01/2015 07:20:35 PM 544 Views
It's a bit disingenuous on Nasrallah's part - 12/01/2015 11:34:02 PM 557 Views
Re: It's a bit disingenuous on Nasrallah's part - 13/01/2015 02:40:55 AM 666 Views
Charlie Hebdo's next week cover - 13/01/2015 03:00:13 AM 956 Views
That magazine will sell out in an hour even with the incredibly high print issue. - 13/01/2015 03:19:16 AM 589 Views
Indeed - 13/01/2015 05:17:56 PM 622 Views
Finally it will be only 300 copies distributed in the USA - 14/01/2015 01:24:45 PM 632 Views
I love that. *NM* - 13/01/2015 06:14:36 PM 281 Views
The world will always have assholes - 18/01/2015 03:20:52 AM 563 Views

Reply to Message