Active Users:1178 Time:22/11/2024 11:30:33 PM
Depends whom you ask, but apparently pro-Morsi forces trying to storm his place of detention. Joel Send a noteboard - 16/08/2013 03:04:07 AM

View original post
Though I understand the general idea you are trying to communicate.

My question is how in the hell did this situation get extremely hot all of the sudden instead of smoldering discontent we have had for years.

We went from (this is a simplistic summary)

1) An authoritarian dictator who was the front man to the military (Mubarak).
2) Young people (Tahrir Square) wanting change, these people were not particularly religious.
3) The military who ran Egypt for decades, decide to meet the protests somewhat with getting rid of the dictator as a show of good will and moving to a new form of power sharing with a constitution and elections.
4) The Muslim Brotherhood wins half of parliament, later on Mohamed Morsi (connected to the Muslim Brotherhood) is elected president. Morsi spends the next year trying to expand Muslim Brotherhood power while at the same time dismantle old power structure connected to the miliary.
5) During all this time the economy of Egypt is tanking, we start to see protests over Morsi (people that can't eat take to the streets). Eventually it ends with a week long struggle where the military throws out Morsi.
6) We had 6 weeks of protests by the Muslim Brotherhood. There were some deaths but each individual incident the death total was less than 100.
7) The interm president declares martial law for a month and that same day protests are broken up and over 500 are killed.

What changed in the last week that caused the military to take deadly action?


The sole difference between hundreds of deaths in weeks and an equal number in hours is the former 1) demonstrates a sustained lethal threat resulting in 2) resistance by means up to and including lethal force. You said it yourself: A solid month of increasingly intensifying and violently lethal protests culminated in a martial law declaration and subsequent violently lethal protest suppression; let us not put the cart before the horse. How did the French Revolution respond to attempted rescue of the Bourbons, or the Bolsheviks to attempted rescue of the Romanovs? Note: The absence of any genuine "good guys" in both parallels was deliberate.

Anyway, a bunch of pro-Morsi protesters tried to overrun the building where the military holds him under house arrest and, due to the proclivity for lethal violence on BOTH sides, were shot en masse for their trouble. Pretty much what one expects to happen when a large group of violently lethal civilians charge a position held by a group of equally violent but far better trained and equipped soldiers. It sounds like the Muslim Brotherhoods violent faction decided to attack the army rather than those it sympathizes with, and it went about like one would expect.

Honorbound and honored to be Bonded to Mahtaliel Sedai
Last First in wotmania Chat
Slightly better than chocolate.

Love still can't be coerced.
Please Don't Eat the Newbies!

LoL. Be well, RAFOlk.
This message last edited by Joel on 16/08/2013 at 03:04:55 AM
Reply to message
What the hell is happening in Egypt? *NM* - 15/08/2013 05:32:29 PM 495 Views
A small(ish) civil war. - 15/08/2013 06:45:29 PM 596 Views
Hmmm. - 15/08/2013 07:02:38 PM 531 Views
These states' borders are the key. - 15/08/2013 07:16:04 PM 581 Views
I am not sure civil war is the right word to describe the situation - 15/08/2013 10:59:06 PM 520 Views
Depends whom you ask, but apparently pro-Morsi forces trying to storm his place of detention. - 16/08/2013 03:04:07 AM 688 Views
Exactly what everyone knew would happen. *NM* - 15/08/2013 10:35:08 PM 277 Views
+1 *NM* - 15/08/2013 11:12:45 PM 264 Views
Yes. *NM* - 16/08/2013 05:07:44 PM 212 Views
+3 *NM* - 16/08/2013 10:19:46 PM 200 Views
Everyone hates each other. - 16/08/2013 05:18:54 PM 516 Views
That's awfully apocalyptic, don't you think? - 16/08/2013 07:34:12 PM 578 Views
No. - 17/08/2013 07:45:27 PM 599 Views
Why on earth would we want them shooting "those lunatics"? - 17/08/2013 09:46:58 PM 509 Views
A working democracy? How quaintly utopian. - 18/08/2013 05:00:10 AM 564 Views
You are confusing religous people with religous nations. *NM* - 17/08/2013 08:32:55 PM 230 Views

Reply to Message