Active Users:1143 Time:22/11/2024 12:49:03 PM
Just about every word goes for me too. Cannoli Send a noteboard - 30/01/2015 12:27:36 PM


I think I have a second hand copy of the Thorn Birds somewhere, but never got around to reading it...
Except for this.

Agreed. For me it pretty much defines my view of that whole period, especially the earlier part which is a bit less often depicted in popular culture - I'm still inclined to view Sulla and Marius the way she depicted them. Caesar, Antony, Augustus - there I guess it's more a mixture of sources.
I don't actually see the characters/historical figures that way, although the personalities of Sulla & Marius, yes. My historically informed view of them remained unchanged, but the books did strongly influence my view of their personalities.

I didn't actually finish the series, because it became more intolerable as Caesar's role increased. The more even-handed approach McCollough used to portray flawed historical figures such as Marius & Sulla disappeared, as she made Caesar as much of a Mary Sue as you can get with an historical figure. I thought Stephen Pressfield went overboard on Dienekes in "Gates of Fire", until I read "Caesar's Women".

I much preferred the portrayals of Cicero & Caesar in Robert Harris' "Imperium" & "Lustrum".


It's rather didactic that way - focusing almost exclusively on the big historical characters and going out of its way to cover almost everything of historical importance happening over the period, you could say it's more a fictionalized, glamourized retelling of history (the old kind of history, with heroes and villains determining the course of history rather than socio-economic developments) than historical fiction in the normal sense. But that's not a bad thing.

That's an excellent description. The level of detail as well gives a strong impression of the cultural context, and the familial interrelationships as well. After reading McCullough, I found myself recognizing characters in other fiction on the period, as "so-and-so's grandson, the cousin of whatshisname, etc, etc." This series gave me a level of familiarity with the major players of the late republic akin to the characters of WoT or aSoI&F. For someone interested in that kind of immersion in cultural and social details, I would completely recommend this series.

Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
Colleen McCullough has passed away. - 29/01/2015 12:21:51 PM 4190 Views
It's a pity that The Thorn Birds gets so much attention when The First Man in Rome series - 29/01/2015 02:16:26 PM 1225 Views
Well. - 29/01/2015 06:14:35 PM 1038 Views
*NM* - 29/01/2015 07:01:19 PM 684 Views
That is a smart purchase! *NM* - 30/01/2015 07:46:15 PM 560 Views
That Rome series is the only thing by her that I've read. - 29/01/2015 09:31:36 PM 1111 Views
Just about every word goes for me too. - 30/01/2015 12:27:36 PM 1321 Views
Fair point on Caesar. - 30/01/2015 05:53:34 PM 1286 Views
Same here. - 30/01/2015 07:49:35 PM 1081 Views
Agreed. I very much enjoy that series of books. - 30/01/2015 07:48:05 PM 1037 Views
Agreed - 31/01/2015 02:14:00 PM 1168 Views

Reply to Message