BSG had its lackluster moments, but for the most part it was so good! But then it's ending was just so terrible, and while other things that can potentially make or break a show can come down to a multitude of factors, surely the blame for how a story ends can only be put on the guy in charge. And it was a shit ending, there's no other way I can even phrase it. It didn't match geological and biological records, it didn't make sense for the characters, it didn't even make sense for the story.
So after that, I'm very apprehensive about the man