Active Users:1064 Time:22/11/2024 12:24:46 PM
Re: I don't believe ... dacole Send a noteboard - 03/01/2012 12:06:24 AM
... that the discussion has been so much about the fact that there is violence as it has been about the perceived unnecessary detail and luridity of the descriptions of said violence. It's a position I only partially agree with, but that seems to be the idea.

Anyway, separating your question from its origin, you could easily envision fantasy stories without any overt violence whatsoever, simply by taking non-violent traditional story types and transposing them into fantasy settings.

Random examples pulled out of my ass:

Take a traditional detective story such as Sherlock Holmes, where much of the violence occurs before the story begins when there is even violence at all. Tell a story about a detective solving mysteries in a fantasy setting. As an actual example of this, you could take Neil Gaiman's A Study in Emerald, a Holmesian detective story set in an alternate London ruled by Lovecraftian horrors, a story told without violence.

Court procedurals are the same idea. The violence takes place before the story starts. Have a fantasy lawyer type character who tries to prove people innocent of crimes in a fantastic or medieval setting.

To borrow again from television, a show like House has no violence. Could easily be done in a fantasy settings.

Fantasy travelogue, humorously describing a trip through a made-up world.

Fantasy romance novel, taking a traditional romance story with adultery and passion and melodrama, setting it in a fantastic setting. Maybe the forbidden love between a human and an elf.

Essentially any traditional story type that doesn't use violence, of which there are many, could be transposed into fantasy with very little problem.


How well would these work though? A study in Emarald is a great example but it only works because it is Gamian and he is amazing. Not sure anyone else could have pulled this off. Really would anyone want to read CSI-fantasy land?
Reply to message
Fantasy novel without violence - what would it look like? - 30/12/2011 06:46:04 PM 1235 Views
I read some like that. - 30/12/2011 07:39:52 PM 1031 Views
It's definitely easier for science fiction... - 30/12/2011 07:45:21 PM 1401 Views
I am having trouble thinking of a non-violent Kay novel. - 31/12/2011 08:33:45 PM 933 Views
Sarantium books as well, very much so. *NM* - 03/01/2012 09:54:21 PM 397 Views
Sarantium books as well, very much so. *NM* - 03/01/2012 09:54:21 PM 427 Views
Shall we get into how I don't agree with you about martain again - 03/01/2012 12:04:14 AM 1157 Views
I don't believe ... - 30/12/2011 07:51:34 PM 1220 Views
Re: I don't believe ... - 03/01/2012 12:06:24 AM 932 Views
It would be rectangular and suck - 31/12/2011 07:51:26 AM 1022 Views
No violence does not mean no conflict. *NM* - 31/12/2011 10:38:49 PM 461 Views
No violence? - 31/12/2011 09:47:20 PM 1278 Views
That just suggests to me that the guy is a bad author. - 31/12/2011 11:14:55 PM 955 Views
There are lots of good non-violent fantasy novels. - 03/01/2012 01:34:09 AM 2274 Views
I love all of those but...fantasy? *NM* - 03/01/2012 02:16:31 AM 432 Views
By the purest definition... yes. - 05/01/2012 05:31:30 PM 1061 Views
It would be really difficult in Epic fantasy - 04/01/2012 03:52:42 AM 1193 Views
It wouldn't be that hard - 04/01/2012 02:30:39 PM 880 Views

Reply to Message