I don't want to debate ethics with you, but paying a whore isn't rape.
CatherineSedai Send a noteboard - 21/07/2011 03:31:42 AM
and I dislike that this is dancing along the edge of becoming a blog argument (ridiculous) and I'm shocked, because everything I read from you on the WoT boards makes perfect sense to me.
Firstly though, I think you misunderstand my example about American's. Imagine if George Washington and that lot had decided "Hey, instead of writing them a letter telling them we're done with them and we're staying right here on the other side of the world, what if we all get back in the boats, go home, and kill off that horrible ruling family and free all our kith and kin, reclaim our homeland, and bring a new age of prosperity and peace to our people". Daenerys' and all the exiles coming to Westeros is the American Revolution in reverse.
But, I honestly didn't see any pimps in the story, in Westeros it seems more like the woman decides to sell herself. A woman or man may own a brothel, but the brothel pays the women minus room and board. A pimp would pay the whore minus a "just because" pimp tax. Being sold into slavery and being forced to whore yourself is disgusting. Choosing to let men pay you to shove their pricks in you is disgusting too, but it isn't rape. If a woman makes a living selling her privates, and she chose to do it, and she willingly accepts your coin, it is no rape. The Ladies of the Seven Kingdoms are all whores, because once they are assigned a man, they open their legs so they can live in a nice castle and hand down lands and titles to their children. The Bedding of a Westerosi woman is way closer to rape than Tyrion Lannister's wayward couplings.
I think we all agree that medieval morality, practices, and sexuality is barbaric and disgusting, but when you read a story like this don't you adapt your mindset to think like the people in the world you're reading? Don't you rationalize right and wrong within the moral confines of the time and place you are reading about? If you don't I'm not sure why you read medieval fantasy at all, unless it's just so you can be pissed off.
I read books to live a thousand lives in one and have experiences I can never truly have, travel through time to live the lives of others, become someone else and try to think like them. I'm afraid you read so you can try to apply your "very firm and certain principles of power and governance and jurisprudence" to every situation in history or every person in every walk of life, and denounce them as lesser than yourself.
Firstly though, I think you misunderstand my example about American's. Imagine if George Washington and that lot had decided "Hey, instead of writing them a letter telling them we're done with them and we're staying right here on the other side of the world, what if we all get back in the boats, go home, and kill off that horrible ruling family and free all our kith and kin, reclaim our homeland, and bring a new age of prosperity and peace to our people". Daenerys' and all the exiles coming to Westeros is the American Revolution in reverse.
But, I honestly didn't see any pimps in the story, in Westeros it seems more like the woman decides to sell herself. A woman or man may own a brothel, but the brothel pays the women minus room and board. A pimp would pay the whore minus a "just because" pimp tax. Being sold into slavery and being forced to whore yourself is disgusting. Choosing to let men pay you to shove their pricks in you is disgusting too, but it isn't rape. If a woman makes a living selling her privates, and she chose to do it, and she willingly accepts your coin, it is no rape. The Ladies of the Seven Kingdoms are all whores, because once they are assigned a man, they open their legs so they can live in a nice castle and hand down lands and titles to their children. The Bedding of a Westerosi woman is way closer to rape than Tyrion Lannister's wayward couplings.
I think we all agree that medieval morality, practices, and sexuality is barbaric and disgusting, but when you read a story like this don't you adapt your mindset to think like the people in the world you're reading? Don't you rationalize right and wrong within the moral confines of the time and place you are reading about? If you don't I'm not sure why you read medieval fantasy at all, unless it's just so you can be pissed off.
I read books to live a thousand lives in one and have experiences I can never truly have, travel through time to live the lives of others, become someone else and try to think like them. I'm afraid you read so you can try to apply your "very firm and certain principles of power and governance and jurisprudence" to every situation in history or every person in every walk of life, and denounce them as lesser than yourself.
I always say, if you must mount the gallows, give a jest to the crowd, a coin to the hangman, and make the drop with a smile on your lips. ~Birgitte
This message last edited by CatherineSedai on 21/07/2011 at 04:38:27 AM
Just finished Dance with Dragons - My Thoughts (SPOILERS)
19/07/2011 05:48:48 AM
- 1506 Views
There IS News About Rickon (spoiler)
19/07/2011 03:15:35 PM
- 974 Views
Re: There IS News About Rickon (spoiler)
19/07/2011 06:50:34 PM
- 983 Views
Re: There IS News About Rickon (spoiler)
19/07/2011 09:34:01 PM
- 976 Views
I thought that too, but it doesn't fit.
19/07/2011 09:57:29 PM
- 1125 Views
Funny how people can like a book for completely opposite reasons.
19/07/2011 11:00:12 PM
- 1145 Views
Lol I love this post.
19/07/2011 11:29:05 PM
- 1029 Views
Actually,
20/07/2011 04:57:17 AM
- 994 Views
Re: Funny how people can like a book for completely opposite reasons.
20/07/2011 06:11:10 AM
- 1135 Views
Are you INSANE? Do you know NOTHING about what prostitution entails?
21/07/2011 01:09:26 AM
- 1168 Views
I don't want to debate ethics with you, but paying a whore isn't rape.
21/07/2011 03:31:42 AM
- 974 Views
I'm starting to think you have a powerful women complex...
20/07/2011 07:56:32 AM
- 910 Views
I have the same issues with powerful men, but stupid writers don't give them a pass.
21/07/2011 01:15:57 AM
- 962 Views
I have to take Cannoli's side here
01/08/2011 12:26:51 PM
- 861 Views
I don't know, may be because it is their books you read... *NM*
02/08/2011 08:02:38 PM
- 422 Views
It does not follow that they have the power over interpretation, and certainly not evaluation. *NM*
02/08/2011 08:19:50 PM
- 404 Views