No. I can understand/appreciate the arguments, but IMHO the White Tower AS are not that valuable
RugbyPlayingAshaman Send a noteboard - 15/04/2010 07:27:23 PM
It actually would have been a far greater victory and expansion of the Light's capabilities if Egwene, Nynaeve and Elayne had started their own channeling organization which united the Kin, the Aiel Wise Ones and the Windfinders, in a patchwork quilt based upon each groups' respective autonomy and a sharing of ideas. A better second outcome would have been for the Rebels to have gained public recognition with the White Tower Aes Sedai and their Oath Rod sank into obscurity.
The White Tower A) doesn't have nearly as many channelers as those other organizations, B) more time will be spent restructuring the Tower and Aes Sedai approaches to multicultural respect and the new power balance than doing anything useful and C) has customs and beliefs that are counter-productive.
I think that is the problem with how RJ presented the WT to us. He never showed the possible members who clothed the poor, cared for the sick, opened orphanages or etc, and only showed us the politicians and administrators. As a result, we doubt that useful members of the Aes Sedai even exist. While reforming the White Tower is nice, I think the organization is flawed and Tarmon Gaidon presents a great opportunity to clean house as it were and get rid of it.
Here's the deal: It is Tarmon Gaidon. At this point, making treaties, getting everyone to talk to you and use diplomatic channels is not really that useful. In other words, the White Tower has outlived it's usefulness.
It's sort of like saying "Look everyone! The White Tower approves of me!", while the world ends.
At this point, what the Light needs is manpower, and I think Egwene could have been in a better position to lead a more effective group from outside Tower control.
The White Tower A) doesn't have nearly as many channelers as those other organizations, B) more time will be spent restructuring the Tower and Aes Sedai approaches to multicultural respect and the new power balance than doing anything useful and C) has customs and beliefs that are counter-productive.
I think that is the problem with how RJ presented the WT to us. He never showed the possible members who clothed the poor, cared for the sick, opened orphanages or etc, and only showed us the politicians and administrators. As a result, we doubt that useful members of the Aes Sedai even exist. While reforming the White Tower is nice, I think the organization is flawed and Tarmon Gaidon presents a great opportunity to clean house as it were and get rid of it.
Here's the deal: It is Tarmon Gaidon. At this point, making treaties, getting everyone to talk to you and use diplomatic channels is not really that useful. In other words, the White Tower has outlived it's usefulness.
It's sort of like saying "Look everyone! The White Tower approves of me!", while the world ends.
At this point, what the Light needs is manpower, and I think Egwene could have been in a better position to lead a more effective group from outside Tower control.
"Those who think they have no time for bodily exercise will sooner or later have to find time for illness."
This message last edited by RugbyPlayingAshaman on 15/04/2010 at 08:39:53 PM
Does Rand really need the White Tower?
15/04/2010 06:42:36 PM
- 1229 Views
No. I can understand/appreciate the arguments, but IMHO the White Tower AS are not that valuable
15/04/2010 07:27:23 PM
- 720 Views
Re: Does Rand really need the White Tower?
15/04/2010 09:29:50 PM
- 557 Views
Meh. Growing pains. And unlike the White Tower split, this will not be a refreshing shake-up
16/04/2010 02:45:21 PM
- 685 Views
Depends
16/04/2010 06:50:53 AM
- 608 Views
some respectful disagreement, if you don't mind
17/04/2010 04:04:32 AM
- 573 Views
On the other hand,you recently argued that sending away Else was a capital mistake by Siuan
16/04/2010 09:29:56 AM
- 605 Views
And the WT, even (or maybe especially) under Egwene is the greatest obstacle to that unity
16/04/2010 02:50:24 PM
- 584 Views
Re: And the WT, even (or maybe especially) under Egwene is the greatest obstacle to that unity
23/04/2010 11:08:58 PM
- 621 Views