Active Users:1102 Time:14/11/2024 10:44:54 PM
Re: I sure as hell hope this is an inaccurate report... DomA Send a noteboard - 23/03/2010 07:13:25 PM
Because for Brandon to insist that his portrayal of the Tar Valon siege (and surrounding area) is correct must be described as... worrying, at best.


It's really no wonder Brandon evaded that question as he could.
The guy is barely coherent, so god knows how the "problems" got explained to Brandon in the first place! From the answer, it seems the guy lost him by explaining there was a problem with how the army was divided at the bridges. That's wrong. The problem is not that Brandon has barely mentionned the soldiers holding the bridge towns, it's that he put Bryne's camp somewhere else than Jordan had it last in KOD, when Siuan wakes up after Egwene told her she's been captured. He had it surround the Aes Sedai instead of being closer to the Erinin, among the 5-6 camps on the western shore.

That's really not the sort of thing I would tell a writer publicly at a signing anyway. It's rude and it makes him lose face and beside this is not RJ, who knew the world he created up and down and could answer any question about the locales with consulting notes and all. If Brandon isn't warned in advance (and provided with proper references or quotes), he can't answer questions like this. It's fairly obvious Maria and him overlooked the paragraphs in which RJ gave clues/indications (it's not always very clear) about the vicinity of the city and the location of everyone in COT/KOD.

It's not problems Brandon could easily solve for the paperback (it's not a matter of changing just a few words, for the most part it's not), so personally I don't really expect it will be changed.

The matter about the bridges is perhaps more one of perception. It seems that RJ and (a lot of) us were under the impression the TV bridges are arched and very high, to let big masted ships pass under. This would make it quite impossible for Egwene at the foot of one to see the gate on the other side. Obviously, Brandon's perception of the bridges was that they are fairly flat, making it perfectly possible for Egwene to see the gate, only half a mile from where she stood. I'm not sure there is a quote describing the bridges as arched. Perhaps in NS or something, as Moiraine/Siuan ride on one. Perhaps I got this mental image from the NS comic, where the TV design approved by RJ showed the bridges as arched. Perhaps it's the White Bridge that misleads me, or perhaps it's just a logical guess based on the fact big ships go under those bridges. Anyway... that's the sort of details that need to be double-checked before going to Brandon and telling him "you made a mistake with this and that", out of respect not to make him lose his time over nothing. Several "mistakes" like this have not stood after deeper research (one example: some argued that the number of Younglings with Gawyn in TGS didn't match the number he had after Dumai's Wells. Further research showed that indeed those numbers didn't match, but there's also a brief mention by RJ in one book that Gawyn had left a good chunk of Younglings not far enough advanced in training at TV, and Elaida has kicked them out and sent them to Dorlan - so Brandon's numbers were right).

This message last edited by DomA on 23/03/2010 at 07:27:10 PM
Reply to message
Signing report with some speculations - 23/03/2010 12:37:18 PM 2949 Views
Heh, the Dragonmount Twitter directs here. Who's the spy? - 23/03/2010 02:46:11 PM 944 Views
Heh. On the subject of the source, some more interesting tweets - 23/03/2010 05:56:53 PM 866 Views
Re: Signing report with some speculations - 23/03/2010 02:59:37 PM 1023 Views
Re: Signing report with some speculations - 23/03/2010 03:42:32 PM 853 Views
Re: Signing report with some speculations - 23/03/2010 05:09:25 PM 891 Views
Re: Signing report with some speculations - 23/03/2010 05:23:44 PM 881 Views
Brandon Sanderson bought up Sulin, not me.... - 24/03/2010 07:18:41 AM 1341 Views
Cadsuane's ? - 24/03/2010 07:46:25 PM 902 Views
I sure as hell hope this is an inaccurate report... - 23/03/2010 05:55:35 PM 875 Views
Re: I sure as hell hope this is an inaccurate report... - 23/03/2010 07:13:25 PM 858 Views
Re: I sure as hell hope this is an inaccurate report... - 23/03/2010 08:44:58 PM 739 Views
Re: I sure as hell hope this is an inaccurate report... - 23/03/2010 08:47:34 PM 707 Views
Re: I sure as hell hope this is an inaccurate report... - 23/03/2010 11:48:18 PM 889 Views
Re: I sure as hell hope this is an inaccurate report... - 24/03/2010 11:49:01 AM 675 Views
Re: bridges - 25/03/2010 08:13:08 AM 653 Views
Ugh. There's someone you wouldn't want to be stuck in an elevator with. *NM* - 23/03/2010 06:49:24 PM 446 Views
Foretelling by Hurin's nose? - 23/03/2010 09:06:07 PM 1638 Views
Re: Foretelling by Hurin's nose? - 24/03/2010 12:25:41 AM 1363 Views
Is it actually possible that Moiraine's rescue will not occur in ToM? - 23/03/2010 10:40:39 PM 735 Views
Re: Is it actually possible that Moiraine's rescue will not occur in ToM? - 24/03/2010 12:22:31 AM 1137 Views
Thanks. I'm glad I'm not the only one who didn't get how that could be. - 24/03/2010 12:26:07 AM 770 Views
lol - 25/03/2010 05:31:55 PM 792 Views
um, dumb question, but what is MAFO?? *NM* - 24/03/2010 04:19:36 AM 573 Views
Re: um, dumb question, but what is MAFO?? - 24/03/2010 09:12:00 AM 2223 Views
MAFO are not a joke. It's a way to transfer legal responsibly from Brandon to Maria & Harriet too. - 27/03/2010 01:42:53 AM 1976 Views
*sigh* - 27/03/2010 08:47:13 AM 876 Views
Don't suppose you have a link to the Mistborn Q&A, do you? - 24/03/2010 07:35:01 AM 703 Views

Reply to Message