Active Users:1053 Time:13/11/2024 06:48:33 AM
Intuitively obvious, my dear Watson newyorkersedai Send a noteboard - 22/03/2010 01:53:54 AM
http://encyclopaedia-wot.org/main/theories.html#bobs
Bob's theory is an excellent thought process on Asmo's murder. His focus, however, is on the two servants that Rand sees when jumps into Rhavin's throne-room. I simply want to remove the focus on the servants, and instead put it on (a) who the suspects are, and (b) which ones might be "intuitively obvious." I don't even care about picking one out of the four best candidates.

Sammael, Graendal, Slayer, the Gholam, Fain, Mesaana and maybe two others are, as far as I can tell, the only people that could/would have done it. Asmo was extremely shocked to find his attacker, and died with only enough time to get pallid and shout two words.

The DO can't bring Asmo back, and knows of his death in some way, despite the black cord being cut in tSR. The DO either (a) was told by someone/-thing, or (b) will always learn that people are dead, whether or not it's in time to capture their soul.

Balefire (from the One Power) is such a powerful thing that it always seems like it would be noticed by Rand or Aviendha. I include Fain because his location wasn't confirmed and his odd-ass powers (or dagger) might cause Asmo to die irretrievably. And Slayer might have some soul-powers, or might have done something involving Asmo and TaR (maybe killing him and tossing the fresh corpse there would get the soul past the DO?). Luc/Isam seems a better candidate than Fain.

The gholam is also a great candidate for many obvious reasons. All of the prior three make more sense than Mesaana, who I'm simply including because I can't think of a reason to exclude her. I don't know why Bob excludes her in his theory (maybe Jordan said it wasn't her?), so she's still possible.

Sammael and Graendal must (like Moghedien and Rhavin) have known that Rand was going to attack Rhavin the day after the Lanfear mess. Moghedien knew when Rand was attacking, so they would have had a timeline to work with. They are probably the best candidates. Given their inclusion in Rahvin's plans, it would be "intuitively obvious" that one of them did it.

The other two? If Lanfear made her way through the Aelfinn - or even wished him dead - in her original body, she could easily have been spying on Rand at the time. THAT would certainly explain Asmodean's extreme shock and fear. I believe that Lanfear's knowledge got her through the 'Finn more or less fine (trading some of her Power), then she was killed by the Dark and brought back just to teach her a lesson. I love this idea, but the only problem I find is that she wouldn't just attack Rand right after. Given how often she threatened him though, it would be "intuitively obvious" that she did it.

Or, Taim could have done it. The Shadow knew Rand had a dark teacher. It makes sense for them to think to replace Asmo with one of their own. Asmo's knowledge, both of power and darkfriends, would make him a threat to Taim (he's gotta be a DF). Asmo certainly would have done many of the things that Taim conveniently appeared to do (and he knew them already). And once Taim got the chance, I think he was trying to set himself up as a teacher/superior (through his displays of knowledge and usefulness). Given the fact that Taim appeared shortly after Asmo's death and sort of took over Asmo's role, it would be "intuitively obvious" that he did it.
Reply to message
Intuitively obvious, my dear Watson - 22/03/2010 01:53:54 AM 1791 Views
idle speculation != "Intuitivly obvious" - 22/03/2010 03:01:10 AM 559 Views
The best explanation for the "intuitively obvious"-comment is... - 22/03/2010 09:41:32 AM 577 Views
So again...how would Slayer know he was in the hallway? - 22/03/2010 03:18:51 PM 578 Views
I think Slayer spied on Asmo - 22/03/2010 03:45:20 PM 445 Views
Fair enough.... - 22/03/2010 06:25:25 PM 598 Views
I think... - 23/03/2010 09:31:41 AM 514 Views
I agree. Slayer is the most intuitively obvious candidate. *NM* - 22/03/2010 06:29:07 PM 210 Views
Slayer....the book4 minor villian? *NM* - 22/03/2010 06:34:52 PM 354 Views
Slayer actually was a major villian in TSR. - 23/03/2010 09:11:39 AM 408 Views
Re: Slayer actually was a major villian in TSR. - 28/03/2010 07:16:59 PM 445 Views
In my view, Graendal might have sent Slayer, which would explain her knowledge. *NM* - 29/03/2010 09:45:14 AM 447 Views
Actually that's one of my hang-ups about Slayer too - 06/04/2010 02:27:22 PM 424 Views
As far as I'm concerned... - 25/03/2010 06:42:53 AM 436 Views
The problem is that people don't read the books or at least ignore what is said about Slayer... - 25/03/2010 09:41:09 AM 424 Views
Correction... - 25/03/2010 05:22:46 PM 412 Views
So, basically... - 25/03/2010 05:50:42 PM 417 Views
The clues are there? - 25/03/2010 06:29:16 PM 434 Views
Re: The clues are there? - 26/03/2010 12:51:43 AM 401 Views
He wasn't being insulting, I don't think. - 26/03/2010 02:16:26 AM 451 Views
well, RJ was a nuclear engineer. 'Nuff said about obviousness, huh? - 26/03/2010 04:38:00 AM 457 Views
Apparently... - 26/03/2010 08:58:32 AM 428 Views
No it isn't. - 26/03/2010 05:43:02 PM 414 Views
You don't understand... - 27/03/2010 09:11:35 AM 441 Views
Re: You don't understand... - 27/03/2010 05:23:35 PM 445 Views
Re: You don't understand... - 28/03/2010 08:17:40 PM 404 Views
Yes, it's Winter's Heart. - 29/03/2010 04:01:41 AM 417 Views
Both merged into one being - 29/03/2010 09:43:47 AM 454 Views
Not what I asked. - 29/03/2010 06:10:42 PM 397 Views
If he couldn't do this... - 29/03/2010 06:59:16 PM 437 Views
Re: If he couldn't do this... - 29/03/2010 07:46:39 PM 400 Views
That Basel Gill comparison just silly... - 29/03/2010 08:49:19 PM 442 Views
Clearly, one of you has proved that Basel Gill is Demandred *NM* - 29/03/2010 10:12:00 PM 214 Views
I've asked you only one question, repeatedly. - 30/03/2010 12:34:44 AM 480 Views
Yeah, and I repeatedly tried to show you the clues... - 30/03/2010 09:17:59 AM 413 Views
You have never provided anything even resembling evidence. - 30/03/2010 08:20:54 PM 381 Views
Dude - 30/03/2010 09:49:05 PM 370 Views
You know what's really embarrassing? - 30/03/2010 10:28:38 PM 495 Views
be nice *NM* - 31/03/2010 01:22:03 AM 203 Views
One last time... - 31/03/2010 09:18:01 AM 413 Views
Re: One last time... - 31/03/2010 06:20:24 PM 412 Views
No... - 31/03/2010 06:31:57 PM 395 Views
Re: No... - 31/03/2010 11:43:42 PM 440 Views
So... - 01/04/2010 10:22:31 AM 400 Views
Re: So... - 01/04/2010 06:41:34 PM 499 Views
Egwene did it though - 09/04/2010 02:26:10 AM 416 Views
Not before Lord of Chaos she didn't. - 09/04/2010 08:03:12 AM 395 Views
Rand does it in the end of TFoH, though, shortly before Asmo's death. *NM* - 09/04/2010 08:34:23 AM 215 Views
But we don't actually see that - 09/04/2010 12:23:37 PM 401 Views
Hmm. True, that. - 09/04/2010 07:28:15 PM 350 Views
I see what you are saying now - 09/04/2010 12:08:00 PM 368 Views
Yep - 09/04/2010 07:27:27 PM 382 Views
A question on balefire/2 servants - 24/03/2010 04:31:49 PM 367 Views
Re: A question on balefire/2 servants - 24/03/2010 05:03:32 PM 378 Views
First rule of balefire: - 25/03/2010 06:44:17 AM 379 Views
Yep, that's my understanding too. - 25/03/2010 07:00:39 PM 398 Views
On the servants theory - 25/03/2010 11:33:08 AM 374 Views
Rand's odd wounds - 29/03/2010 02:48:58 AM 361 Views
Who says the Dark One couldn't bring Asmodean back? Why would he want to? - 25/03/2010 05:50:55 AM 449 Views
RJ said that. *NM* - 25/03/2010 09:31:32 AM 350 Views
Do you have that quote handy? - 28/03/2010 07:01:06 PM 384 Views
From memory, but can't find the URL - 28/03/2010 08:09:29 PM 369 Views
Here: - 29/03/2010 09:48:36 AM 373 Views
thanks! good job *NM* - 29/03/2010 10:13:12 PM 176 Views
You dont address all the criteria - 30/03/2010 11:27:58 PM 375 Views
Did you mean me? *NM* - 31/03/2010 05:54:56 AM 175 Views
@Fanatic-Templar: Proof Slayer can't travel through T'A'R... - 31/03/2010 03:54:19 AM 376 Views
Exactly my point. - 31/03/2010 05:02:41 AM 386 Views
Maybe none of it matters anyway, Slayer will go down like a punk and I know how it goes - 31/03/2010 05:56:46 AM 423 Views
Lan can swordfight with his boots? *NM* - 31/03/2010 06:41:53 AM 191 Views
I don't think so... read again *NM* - 31/03/2010 10:54:03 PM 168 Views
Re: Maybe none of it matters anyway, Slayer will go down like a punk and I know how it goes - 31/03/2010 03:52:16 PM 398 Views
thanks! but as soon as I posted - 01/04/2010 03:43:59 AM 374 Views
Re: Intuitively obvious, my dear Watson - 14/05/2010 01:28:38 AM 422 Views

Reply to Message