As important as I thought those were, I was smiling broadly when Aviendha identified 6+ communication devices. I assumed they would go into immediate testing/use. I expect them to return because they would be incredibly useful. Those items could increase coordination of attacks and information gathering to great effect.
Militarily speaking, these would be every bit as significant to tactics and strategy as the introduction of gunpowder or Traveling. We've seen other AoL communication techniques already, tho. The call box Sammael used with the Shaido would be quite handy... But Moridin (back when he was the Watcher) notes only three remain, so I guess they might not appear again.
And it seems to be an involved process, and probably not easy to duplicate.There's one technique that I've overlooked for a long time, and I'm surprised I haven't made more of it before now: the Traveling-Chime. If you can't remember, it's what Sammael uses when he visits Graendal in PoD. A gateway forms but doesn't open, and a chime sounds, requesting permission to enter.
It's perfectly interactive, even between saidin and saidar, and doesn't require an open gateway. I think it could be quite handy. In that scene, Graendal gives an "answering chime" in response. I'd like to think that there may be many different chimes that one can respond with. Yet even if no other sounds can be used, two tones can create a nice system of communication. With two sounds (just one may suffice), the system can be used to tell a would-be Traveler that a place is safe or dangerous. It can also be used to indicate *who* is about to appear at a location.
Hell, it can also be used to help find people. Instead of Elayne physically looking in several different locations for Aviendha, she could open gateways to her favorite haunts one after another. She would only go through a gate after Avhiendha replies. Even a simple method like this would add more long-range communication and reconnaissance abilities than our protagonists currently have.
There is also simply using gateways themselves to communicate. Even (or especially) people who are too weak to make a gateway big enough to walk through can utilize it. I cannot imagine that sound is impaired by the size of the gateway it is passing through. Simply set up a communications center, and divide it into sections, each warded against eavesdropping and outside noises, and in each section, open & tie off a tiny gateway to a similar room elsewhere. This way, major locations and centers of power, or even military HQs, can keep in contact with each other. Simply set up such a room in the White Tower, the Stone of Tear, the Royal Palace in Caemlyn, the Sun Palace, the Black Tower, etc. You can simply have a person manning each mini-gate and writing down whatever comes through, or speaking out the messages he is given to relay. Nobles and merchants might even have similar set-ups, as long as someone breaks through the White Tower's abhorrence of doing useful work. If that is too awkward or risky or man-power-intensive a situation, replace it with gate-mail. Set up post offices but with mini-gates large enough to take a letter, that lead to a central hub, where it would be sent through a similar gateway to the appropriate office. Maybe there could be a central hub in each country, with the larger countries broken down into regions, and each regional hub having gateways to a post office in each major town. Larger towns could be broken up with offices in each neighborhood large enough to qualify, or wealthy enough to afford it. Elayne wants to start a "royal post" but why waste time with horsemen and wagons carrying sacks of paper on months-or-weeks-long trips where every mile increases the odds of it getting lost or stolen or destroyed en route? The worst that can happen with the gateway system is getting a letter sliced on the edge, which could be minimized by fitting some sort of wooden or metal frame inside it. It's perfectly interactive, even between saidin and saidar, and doesn't require an open gateway. I think it could be quite handy. In that scene, Graendal gives an "answering chime" in response. I'd like to think that there may be many different chimes that one can respond with. Yet even if no other sounds can be used, two tones can create a nice system of communication. With two sounds (just one may suffice), the system can be used to tell a would-be Traveler that a place is safe or dangerous. It can also be used to indicate *who* is about to appear at a location.
Hell, it can also be used to help find people. Instead of Elayne physically looking in several different locations for Aviendha, she could open gateways to her favorite haunts one after another. She would only go through a gate after Avhiendha replies. Even a simple method like this would add more long-range communication and reconnaissance abilities than our protagonists currently have.
Basically, such a system would run like a post office does now, but without all the vehicles - the steps between a clerk sorting outgoing mail and another one sorting incoming mail would all be eliminated!
The possible fourth is one I'm confused about: Sammael's truce messenger. If you recall, Sammael says he knows the answer because of what happened to the messenger. I never assumed that Sammael was waiting to hear news of the courier from other people. I always felt that whatever Sammael did made "a link" between them. I also assumed that this form of communication was extremely limited; it can only tell Sammael one of two things, either "A" or "B."
You DO know that Sammael was lying, right? He told Graendal that Rand agreed to their truce, when in fact he did no such thing. That means one of two possibilities - Sammael's method is flawed, leaving him to think he had a truce, which must have come as a huge shock when Rand invaded his country, and demonstrating a huge flaw in this method of communication, or else he was simply lying about the system, and it was NOT set up to relay an answer to him - that his presentation was all for show so that Graendal would learn of his offer and believe he made a truce with Rand, and thus submit to Sammael out of fear. So, I don't think this can be assumed to be a genuine technique for communication.
Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
"New" forms of communication may pop up soon in Randland
04/03/2010 11:33:01 PM
- 1113 Views
That was the most implausible scene in all of KoD, if not all of WoT
05/03/2010 11:45:56 AM
- 619 Views
What about using gateways to talk through?
05/03/2010 12:13:24 PM
- 734 Views