Active Users:1012 Time:19/12/2024 06:37:17 AM
Actually the Seanchan advantages go much deeper than that, and it ties in with Rand's "crippling" Cannoli Send a noteboard - 25/02/2010 11:06:30 PM
...and when he does, he cripples himself (like the Seancean battle in PoD) for no reason.
How did he cripple himself? The only thing I can think you are referring to is the small number of troops he took on the campaign with him. Rand's shortcomings and problems on that campaign had nothing to do with insufficient numbers. He didn't take that many troops, because he was moving fast and light. As we see in Perrin's PoV in tGS, size of a group still matters even when you are Traveling, because of the strain on those making and holding open the gateways. Rand was using smaller and mobile forces, operating at distances from one another, complicating coordination and communication. More troops would have just got in the way. As it turned out, even the Seanchan countermove of consolidating their force to prevent Rand from defeating them in detail was checked by Rand's use of Callandor. He not only had a good plan, he had a contingency that worked just fine. The consolidation of the Seanchan forces made them vulnerable to a single-source weapon of great power like Callandor. Rand THINKS he lost because of what he suffered, but unbeknownst to him, he inflicted great damage on the Seanchan, and permanently stopped them from repeating their attempted invasion.

It's still worth noting that it took the combined force of the "Westlands" (man do I hate that name) to throw back just four clans. Rand has ALL of them, less one.
I just say "wetlands." That's the only canonical name given.

Aiel armies are just better than other Westland armies. They move faster, fight harder, and are just in general amazing.

Only problem is that they're mostly used, as you said, as bogeymen- mostly because Rand doesn't want to have humans killing humans when the Last Battle is right around the corner.

Think about it- the Seancean are, while not incompetent, not nearly as superior as they make themselves out to be. They have two advantages- sul'dam and flying creatures- and that's it. Those are big advantages, but if Rand had made a concerted effort to fight back the Seancean with his massive armies of Asha'man and Aiel and the boundless legions of his "regular" armies, he'd have won. And really, the Seancean are the only military threat left for him to worry about now.

(Well, there's the Borderlanders, but that's a weird situation)


Except the Seanchan have vastly superior organization, communication, logistics, standardized procedures and institutional memory. The wetlands lose a Great Captain like Pedron Niall, and they have been dealt a serious blow. The Seanchan lose a Kenner Miraj and they keep right on rolling along. All the organizational things the Seanchan do as a matter of course require great efforts on the wetlander's parts. They might make a massive army, like the invasion force for Illian, but that is a unique undertaking, that required months, had variable quality units, and little or no coordination between the national components. The Seanchan pull that kind of organizational feat off all the time! No wetlander force could have suppressed the news that they had taken a major city like Tanchico. No wetlander army could have come upon a city like Ebou Dar or Amadicia as suddenly and with as much surprise as the Seanchan did. We see that a man of the right rank or authorization can simply walk into a headquarters and take command. A wetlander situation would require tons of what modern military types would call "dick-beating" to settle that out. Contrast Karede's experience in the other general's tent in KoD with Mat's first encounter with the future Band in tFoH. Karede had a much easier time getting what he needed from strangers than Mat did with people who knew exactly who he was and how well connected.
Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
Just how badly does Rand really need the Aiel anyway? - 24/02/2010 03:47:26 PM 1220 Views
I think you've understating Cairhein - 25/02/2010 01:57:12 AM 700 Views
Good point, I guess. But "boogeymen & placeholders" is a long way from "hard core of mighty army" *NM* - 25/02/2010 11:18:50 AM 282 Views
It's just that Rand doesn't do much army stuff any more - 25/02/2010 06:28:39 PM 555 Views
Actually the Seanchan advantages go much deeper than that, and it ties in with Rand's "crippling" - 25/02/2010 11:06:30 PM 751 Views
Reply - 26/02/2010 08:52:18 PM 523 Views
Re: It's just that Rand doesn't do much army stuff any more - 26/02/2010 08:32:35 AM 569 Views
This right here... - 26/02/2010 05:11:00 PM 582 Views
Re: Just how badly does Rand really need the Aiel anyway? - 26/02/2010 05:53:54 PM 545 Views
The Point of the Aiel is yet to come - 01/03/2010 11:50:13 PM 540 Views
Here's hoping, but... - 02/03/2010 12:09:02 PM 541 Views
ouch! *NM* - 02/03/2010 02:14:30 PM 265 Views
Re: Here's hoping, but... - 02/03/2010 04:39:04 PM 545 Views
We have assurances... - 02/03/2010 09:14:47 PM 556 Views

Reply to Message